My reservations and criticism re: #Signal are not just valid, but the reality is even worse than I thought:

  • The fact that @signalapp requires not only their shitty #Android #App, and a #PhoneNumber but literally won't allow people to use their shitty #Desktop-App unless they have an Android device with a camera pointed at it makes it utterly unuseable for certain users who don't have a fucking #camera in their Android

Seriously, do they expect folks to deal with that shit?

FIX THAT SHIT, @Mer__edith, and if it means you need to kick some devs in their crouch then consider this a necessary "investment"

#sarcasm #TechSupport #TapesFromTechSupport #Enshittifucation #SignalSucks #TelegramSucks #Messengers

Kevin Karhan :verified: (@kkarhan@infosec.space)

Content warning: Rant re: Signal Shills being dangerous Tech Illiterates

Infosec.Space

Anyone who expects me to install yet another app for their garbage can kindly fuck off!

  • Fix your shit and give me a compelling reason to even consider making an account in the first place.

I won't but seeing folks who actually take privacy serious and thus have their #cameras removed from their #Android device struggle makes me fucking angry.

Personally, I wished @delta / #deltaChat had a plugin for like @thunderbird / #Thunderbird so that it can be used as #Chat in it and sort the inbox. Would make it the superior solution for #corporations that already have #eMail #Archival setup for legal compliance…

Kevin Karhan :verified: (@kkarhan@infosec.space)

One thing that really pisses me off personally is the #regression in terms of #Messenger #Apps. My personal distaste and dislike for #proprietary, #SingleVendor & #SingleProvider #services like #Signal [¹](https://infosec.space/@kkarhan/114234551915193036) [²](https://infosec.space/@kkarhan/114935952643402592), #Telegram, #Discord [³](https://infosec.space/@kkarhan/114865723904157014) [⁴](https://social.treehouse.systems/@krutonium/115157611977216372), #WhatsApp [5](https://infosec.space/@kkarhan/114873895410403238), #Slack, #MicrosoftTeams, etc. aside: - *WHY* is there no #CrossProvider #Messenger to handle that shite? - *WHY* does everyone of these shitty providers think people want to download their #bloated #WebApp that takes up triple digit Megabytes if not entire Gigabytes and will gobble up all the #RAM and #CPU each of them can?? This problem ain't new and *already got [solved for corporate social media](https://infosec.space/@kkarhan/114862619013462466) ages ago!* (Not to mention actually good messengers!) - And no, [bridges](https://toots.ch/@dalai/114862754556459439) *[don't](https://swecyb.com/@troed/114862774972645542) count*! - I mean `API 0` - [style](https://digipres.club/@foone/112685423773959519) access because obviously [none of the platforms](https://digipres.club/@foone/112685414638522984) will *allow, endorse or support such an endeavour* and [*actively fight the developers and users*](https://digipres.club/@foone/112685441496803574) ! So yeah, consider this a call for a @gajim@fosstodon.org / #Gajim or @pidgin@fosstodon.org / #Pidgin *for garbage platforms!* - Cuz back in the day we had *way worse messengers* yet people actually made #AIM, #ICQ, #MSN, #QQ, #IRC & #XMPP work just fine from one single *"phat" client*! - Can we please get that back? Cuz #WastefulComputing pisses me off! #api0 #Enshittification

Infosec.Space

Also why doesn't @signalapp / #Signal just accept a #screenshot of said #QRcode as a means to authenticate?

  • Seriously, there's no valid reason they can't do it like #Telegram and just send a message in-app to ask:

"Do you want to add/authenticate [instert device name here] at [IP Address]? Here's a unique pairing code to enshure that's correct!"

Like the #UX is worse than early versions of #OTR on #Pidgin back in those days...

@kkarhan @signalapp I think telegram Is just a dumpster fire these days. They're less secure Then all the other encryption apps at least when it comes to the encryption algorithms.

@adisonverlice ALL #SingleVendor, #SingleProvider #Messengers that are #proprietary by virtue of not having everything #FLOSS'd are inherently bad.

If that shit was actually secure, it would've been abused so hard that she'd be in jail for refusing to comply with #CloudAct and duely issued warrants as well as being complicit in the "abuse" of said platform.

thaddeus e. grugq on Twitter

“I’m gonna tell you a secret about “logless VPNs” — they don’t exist. Noone is going to risk jail for your $5/mo https://t.co/Q2aOQJkG4g”

Twitter
@kkarhan @signalapp @Mer__edith Yeah. Makes me Want to know why exactly The trump administration used signal for classified documents. In fact I actually have a memo from the defense digital service which tells DOD people *not* to use Signal for classified documents. If you want it I can give it to you it's public.

@adisonverlice worse even is that they didn't just use @signalapp but a shady #3rd party client so in this case it's NOT @Mer__edith et. al. who are to blame, but the folks that REFUSED TO ENFORCE #ITsec & #ComSec!

  • Cuz there's a reason they got hired and paid to say "no" and why there's a full suite of dedicaded, applianced hardware for any sensituve comms!

But then again #AgentKrasnov is an #InfoSec, #OpSec & #NatSec nightmare!

@kkarhan @signalapp @Mer__edith Yeah. And tell me if I'm wrong because I could well be, you seem to know more than I do in terms of signal, but hasn't their protocol and their server code or whatever been out of date for a while? Again tell me if I'm wrong.
@adisonverlice I think the (released) open source server code was outdated for some time, however right now it seems to be pretty up-to-date: https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Server
@kkarhan @signalapp @Mer__edith
GitHub - signalapp/Signal-Server: Server supporting the Signal Private Messenger applications on Android, Desktop, and iOS

Server supporting the Signal Private Messenger applications on Android, Desktop, and iOS - signalapp/Signal-Server

GitHub
@nick @kkarhan @signalapp @Mer__edith But here's the question you really should be asking. Do you trust signals code? Because they've showed many times that they really can't be trusted. Are they reliable no. Just because you can host your own server doesn't mean that it's good, nor does it repair its already tarnished reputation. Keep in mind that servers still contains metadata. And that means you can reply, reply, comply with KYC laws.