Because mastodon is like a 99% male audience, I will say this: if you have an aging mother you are in relationship with and care about, do NOT make her go through medical stuff alone. I am skilled & mean enough to fight through medical stuff and even so you would not believe how bad it is. Just accept that you cannot imagine.

I talk to a lot of people's aging moms and they are abandoned & alone even in nice families. I don't care how awkward it is, you have to try to ask them about it.

Our moms are suffering because no one cares and they aren't telling anyone. They're getting diagnoses 15 years late, they're being bullied about medications, they're silent about what they're going through.

The difference between the younger women and the older women in the patient groups I'm in is horrific. I have listened to many, many people's moms describe years of suffering that could've been prevented. I am not trying to lay on any guilt. I'm just saying a little bit could go a long way.

It doesn't have to be this way. I have helped multiple older women argue to get past primary care and get to specialists and learn that there is better science than decades ago, that has studied more women, but there's only one of me in these chats. You can't fix the system but if you have an older woman in your life you can ask if you can research something for them, or go to an appointment and make sure they're heard, or suggest the random pains they have are a thing that needs attention.
@grimalkina I once saw a post that I think about a lot, something like: all of womenโ€™s medicine is like โ€œwe know this thing about your body is 100% true because we did one study 70 years ago. They studied one rat. The rat was male.โ€
@joby @grimalkina Opinion: So many that work in medicine do it to make a living not to care for people. It's a job. Nothing in the system encourages excellence so care givers eventually give in to the system. Thank you to advocates, care givers and and administrators that find the energy to resist. We learn to Advocate as our older family members slowly die and we try to support them. So confusing, so tiring, so much ignorance and indifference. And, we are next.
@grimalkina I helped my mom at appointments and noticed too that I was taken much more seriously if I dressed up/ dressed professional, not casually. Annoying that it matters, but it definitely did. Also had to continually redirect the conversation back to her, so she would be taken seriously and not ignored or talked around. This takes work.
@grimalkina May I ask about which country you speak?
@NatureMC no you may not. I have family in multiple countries and this is a theme across all of them. I think you are capable of generalizing from one person's narrative in a specific context and adapting it to your own.

@grimalkina That's ok! ๐Ÿ‘ Your answer shows me that it doesn't seem to be a problem of one country only despite the very different health care systems in the world.

(I first read your post connected to a certain health care system.)

@grimalkina Not just moms. My wife is 71 (seven years older than me), and there's a reason she still spends all day every day in the garden doing heavy stuff, and walks for miles with her friend, and our love life is even better than it was when she was 40: we've both fought to get her the right medical care instead of letting them let her get "old." Hips, heart, hearing, hormones. Next up: cataracts, and then she'll see better than she did at 20!

@msbellows โ™ฅ๏ธ๐Ÿ’œ๐Ÿ’š๐Ÿ’›๐ŸŒž

Playing in mud is good for us!!!!

If I were there I would sing Rick Charette's song, "I Love Mud" to her-

Chorus:

"Mud, mud, I love mud!
I'm absolutely, positively wild about mud.
I can't go around it. I've got to go through it.

Beautiful, fabulous, super duper mud."

@grimalkina

@BrambleBearSnoring @grimalkina Oh, that is superb. I'm finding that and playing it at an opportune time. Thank you!

@msbellows @grimalkina

I have loved that song for decades, and sing the chorus at every opportunity. Your post reminds me there are probably mud puddles waiting for me at the dump. They often have cool rocks hiding on them.

Mud luscious and puddle wonderful-what is that from???? Yhink, think, think

[in Just-]

in Just- spring          when the world is mud- luscious the little lame balloonman whistles          far          and wee and eddieandbill come runningโ€ฆ

The Poetry Foundation
@BrambleBearSnoring @grimalkina You're my new favorite person here.
@msbellows ๐Ÿ˜๐Ÿ’š๐ŸŒž๐ŸŒป@grimalkina
@grimalkina I'm interested in hearing what you have to say, but you have to make it clearer because this is a topic many have absolutely zero knowledge about. We need examples, steps to take, and advice. You really need to spell it out. Talking with your aging parents is not easy. Autonomy, shame and ego are all mixed up in there. There is history on top of that. So can you give us a head start? In fact, a dedicated podcast episode would rock. Something one could also share with relatives.

@bitecode who do you think I am, John Green?? Where am I getting the money and time to make all of that on top of all the free labor I am already doing? This is literally a call to action for other people to do more BECAUSE I am already at the absolute limits of how much I can help with this.

I don't mind respectful content requests, but telling me "you have to do x" and "you need x" is NOT it.

@grimalkina I see. You seem to be going through hard times. I'll make sure you don't hear from me again.

@grimalkina
Yep, good thread.

26 years ago I moved my parents from their home 200 miles away into the 'granny flat' I set for them on the ground floor of my home. I moved them while they were still well enough to make the move and resettle, and progressively provided more and more care for them over the years.
Dad died a couple of years ago, and now I am just caring for Mum.
We take her to her appointments, my wife drives, I take Mum in and sit through the consultations with her. I make sure she has meds and support, personal as well as medical.
Mum is 93 now and still going strong. We are planning a move to rural Wales and will take Mum with us. I will probably still be caring for her when I am 70.

I am also still working, employed part time, self employed, and a volunteer.

@grimalkina And they're already starting with the 'many doctors simply don't listen to what women tell them' handicap. :/
@tankgrrl @grimalkina There is a current tiktok/IG scandal, in which a cute male med student thought that making videos making fun of patients, especially women, was somehow "funny" and great content. Called out by SO many doctors, which showed another issue. Women doctors were accused of "not being able to take a joke," whereas men doctors were praised for encouraging professionalism. A male doctor pointed out: if women doctors were faced with that, imagine what female patients go through.

@tankgrrl @grimalkina The med student, BTW, is apparently a 4th yr student and has subsequently deleted his accounts. He got all that way being sexist and insensitive. Something is very wrong with their training.

Based on his content, he looks to be a doctor with a future sexual misconduct charge. I hope whatever action Mayo Clinic is taking addresses this.

@CStamp @grimalkina

*sigh*

We should have left the age of 'hysteria' behind 150 years ago.

@tankgrrl @grimalkina Yep. And someone studying at the Mayo Clinic? He made them look really bad.

@grimalkina Even if you are a former medic (mum was a nurse) having company for medical care is invaluable. I attended appointments with my mum when she lost some hearing at 63 (she was a teacher of the deaf at the time) and recently happened to be visiting when she got a nasty UTI.

My Dr stepdad benefitted from my mum's support when he got ill in the weeks before his sudden death. Urology said they rarely received a fully-hydrated patient after a day in A&E... Mum had bullied Stepdad to drink!

@grimalkina my first instinct here was to yes-and a suggestion folks offer such support for younger women in their lives, too, given the differences in care I've seen when family, especially male family, just show up. Then I was suddenly hit by the realization I am old enough to be that parent of adult nerds on this very platform. Oh no.
@worldsworstgoth oh I completely I agree I just think, cynically, it's much harder to get older men to care about anything here so the selection of a set of identities was to optimize the potential for compassion and privilege to exist together there
@grimalkina Hitting a nerve. BTDT for my mother.

@grimalkina

Thanks for offering thoughtful observations and kind advice on this important topic.

This is relevant to aging spouses as well as mothers. It's all too easy, and common, to assume that, if we aren't hearing requests for help, none is needed.

@grimalkina My mother is 79 years old and a retired RN. She is the type of person that refuses to share any information with her children, especially medical and financial information, and she gets very defensive if you ask.
@[email protected] obviously this is something people should interpret for their own context, jesus fucking christ.

@gcvsa

Yeah, that is so hard. We have one of those in our family. I just keep pointing out that itโ€™s impossible for anyone to keep track of everything in the moment at appointments, and itโ€™s really helpful to have another set of ears to take notes. Also, in an emergency, itโ€™s great to have someone who already knows something about your medical history. Or where to look for all the financial and legal stuff!

@grimalkina and donโ€™t put that caregiving burden only on the women in the family. Often only one woman. Caregiving often kills the caregiver first.

Describing the situation in one particular country in a toot in international Fediverse without ever mentioning which country's situation that toot refers to: In my experience, that's mostly done by toot authors from the USA. Here, too?

I briefly tried to determine country of origin from the various resources linked from @grimalkina 's profile, but failed. (No impressum, so she's highly unlikely to be a European author.)

@dj3ei @grimalkina mothers in germany get a bit more if their sons intervene. Every bit helps. Tested for you.

Fathers, too. Which is what I tested.

Mothers probably even worse, I have no reason not to believe.

@dg3hda @grimalkina

@dj3ei

I am summarizing over experiences and conversations I've had with European women in these patient communities, Canadian women, AND women in South America and US, so I felt comfortable speaking about this as a shared issue across many systems. I have family in the UK, EU, Canada, US. My main patient chat represents all those regions and 10+ countries.

Don't EVER speak about my labor on women's health in this objectifying, dismissing, asshole reply guy way again.

Yes, @grimalkina! I'm Canadian, we have social healthcare unlike many in the US, and still I heartily endorse this message. I've also dealt with the German healthcare system (even more baffling than here).

The difficulty is not just with healthcare systems, but mysogyny, disrespect of the elderly, failure to listen, bullying ... and these can and do go on everywhere. ๐Ÿ‘

@dj3ei

@deborahh @grimalkina @dj3ei I routinely help my elderly mother navigate these issues in Europe.
If thereโ€™s a blind spot in this thread, itโ€™s not American centralism, itโ€™s exactly the misogyny that was originally pointed out.
@MostlyBlindGamer @dj3ei yes. Not sure if my reply was in the right part of the thread: @grimalkina was speaking generally, and I was refuting the reply guy who wanted to narrow the topic based on her geographical location.

I'm happy I called the original toot "good stuff" all along. Incidentally, I still do.

I made the mistake thinking this reflects on the USA system only. (I've heard bad things about the USA's medical system.) I was honestly mistaken, had no intention to narrow or weaken.

And I made the even bigger mistake of just grumbling, instead of simply asking, as @sennoma correctly pointed out.

I do apologize for both these mistakes.

@deborahh @MostlyBlindGamer @grimalkina

@MostlyBlindGamer @grimalkina @dj3ei as I fight my way to the help I need (me, a stubborn woman, with a lifetime's experience of fighting with doctors), I am constantly aware of how many women must get left in the dust, un-helped - because they don't have language to push back, or are too polite, or don't know where the loopholes are, or are simply too exhausted to continue.

When it comes to doctors: it needs a good BS detector, research skills, courage to say NO. Sick folks may need a helper.

Thanks for making the international scope of your original toot transparent!

I underestimated the scope of your work. Please kindly accept my apologies!

@grimalkina

@dj3ei Talking ABOUT a fediverse comrade without talking TO them makes you seem dismissive and condescending. You could've simply asked @grimalkina whether her observations were specific to any particular country.
@grimalkina I was 27 when this problem abruptly went away... I wish I'd been better positioned to help her more but as it is, I was already her primary caretaker and doing my best.
@gooba42 I am sure you did all that you could.
@grimalkina
Have a list of your elder's questions. And carry a clipboard to write all the answers down!

@grimalkina
I take my mother to all of her medical appointments and take full notes. I manage her pills. I visit her every Sunday with my son, bring her food, get her to eat, and spend hours with her.

And that despite the fact that she abused the hell out of me as a child, and did a lot of permanent damage.

@Quasit @grimalkina
this is what comes to mind for me. many people's parents are abusive and i can't blame them for going no contact or not going into debt to give them medical care

it's cool that you made it work though

@grimalkina

i've been dealing with my mom's medical and financial stuff for a few years now. it's insane. the US medical industry and financial institutions really do seem to want the elderly to just die but give them all their money first.

my sister and i tag team being on the phone when she's at the doctor's and we both review all visit reports and talk to the doctors and insurance as necessary.

i truly pity elderly folks that don't have someone to assist them with all this, someone fully in their corner.

@grimalkina
The level of gaslighting in healthcare has risen 10,000% (my scientific opinion) over the last decades and 99% of it is directed at women.
And it goes like this:
Your problem is
1) a natural part of aging
2) a natural part of being a woman
3) all in your imagination!
4) you are drug/attention seeking
5) any combination of the above.
Yes! your mum and other women in your lives need support at doctor appointments - the more serious the issue the more critical support is.

@Petesmom @grimalkina
First you are too young to be sick, then too hormonal in your teens, then too far or skinny or something, definitelly hysterical, then again hormonal in your menopause years, and then you lack the hormones until you die. Did I get it right?

I of course personally just left the l train that track was leading to (I am a trans person) and have noticed how concerningly better I am treated by doctors (unless they learn I am trans). Something about being more male-presenting...

@grimalkina @MostlyTato 99% male audience? Thatโ€™s not been my experience
@treleanor @grimalkina
Not mine either, now you mention it.
@MostlyTato @treleanor @grimalkina It doesn't feel like my experience of interacting, but it prompted me to run through my followers list and make a quick estimate. In the most recent ~250, of the ones that I was able to easily guess a gender for (maybe 150), I had about +60 male. That would be around 70%, and maybe more than 80% depending on the ones I didn't attempt to guess or guessed wrong. This is kinda surprising but not surprising.