SukainaWritesBook Review: Death Comes To Matheran by Shabnam Minwalla
Tara and Sameer lost their father in an accident 11 years ago. After living through several difficult circumstances over the years, they return to their high-end area of El Camino in Mumbai from Oxel, Goa. The Jhaveris belonged to the rich and affluent — the kind of people nobody could touch, the ones who dined in the same restaurants as famous movie stars.
As the story begins, Tara and Sameer book an Airbnb in Mumbai after being invited by Pramila’s brother-in-law, Nimesh, to get their family wealth in order while the family feud remains divided into two sides. As the story moves ahead, more secrets unfold and the intentions of several characters are revealed.
A few pages in, we notice a change in formatting and design as letters and transcripts enter the storyline. The only giveaway is that they are specially written and saved for Sameer and Tara Jhaveri.
Then begins the puzzle of the Matheran accident — or was it really one? Tara was too young to understand, while Sameer is haunted by memories of losing two parents: one to death and one to memory. As their mother, Pramila, slowly starts recovering, things are no longer the same in El Camino. Throughout the story, we are introduced to several characters through conversations, phone calls, and passing moments.
In this book, Shabnam Minwalla makes the reader aware that somebody was collecting information. Somebody was gathering evidence. Somebody else, like Tara Jhaveri, wanted answers about what exactly happened on the fateful night when their father lost his life.
The beauty of the book lies in everything happening between the lines — the cracks, the hidden tensions, and the layered characters. Every character is written with finesse, and the reader constantly keeps guessing who is responsible and who is hiding secrets.
As Tara Jhaveri returns to her world in Mumbai and feels left out, the author introduces us to the affluent, the rich, and people living in a bubble. Shabnam Minwalla captures the behaviour of the well-off extremely well, especially their inner circles and the dynamics among young adults. Many readers may recognise behaviours similar to those in their own social circles, and the little nuggets Minwalla leaves in certain situations speak volumes about the elite.
The book does not end with a happily-ever-after. The world demands proof and evidence, and that is exactly what Shabnam Minwalla succeeds in portraying.
Aside from solving a crime, the author also dives into the relationship between a daughter and her mother, along with the emotional realities of being 17 years old.
The book becomes even more interesting because of the characters’ development and the realisations that slowly dawn upon them.
Towards the climax, the book becomes a tad theatrical, but it definitely grabs your attention again.
Shabnam Minwalla likes to tie things together well and does not leave behind invisible details.
That is exactly why the author remains on my auto-buy list. Thanks to HarperCollins for the media copy.
#aboutBooks #blog2026 #bloggerOfIndia #bloggerReview #bloggingCommunity #bookBlog #bookBlogger #bookCommunity #bookLovers #bookRecommendation #bookReview #bookReviewers #bookReviews #bookish #Books #deathComesToMatheran #elite #family #fiction #HarperCollinsIndia #May2026 #mayBlogPost #mediaCopy #mystery #Reading #shabnamMinwalla #sukainaWrites #theNightReader #thriller #youngAdult
Rich Rubin
Sarah Avery
Minnie Lahongrais
Humphrey Archer