We need a solution to process international payments that isn't an American fintech company or cryptocurrency and is privacy-respectful like yesterday.

Please 🙏

Edit: By privacy-respectful, I don't mean anonymous. I mean a solution that practices data minimization, and does not share and monetize the data it collects.

@Em0nM4stodon
@Taler is working on it I think?
@fnohe @Taler I have lots of hope for this project 👀
But also, I need something now, and I need something that accepts credit cards.
@Em0nM4stodon @fnohe @Taler how do you expect to accept credit cards *and* preserve privacy?

@hyc Not asking for a passport and biometric data to register would be a good start. Not sharing account information with 345 partners would be a second positive step.

Also I wrote privacy-respectful. I don't mean anonymous.

@Em0nM4stodon and what color wings should we put on the pigs?
@Em0nM4stodon The EU is preparing this. (First levels already in some countries).
@NatureMC Sadly, I am not in the EU. But I'm glad there is work being done there.
@NatureMC @Em0nM4stodon Do you mean Wero?

@rhelune We have 2 different initiatives in the EU:

- Wero, a private-sector initiative by the European Payments Initiative (EPI): https://europeanbusinessmagazine.com/business/europes-24-trillion-breakup-with-visa-and-mastercard-has-begun/

- and the EU-states initiative EuroPA for installing a central bank-backed digital currency usable across the eurozone: https://www.ecb.europa.eu/euro/digital_euro/html/index.en.html

And yes, the first step to become independent of US data-collectors is Wero.

@Em0nM4stodon

Europe vs Visa & Mastercard: The $24 Trillion Payments Shift

Europe is building its own payments system and reducing reliance on Visa and Mastercard. Here’s why the $24 trillion shift matters now.

European Business Magazine

@Em0nM4stodon

Payment, and the banking world in general, are not privacy respecting in any way shape or form.

Your banker knows what you do with your money.

The only privacy respecting system of payment is cash. Period.

And I used to run complex IT systems for banks.

@ParadeGrotesque I don't mean anonymous. Anonymity and privacy are different concepts.

Of course, legal names and transaction information are necessary to collect for legal reasons. But, for example, facial prints aren't, copies of official ID by anyone else who isn't a bank aren't either, sharing this information to monetize it with commercial partners is entirely unnecessarily privacy-invasive.

There are many things that can make a payment processing solution more privacy-respectful, without being anonymous. Data minimization, and strict policies on access and sharing are key here.

@Em0nM4stodon I think what @ParadeGrotesque is trying to say, is that there is no form of digital banking that ensures privacy. This is why the EU has passed many laws to stop banks doing nefarious things with the breadcrumbs that we leave due to our transactions
@webhat @ParadeGrotesque What I mean is a solution that would practice data minimization, protect well the information it has to collect, and would not monetize this information with external partners (everywhere, not just in Europe). This would be privacy-respectful in the payment-processing world, compared to currently available solutions. Nothing will be anonymous, of course.

@Em0nM4stodon

If that's the case, then there are multiple initiatives in Europe to do that.

Wero and the EU commission digital euro are the two that come to mind.

The goal of both is to have Europe controlled digital transactions and money transfer facilities between banks all over Europe.

You can also take a look at things like GIE "Carte Bleue", which is France credit card system. There are similar systems in other European countries, which are US independent.

@webhat

@Em0nM4stodon @GhostOnTheHalfShell And while we’re at it, isn’t prudish about processing payments for adult-oriented businesses.

@Em0nM4stodon Good Luck finding anything at all...

Again: Good luck finding something, because the #US will basically criminalize anything even remotely competing to their " #Quadropoly " of #AMEX, #Visa, #MasterCard & PayPal!

@kkarhan

I am not that negative. I think European systems will take off... Eventually... And provide a limited independence vs the big US 4. Lessons have been learned, the hard way (see ICC blacklisting, etc).

Privacy respecting European systems will be... But only slightly better than US providers.

But, going back to my original argument: cash is king. It's interesting to note that the country most attached to large euros banknotes is Germany.

@Em0nM4stodon @signalapp @techlore

@ParadeGrotesque @Em0nM4stodon I agree, and #Germany restricting #CashPayments to €5k is not only bad amidst the #Greedflation but also absurd.

  • Worse is only the abolishment of the €500 Banknote which I think will be more needed than ever amidst #inflation.
    • Worst is that the #ECB never introduced €2 and €1 banknotes, so millions if not billions of Euros in Coins are stuck overseas as people can't exchange their tips for local currency.
500 euro note - Wikipedia

@kkarhan @ParadeGrotesque That's what I'm saying though. This doesn't exist yet. But there is a great need for it.

@Em0nM4stodon @ParadeGrotesque yeah, I just acknowledge that so far it's extremely unlikely to ever be allowed to exist

  • Cuz there was a system pre- #wero known as #GeldKarte¹ which did a lot but suffered from being strictly #prepaid & #Chip + #PIN only (a #contactless variant known as #girogo was launched but saw even less acceptance & users) , so not even competing with #Pasmo & #Suica on a national comparison. Until then #girocard is the "controlled opposition"
  • #PaySafeCard works great online but I've never heard nor seen of any acceptance in-store ( #retail or #restaurants) and it's limit to €100 (due to " #AML " / " #CTF ") as well as strict #C2B limits (no #C2C transactions possible!) makes it not a replacement of #PayPal.
  • #Monero does work great, but the continued #debanking attacks are #FUD|ding consumers despite it being "the least worst option" currently existing!
Geldkarte - Wikipedia

@Em0nM4stodon not sure where you are located, but us EU citizens in Germany, France and Belgium potentially already have access to WERO, which is a PayPal alternative handled by the partner banks.

It’s not much yet, but it’s a start!

@distractions I'm in Canada, so sadly I won't benefit from this myself. But I'm so glad Europe is working on alternatives! 🙌

@Em0nM4stodon @distractions

Even for domestic payments in Canada, I can't recall ever seeing an online store use the Interac Online protocol that has been around for at least 15 years. I remember setting it up on my company's web store long ago, but soon after that we moved to an online store platform that simply didn't support it.

The closest I've seen is accepting email transfers but that takes a lot of manual processing and requires holding the order in limbo until payment is received.

@Em0nM4stodon I'm in the US and want a different system here. I try not to use PayPal as much as possible. That is the only one I use. I don't use Venmo, Applepay, etc. And I know Venmo is owned by PayPal. I mainly use cash, and I do have a credit union.
@Em0nM4stodon

It's sad that cash in the mail is still the best option in some cases.  That takes forever and, for obvious reasons, has a tendency to go missing.  At least in the U.S., it's guaranteed not to be opened at any point along the way, but as soon as it has to cross a border, it might be.  Also, not everyone's honest, especially when said opportunity involves cash.

@plutarch
Sending cash in the mail is illegal in France 😬 (probably elsewhere as well)

@Em0nM4stodon

@Em0nM4stodon It's needed, not just to avoid feeding the fintech beast, but to avoid retaliation if you stand up to the Israeli regime and its support by the USA.
Eg judges and others on the International Criminal Court have lost access to critical financial services for daring to lay charges against Netenyahu.
https://apnews.com/article/international-court-sanctions-trump-icc-hague-4cdefe4de067432f6cdb9b137908c463

#ICC #gaza

US sanctions bring uncertainty to the lives of International Criminal Court judges and prosecutors

International Criminal Court judges and prosecutors are trying to live and work under the same financial and travel restrictions brought against Russian President Vladimir Putin and Osama bin Laden. Six judges, the chief prosecutor and two other staff members have been sanctioned by U.S. President Donald Trump for pursuing investigations into officials from the U.S. and Israel. Typically reserved for autocrats, crime bosses and the like, the sanctions can be devastating. They prevent the ICC officials and their families from entering the United States and have extended to the minutiae of their everyday lives. Despite what one judge described as the “small annoyances” caused by the sanctions, they told The Associated Press that they remain steadfast in their work.

AP News

@Em0nM4stodon Francesca Albanese has also been sanctioned by American fintech for telling the truth about what Israel is doing in Gaza.
https://www.ynetnews.com/article/rjwbji7z11l

#Israel #gaza #FrancescaAlbenese

UN rapporteur Francesca Albanese says US sanctions have left her 'financially censored'

Albanese says sanctions now prevent her from banking, receiving payments or entering the US, as criticism intensifies in Italy over her rhetoric on Israel and her remarks after a violent newsroom raid

ynetglobal

@Em0nM4stodon BRICS is supposed to be the rival system to US dollar.

Although, BRICS is in disarray since the Iran war kicked off, mostly due to India backstabbing other key member states.

@Em0nM4stodon I like Mollie (Dutch psp, supports multi currency and many methods including cc of course)
I think this a lot.
A non profit payment system would be SO EMPOWERING.
Kinda like activitypub vs. corporate media.
I am pretty sure a sign of how empowering it would be
is how much western governments would fight it.

@Em0nM4stodon That is illegal.

America has pushed AML laws on everyone. And I mean EVERYONE. Like, even Switzerland has no more banking anonymity.

Cryptocurrency was... well, an attempt, but, governments caught on too.

@Em0nM4stodon

what would be the purpose of a "privacy-respectful" payment system that isn't anonymous?

@gracie @Em0nM4stodon The point is that a lot of companies involved in transactions today sell information about the transactions they process to hundreds of companies unrelated to the transactions. This started as a way to slightly cut the fees charged to merchants so as to undercut competitors, but now it’s just a common business practice.

Full anonymity would be nice, but it’s possible to be better than the nightmare we have today without it.

@Em0nM4stodon two genuine questions:

1. What's the issue with something like Monero/cryptocurrency in general?

2. If you do need something involves a debit/credit card, would you not be looking for a SECURE platform instead of a PRIVATE one? Nothing about that system is privacy-respecting, the best you could hope for is a more secure solution that only cooperates with some data requests.

@Em0nM4stodon

Don't know if privacy-respecting but aren't these non-US payment systems?

JCB (Japan Credit Bureau)
UnionPay (China)
Alipay (China) via QR code
WeChat Pay (China) via QR code

@Em0nM4stodon well, the explanation of my father in law for one method: you needed to send some money to a relative in China, so you go to a jewelry store and give them money. They'd have a corresponding jewelry store in China that would release a corresponding amount to your relative. Alternatively, you want to get some money out of China, you'll do something similar. Each store has a balance sheet. At the end of the month, someone would fly to China "wearing" the balance in diamonds or returning wearing diamonds they didn't have when they didn't have in the first place.

How's that for low tech :)