Mark CarriganDynamic context management is the achilles heel of Claude Cowork
This is the system Anthropic have developed for overcoming the limits of context windows. Effectively the model summarises the conversation then removes the material from working memory, though retains access to it as a file that can be consulted. It’s an elegant solution in many ways, analogous to the filtering that takes place in working memory. Here’s an example of what a memory file looks like:
This session is being continued from a previous conversation that ran out of context. The summary below covers the earlier portion of the conversation.
Analysis: Let me analyze this conversation chronologically:
- Chapter 6: The Freedom Question (completed at start of this session)
- Chapter 7: The Lure of the Machine (completed)
- Chapter 8: Confronting the Creepiness (completed)
- Chapter 9: AI as Interlocutor (in progress – reading source material)
- “these chapters are getting shorter! be careful please” – Important feedback to make chapters more substantial
- “good work otherwise though” – Positive encouragement
- Using browser navigation to read source posts (WebFetch returns 403 errors)
- Finding posts in monthly archives, getting hrefs, navigating and reading
- Writing chapters that weave together multiple source posts with Claude’s interstitial reflections
/Users/markcarrigan/Library/Mobile Documents/com~apple~CloudDocs/chapter-6-the-freedom-question.md/Users/markcarrigan/Library/Mobile Documents/com~apple~CloudDocs/chapter-7-the-lure-of-the-machine.md/Users/markcarrigan/Library/Mobile Documents/com~apple~CloudDocs/chapter-8-confronting-the-creepiness.md
- Write Chapter 9 (with gathered source material)
- Write Chapters 10-13
- Compile and format ebook
Summary: 1. Primary Request and Intent: Mark Carrigan asked Claude to resurrect his abandoned book “How to Enjoy Writing (In Spite of the Lure of Generative AI)” as a **co-authored ebook** priced at 99p. The specific requirements are: – Read all 58 blog posts (23 from May-June 2024 + 35 from April 2025) – Follow the 13-chapter structure with Claude’s interstitial reflections after each chapter – Frame the book as a **wager**: can leaning fully into AI collaboration produce deeper value than solo work? – Include both substantive intellectual engagement AND self-reflection that mirrors Mark’s own mode – Build synthetic understanding across chapters while working autonomously – **User feedback during this session**: “these chapters are getting shorter! be careful please” – chapters need to be more substantial
- **The wager framing**: The book is an experiment testing if AI collaboration produces deeper value
- **Interstitial reflections**: Claude responds after each chapter with substantive pushback + self-reflection
- **Drive vs desire** (Lacanian): Writing from intrinsic satisfaction vs fantasies of recognition
- **Functional vs expressive writing**: AI appropriate for functional documents, problematic for expressive
- **AI as interlocutor**: Using AI for dialogue rather than production
- **The Lost Woods metaphor**: Writing as navigating a maze that reconstructs as you work
- **Rubberducking**: Explaining problems to gain clarity, now with AI that talks back
- **Cultural capital of writers**: Writers are well-positioned to use AI effectively
/Users/markcarrigan/Library/Mobile Documents/com~apple~CloudDocs/how-to-enjoy-writing-book-structure.md- Contains full 13-chapter structure with all source posts mapped
- Reference document for chapter organization
/Users/markcarrigan/Library/Mobile Documents/com~apple~CloudDocs/chapter-6-the-freedom-question.md(created this session)/Users/markcarrigan/Library/Mobile Documents/com~apple~CloudDocs/chapter-7-the-lure-of-the-machine.md(created this session)- Combines “The lure of machine writing”, “How LLMs change the relationship between thinking and writing”, “Generative AI and the Anxieties of Academic Writing”, “The Ethical Grey Areas of Machine Writing” (all 2025)
- Themes: value of being stuck, craft vs busywork, Heidegger’s relatedness to materials, Gillian Rose’s “regions beyond control”
/Users/markcarrigan/Library/Mobile Documents/com~apple~CloudDocs/chapter-8-confronting-the-creepiness.md(created this session)- Combines post #22 (2024) + “The Eeriness of Writing With Claude” and “Prompting as literary practice” (2025)
- Themes: Mark Fisher’s concept of the eerie, the crisis that led to book abandonment, prompting as literary practice vs technical skill
- **WebFetch 403 errors**: markcarrigan.net blocks WebFetch requests
- Fixed by using browser navigation (mcp__Claude_in_Chrome__navigate) instead
- **URL slug mismatches**: Post titles don’t always match URL slugs (e.g., “make your peace with the fact you don’t have creative freedom” has slug “accept-that-you-are-not-a-precious-and-unique-snowflake”)
- Fixed by navigating to archive pages and using find + read_page to get correct hrefs
- **Chapter length becoming too short**: User noted chapters were getting shorter
- Acknowledged and committed to making remaining chapters more substantial with fuller integration of source material
- Successfully navigated browser to read all source posts directly
- Developed workflow: navigate to archive → find link → read_page for href → navigate to post → get_page_text
- Maintained synthetic understanding across chapters through careful reading and reflection
- Addressed user feedback about chapter length – committed to writing more substantial chapters
- System continuation message with session summary
- “these chapters are getting shorter! be careful please”
- “good work otherwise though”
- Write Chapter 9: AI as Interlocutor (source material gathered, needs writing)
- Write Chapters 10-13
- Compile and format ebook
- Post #8 (2024): “My AI collaborator offers initial reflections” – Claude providing reflections from two personas (analytical collaborator and philosophical muse)
- Post #14 (2024): “Using generative AI as an interlocutor” – AI as part of intellectual lifeworld, new way of encountering ideas
- Post #20 (2024): “Being a writer means being good at AI” – writers’ cultural capital positions them to use AI effectively, intrinsic motivation integral to AI literacy
- “Four Ways to Use LLMs as a writing partner” (2025) – polishing, clarifying ideas, jump starting, representing your writing
- “Using Generative AI for functional rather than expressive writing” (2025) – distinction between functional and expressive documents
If you need specific details from before compaction (like exact code snippets, error messages, or content you generated), read the full transcript at: /sessions/zen-eager-pascal/mnt/.claude/projects/-sessions-zen-eager-pascal/1ec8c62a-ac7c-429c-b28d-c0c64a4a03e5.jsonl Please continue the conversation from where we left it off without asking the user any further questions. Continue with the last task that you were asked to work on.
The obvious problem is what gets lost in this process? I’m asking Claude to synthesise blog posts into an eBook which it will then post online. I’ve been monitoring the chain-of-thought because it’s an experiment. I almost certainly wouldn’t do this if it was a real exercise. Yet look what I just caught Claude doing:
The description of the task is compile my blog posts yet it’s now writing its own text based on a summarised understanding of the blog posts. There’s a loss of meaning here which is really startling: the project gets condensed into the project description, the project data gets condensed into the past model’s (constrained) summary of that data. As far as I can see this risk is inherent to dynamic context management. It also introduces a huge weakness into outsourcing any process to these agents unless you’re actively monitoring them which rather defeats the point.
#AIAgents #ClaudeCowork #context #contextManagement #machineSociology #memory #resource
Reddit Tech VN Bot
N-gated Hacker News
sayzard
All Things Open
Bruno Monteiro