I talk about cops online, and I have cops hate-following me through their puppet accounts. Sometimes, they reply or DM me.๐Ÿคท๐Ÿฟโ€โ™‚๏ธ

I talk about GOP politicians, and I have them too. Hi!

I talk about VC bros. So many fleece vests!

For the most part, people are surprisingly reasonable. I'll rant about 10 things, and they'll reply "Mostly fair. But 9 is wrong."

But the 2 things get me the most push back:
* Holding white women accountable for their own actions.
* Advocating for Black women at all.

1/N

The flip side of "presumption of guilt" when talking about Black men, is "presumption of innocence" when talking about white women.

They're both forms of racism. They both harm Black people.

One is easy to recognise *in other people.* One is hard to see *in ourselves.*

Some people have an emotional reaction when I point out that more than half of all white women voters in the US reliably vote for whichever candidate promises to harm Black people more. They get mad at me for saying this!

2/N

The US is a very racist country. It has racist systems, processes, and outcomes. That racism harms all of us, but disproportionately harms Black people.

If you want to reduce that racism, you have to understand where it's coming from.

Almost half of that racism, comes from white women. Some of the rest of it comes from white men, but is done in the name of white women.

You cannot effectively combat racism, if you don't understand and accept this.

3/N

As a Black dude, I gotta say that the dynamic I see is super weird:

1) ~50% of all white men I interact with are super open-minded and inclusive! They want less racism. โ™ฅ๏ธ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿฟ

2) ~50% of all white women I interact with are super open-minded and inclusive! They want less racism. โ™ฅ๏ธ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿฟ

3) ~50% of the white men and ~50% of the white women that I interact with are... not super open-minded.

But both the good white men and white women I interact with, are convinced that 3) is 95% men?๐Ÿคท๐Ÿฟโ€โ™‚๏ธ

4/N

And it's not like ~95% of the white people in New York are open-minded, and ~95% of the white people in Atlanta are not open-minded. That's not how it works.

It's ~50% of the white people in New York are super open-minded, and ~50% aren't.

And it's ~50% of the white people in Atlanta are super open-minded, and ~50% aren't.

And it's not like "this whole family is open-minded, and this whole family is not open-minded." That's not how it works. It's "most families have both."

5/N

It's super weird to me that it seems like half of the white folk in this country, literally cannot see the other half, even though that's their coworkers, family members, friends, and partners. ๐Ÿ™‚๐Ÿ™ƒ

It got me thinking: What evidence could you show to the 50% of white folk that are more open-minded, to convince them that the other 50% exists and is about half women? That Black folk are not making this up?

Poll data, viral Karen videos, and lived experience of ~40M Black folk, isn't doing it.

6/N

Then I remembered, that "evidence does not persuade." So there is no evidence that I could possibly show to convince the 50% of white folk that are super open-minded, that close to half of the other 50% of white folk that are less open-minded, are women. ๐Ÿคท๐Ÿฟโ€โ™‚๏ธ

7/7

@mekkaokereke
If you have evidence, present it, and they are not persuaded, then are they really open-minded?

@rgulick @mekkaokereke

People are not collations of logic; they are a run on sentence of the fanfic stories of the things they've heard that flow into what they already know.

Resisting going with your own mental flow takes work. You've got to rewind, rewrite whole chapters of the story, make it all make sense.

Yes, a lot of it is protecting one's own ego, especially if it's become a life totem, but it's a lot of self-introspection-aversion too.

@rgulick @mekkaokereke

That's what I'm thinking as well. You say "50% of white people are open minded" WTF?

Now, I don't live in the US, maybe you guys are aliens or something. But I cannot understand from where you got that percentage. This comes both from my day to day physical life and my day to day internet life. People are fucking stupid in most cases (and I will voluntarily not explicitly exclude myself from this).

Why Facts Don't Change Minds (But Stories Do)

YouTube
@mekkaokereke watching my step sister go down the right wing rabbit hole was educational (and sad). But it's easy for me to pin that on "yeah, but she's always been an idiot" and not generalize it as much as it probably deserves.
@mekkaokereke The problem is that too many of us open-minded white people conflate the identity of the not-open-minded white women with that of their not-open-minded white husbands/boyfriends/partners. Itโ€™s like the misogyny subsumes the racism.
@ksmoker @mekkaokereke And white women HIDE behind that misogyny. They know exactly how to deflect from their own racism. Never believe a white woman who says she โ€œhasโ€ to obey her husband. I was raised in that culture and they asked me to leave pretty damn quick. Lol

@mekkaokereke Oh fuck yeah there's racist white women out there, and lots of 'em.

Both in the US and down here.

Often, the bigots are hiding in plain sight.

As in, there's a stereotype of what a racist looks like. The shaved head, the MAGA hat, the fascist tatts, the white robe...

Yet many racists are perfectly pleasant to other white people. They're normal looking, everyday white people.

They're quite reasonable in white company, as long as no-one mentions race.

They often genuinely don't think of themselves as racist.

They even mouth the right platitudes at the right times.

It's just (and these are actual examples I've come across)...

The woman from Columbia is the most qualified candidate, but they have concerns about hiring her because of her accent.

They're celebrating International Women's Day, and every single woman in the video is white.

They couldn't find any non-white women to speak at their charity fundraising event.

They pull aside a South Asian woman, and tell her they had an Indian colleague at work who complained about racism in Australia, "and I told her if you don't like it, leave".

Someone mentions the Jews, and they start sharing what they really think.

Or they get angry at someone who's not white, and they morph from Bruce Banner into the Incredible Hulking White Supremacist. (1/2)

@mekkaokereke Here's the crucial thing about the type of racist white person I've just described.

If you're white, and you don't discuss race, then it's entirely possible for you to not even notice that you're in the company of a racist.

And if you're oblivious to many such people, then it's entirely possible (if you're white) to grossly underestimate how prevalent white women like that are.

Because chances are there are many in your workplace, or your social circle, or your family, and you're completely unaware of it.

(And I speak from experience on that last point: There were a few in my life who didn't make themselves known until I started dating my current partner. So I'm definitely not immune to the underestimating!)

Remember: Not all racists wear MAGA hats. (2/2)

@ajsadauskas @mekkaokereke > If you're white, and you don't discuss race, then it's entirely possible for you to not even notice that you're in the company of a racist.

This right here!

@steve @ajsadauskas @mekkaokereke the issue I have run into is that discussing race with white people will almost always show they're racists who refuse to admit it's possible.

Having been in rooms full of only white men means I have seen how people act when they are comfortable. Many go along with the edgy jokes to stay in the favor of the obnoxious ones. Calling it out gets you ostracized as "one of those".

Maintaining employment is a constant balance of only saying just enough. It sucks

@ATLeagle @steve @ajsadauskas @mekkaokereke It's stories like these that remind me that I am so privileged that in my nearly 20 year IT career, I have never once been in a room full of only white men.

I work for a major multinational whose US head openly used words like "critical race theory" positively, in a way that showed he actually knew what he was talking about.

@mdm @steve @ajsadauskas @mekkaokereke my current position is somewhat like this, but being in Georgia means that I am still surrounded by bad actors. They are getting more vocal in their little circles as the election rhetoric ramps up.

I am avoiding being on site as much as possible because of this.

@ATLeagle @steve @ajsadauskas @mekkaokereke I hear you. Had a similar revelation this weekend with co-workers. And I am white
@steve @ajsadauskas @mekkaokereke
If you're white AND not in the company of a black person of the opposite sex.
@ajsadauskas @mekkaokereke really great point and one that might also partially explains white people not seeing racist behavior in online places. Not that this is an excuse to deny the experience of black and other nonwhite people
@ajsadauskas @mekkaokereke Yeah this. There's definitely a confluence of circumstance that made me more (much, much more) likely to be in contexts, and having the kinds of conversations, where prejudices show up, around men rather than women. And that distorted my perception for a very long time. If I'd applied actual logic at any point, my cognitive dissonance would have become clear.

@ajsadauskas in Canada too. Racist, Ignorant, and completely certain their POV is merited and just.

Unable to listen to opposing POVs to their own which grants them a presumption of superiority and authority, though like LLMs were fed with bias. They get angry & vengeful when they have to reexamine their biases & solutions that refuse to contain the whole.

They spew the same racist and biased nonsense with so much confidence. The confidence of an LLM.

@ajsadauskas @mekkaokereke Ian Daskin at Innuendo Studios calls the racists who take advantage of the stereotype/perception "the gentrification of white nationalism."

@mekkaokereke

the most depressing feature on mastodon:

yelling at black people to fix problems white people gave us

i'm a white dude

i have anger at where our country is

and i'm going to yell at the white ignorant indecent bigots who got us here about that (often off mastodon)

i'm not going to condescend and patronize black folk here and lecture them how to fix problems... that a bunch of white racists gave us

if you do this and you're white: please check yourself

@mekkaokereke

Is this not what the race-class narrative is all about?

People, mostly white, but far from entirely, believe all manner of things about Black and brown people that are not true because they've heard them repeated over and over again, the decades of dog-whistles that the current bat-shit crazy version of the GOP and the regressive-right media ecosystem that sustains it have turned into blaring sirens.

Race-class narrative stories and messages cut through the false beliefs and ...

@mekkaokereke

replaces them with positive imagery of commonality of needs, desires and opportunities.

Of course for this to work requires lots and lots of repetition over a period of time. The challenge is to get many, many more of us using RCN themes and structures in our day to day interactions.

Making RCN ubiquitous for us isn't sufficient to eliminate racism, racist structures still need to be dismantled, but I think it's a critical path element needed to be able to do that.

@mekkaokereke I probably keep to myself more than I ought to? I don't engage strangers, open minded or otherwise, so *everything* passes under my radar unless it's super blatant.

I'm also pretty well convinced that here in SW MO I'm surrounded by violent fascists waiting to be triggered. The Gadsden flags and "2AMom" license plates are just too prevalent to ever feel properly safe.

@mekkaokereke As a WW I have witnessed this dynamic. I had to come to realize I was in a self-imposed bubble of like-minded white people. Even my own brother characterized it as โ€œthe white man will not go down without a fightโ€ in 2016 as we were trying to get some understanding of the appeal of Trump. But white women elected him.

@mekkaokereke Americans really need to unhitch this conceit stereotype that racists are froth-mouthed, southern, conservative, and not in their own house. Most of my racist experiences come from mid-Atlantic liberals oblivious to their harm.

Just like we all have to kill the cop in our heads, white people have to kill the racist in theirs.

@platanoutre @mekkaokereke
More white people need to read Dr. King's Letter from Birmingham Jail.
@jargoggles @platanoutre @mekkaokereke and โ€œWhen Peace Becomes Obnoxiousโ€. They go together really well.
@jargoggles @platanoutre @mekkaokereke Got link to text? ๐Ÿคท๐Ÿผโ€โ™‚๏ธ
@iDGS @platanoutre @mekkaokereke
It's pretty easy to search. There's a full text version here: https://www.africa.upenn.edu/Articles_Gen/Letter_Birmingham.html
Letter from a Birmingham Jail [King, Jr.]

@iDGS @jargoggles @platanoutre @mekkaokereke

EVERYONE (but especially white folks) read Dr. King's letter from Birmingham Jail.
https://letterfromjail.com

Letter from Birmingham Jail, by Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.

Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.'s letter to 8 white church leaders, written from a jail cell in Birmingham, Alabama in 1963.

@jargoggles @platanoutre @mekkaokereke
If America was serious on equality, everyone would have read it in History at school.
@taatm @jargoggles @platanoutre @mekkaokereke Oh say can you see heterogenous America?

@jargoggles

I've said it before and I'll say it again: one of the best curriculum decisions my (heavily white) high school made was to assign Letter from Birmingham Jail as reading, rather than the usual feel-good selections from his speeches and writings.

@mekkaokereke this! I was discussing the generalization yesterday, humans going to human... so often I hear 'a woman would never' in reference to bad behavior, including murders. But they don't mean women, they mean ww, and they don't mean women at all, its an idea of yore. These 'delicate creatures' didnt count as people themselves. It's an idea, and if you go the direction of 'mules and men' you'll know where they'd like to place the rest, anything to not have to treat us all like humans
@mekkaokereke
I don't think these people understand that for folks like me, you, my son, so many of us, this election isn't about the right to DO things, this battle is about living in a country where we have the right to BE WHO WE ARE. It doesn't get any more fundamental or basic than that. They just don't want us to exist at all. To be who we are in "their" society.
#HarrisWalz2024

@mekkaokereke this somewhat checks out with my experience as a white trans women with transphobia. queer or feminist spaces that are white af tend to not be so safe. and I equally worry about men and women. men are more directly dangerous, because they're physically stronger. but women can throw me out of saver spaces

it's maybe a bit more directly to "protect white women" when it's transphobia than racism, but still hard to get this across

so no idea ๐Ÿ˜”

@sima @mekkaokereke Iโ€™m in a fandom-related female-only group on Facebook and theyโ€™ve been welcoming and inclusive to trans and NB members, but I still remember the Black woman being told discussing politics was not okay when she was discussing racism. The mods eventually backed down, but the damage was done. I wonโ€™t invite a non-white person to the group because the โ€œsafe spaceโ€ is only safe if youโ€™re white. Ugh.

@mekkaokereke
It's not that evidence doesn't convince.

It's that "women are morally superior to men" is dogma to most progressive folks. And even if they don't believe it, they wouldn't be caught dead saying it.

I think the mark of being truly open is accepting anyone, from any category can have the full range of human characteristics, from good to terrible.

At least, that's what I believe, and I'm frequently lonely.

@iinavpov @mekkaokereke I'll follow you because of this
@mekkaokereke I have some minor experience with this, having both black and women friends (*shock*).
People I've known for years and would never suspect as being racist or sexist, when they interact with my other friends without me being present, behave very differently.
They never bare their fangs where I can see them.
It's not that I don't know the other 50%; is that they behave when I am around.
@mekkaokereke Which is kinda weird, because I feel like if you asked people the percentage of white women who are "Karens" and they thought for a minute, they'd be like "Oh. Yeah, maybe there are a large number of close-minded white women along with all the close-minded white guys."
@mekkaokereke the worst issue that I find with white women (and women in general) is that they want to be lauded as โ€œpeacekeepersโ€, not making waves, etc. So they are super dedicated to the upkeep of the status quo and think anyone that is not invested in that is a โ€œbad personโ€. But they refuse to recognize that the status quo is racist/sexist or if they do, then they have excuses for why it canโ€™t change too fast (because that would be hard for others). Racists arenโ€™t only the people wearing MAGA hats, they are the ones trying to keep the current racist structures in place.
@irene @mekkaokereke "Racists aren't the people wearing MAGA hats, they are the ones trying to keep the current racists structures in place."
I beg to differ with you. I do not know a single MAGA person who would rather keep the current racists structures in place. In fact, Project 2025 and the RNC platform specifically has items to ensure rolling back to the earlier racist structures.
@Ralph058 @mekkaokereke lol, yes, I should have said racists arenโ€™t *only* the people wearing MAGA hats.
@Ralph058 @mekkaokereke there, I fixed it
@irene @mekkaokereke There are a hell of a lot of well meaning people who are racist without even realizing it. And, I don't mean the people who start with "I'm not a racist, but..."
The biases have changed so much since I was a kid, for most people.
But a lot of well meaning people are suckered into believing that people who have entered the country illegally should be deported rather than we need to fix the immigration system so these people that our economy needs are welcome to come here.
@Ralph058 @mekkaokereke yup, the problem is when you call them out on it and they refuse to learn.

@mekkaokereke well, I'm white and all of those Karen videos convinced (and disgusted) me.

I think men's behavior often (to me) being more overt combined with my own obliviousness to hide ww's racism from me for most of my life.

But I'm also not one to speak up and have conversations about race with other white folk, and as people are suggesting, maybe that's an effective way of flushing the racists out of their hiding behaviors.

Which reinforces the notion that if you don't actively do something about it, it (whatever it is) is gonna continue.

@stevenray @mekkaokereke Out of curiosity and without judgement: if you have an interest in questions of race and racism, as your participation in this thread suggests, what is it that stops you from discussing these topics with other white people? Is this something that you want to change?

@fivetonsflax @mekkaokereke thanks for your question.

I'm often reticent to express myself around other people, which is one behavior which makes me suspect that I have some degree of autism. It can be very situational for me. Sometimes I'm gabby, but only one on one. In a group setting, I'm highly likely to be wallpaper.

I certainly see value in having the discussion. It's being comfortable verbally engaging that's a real issue for me in those settings.

And maybe that's not the whole story. I really don't know. It's certainly part of it.

I'm on a bit of a journey trying to figure that part of me out. I have a long way to go.

I hope that helps.

@mekkaokereke Persuasion is social, then?

Perhaps there is no substitute for being in community with people who attest to this fact from their lived experience.

@mekkaokereke I'm glad I learned to read you threads to the very end. Once again, your last post answered the question I had after reading the first one :-)
@mekkaokereke my white mom lives in a super white, affluent retirement community in a swing state and is continuously surprised when she learns another of the white women she socializes with is a racist. Maybe I'm just a pessimist, but that's kinda my default assumption given the demographics. The sad part is it's just made her avoid talking about politics or race with her friends because she'd just rather not know.

@mekkaokereke

Well to be honest: I'm inclined to take you as a reliable source for who is being racist towards you. Seems like the sort of thing you would know!

I see more men pushing back on these local threads, (or perhaps I assume men(?)) But I don't think Mastodon is very representative of the gen pop.

I guess seeing that it's 50% of white women voting Trump on the regular feels pretty persuasive, but they're a bit quieter about their anti-Blackness online.

@Homebrewandhacking @mekkaokereke White women are less likely to push back directly and more likely to block/report these threads, or talk about how "threatened" they feel, or to @ all the Black people they follow announcing that they are "disengaging" from learning about "stressful topics" for "their own mental health", the same way white women offline are more likely to use verbal violence before physical violence. Of course, in both environments, there will always be some doing both.
@Homebrewandhacking @mekkaokereke No waves! Just quietly prop up the white patriarchy

@mekkaokereke I read an article the other day about a woman who was anti-choice until a friend of hers needed an abortion.

I think the answer is in there: most people can't empathize with something they've never personally experienced unless it happens to someone close to them. (And sometimes not even then.)