Obituary for the late Mark Zuckerberg who turned a Harvard campus creeper app, scraping and rating female students' photos, into a global Public Information Utility, who left this life firmly committed to the right of every member of the Public to enjoy their own truth; and to evade their rights established under the Common Carrier clause of the US Code which was enacted to protect citizens from parasitic utilities like those operated by Meta Corp.

https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?path=/prelim@title47/chapter5/subchapter2&edition=prelim

#law #justice #AI #satire #1A #freespeech #commonCarrier #publicUtilities #antitrust #regulation #oversight #publicInterest #publicSector #journo #journalism #RIP #obituary #meta #social #factChecking #disinfo #disinformation #propaganda #truth #truthMatters #facts #factsMatter

It sure would be nice if some reliable nonprofits dedicated to online #fairness and #integrity with solid rules about #antidiscrimination, #FreeSpeech, dispute resolution, #oversight, and #appeals process would open up #mastodon #fediverse instances.

The community is not particularly well-served by treating what is really a #CommonCarrier as #PrivateProperty from which anyone can be ejected at will.

Over the past 20 years, the FCC has dealt with net neutrality 6 times, and this month it will do so for the 7th time because of artificial intelligence.

For those unfamiliar with net neutrality, it’s based on the common carrier: A common carrier holds itself out to provide service to the general public without discrimination (to meet the needs of the regulator’s quasi-judicial role of impartiality toward the public’s interest) for the “public convenience and necessity.” A common carrier must further demonstrate to the regulator that it is “fit, willing, and able” to provide those services for which it is granted authority1.

The idea that an internet service provider (ISP) is a common carrier is a constant battle. Without it, an ISP could slow one company’s content and speed up another company’s for money – despite the quality of content. It’s not hard to see why network neutrality is important in an age of influence, fake news, and manipulation of information from bad actors. Where people differ is who the bad actors are.

But what does that have to do with AI?

…Make no mistake about it, the major AI platforms are not weak wallflowers compared to the ISPs. There is a pressing need for regulatory oversight of the Big Tech companies that have delivered Big AI, including basic concepts such as openness, privacy, and interconnection.

Yet, access to AI for purposes as diverse as medical research or writing a term paper would be compromised without a fair and open internet. The issue before the FCC on April 25 is bigger than the catchphrase “net neutrality.” The 2024 iteration of the open internet debate is the reiteration of an issue that first surfaced in 2004: whether the dominant and essential network of the 21st century will go unsupervised…

AI makes the fight for net neutrality even more important“, Tom Wheeler, The Brookings Institution, April 9th 2024.

In essence, the perceived value of accessible information has increased. The actual issue itself doesn’t really have to do with artificial intelligence, only the perceived value of the information that the networks connect to.

Access to information is important, regardless of perceived value. If you pay for an internet connection you should be able to get everything available to you instead of turning your internet access into glorified cable television, where you get more content if you pay more while you have no actual control over the content.

What is also interesting is that even if network neutrality is successfully defended, ChatGPT is presently considered 82% more persuasive than humans, as mentioned here earlier this week, and since access to ChatGPT is fairly low cost, it allows smaller pockets to compete with larger pockets for your minds.

And conversely, it allows your voice to compete with larger pockets.

  • Per Wikipedia, accessed 13 Apr, 2024 ↩︎
  • https://knowprose.com/2024/04/13/fcc-ai-and-net-neutrality/

    #AI #commonCarrier #FCC #information #netNeutrality #Technology

    Federal Communications Commission

    The United States of America

    The idea that cable providers (or any ISP) would make good copyright cops is terrifying to me (speaking only for myself).
    #CommonCarrier #Section230 #DMCA #Copyright #TechPolicy #LawFedi
    https://publicknowledge.org/broadband-providers-are-not-copyright-cops/
    Broadband Providers Are Not Copyright Cops: Why the Sony v. Cox Case Threatens Internet Users

    The long-running legal battle between Sony and Cox continues, with possible ramifications for internet users everywhere.

    Public Knowledge
    America's Net Neutrality Question: Should the FCC Define the Internet as a 'Common Carrier'? - Slashdot

    The Washington Post's editorial board looks at America's "net neutrality" debate. But first they note that America's communications-regulating FCC has "limited authority to regulate unless broadband is considered a 'common carrier' under the Telecommunications Act of 1996." The FCC under Presiden...

    America's Net Neutrality Question: Should the FCC Define the Internet as a 'Common Carrier'?

    https://m.slashdot.org/story/420820

    #tech #technology #web #www #internet #fcc #netneutrality #commoncarrier

    Slashdot

    Any updates on Justice Clarence Thomas's designation of #Twitter as a #CommonCarrier since it was bought by #ElonMusk ?

    https://www.rcfp.org/justice-thomas-knight-v-trump/

    Justice Clarence Thomas suggests tech platforms qualify as ‘common carriers’

    The justice's suggestion that social media platforms be regulated like utilities is particularly relevant to press freedom advocates.

    The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press

    Judge tears apart #Republican lawsuit alleging bias in #Gmail spam filter | Ars Technica

    Gmail isn't a #commoncarrier and is protected by #Section230, judge rules.
    #spamfilter

    https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2023/08/judge-tears-apart-republican-lawsuit-alleging-bias-in-gmail-spam-filter/

    Judge tears apart Republican lawsuit alleging bias in Gmail spam filter

    Gmail isn't a common carrier and is protected by Section 230, judge rules.

    Ars Technica
    @protecttruth In the abstract I agree, and I support some kind of #CommonCarrier status for pervasive #SocialMedia . Some things to think about: #FCC Title II regulation; #Pruneyard Shopping Center v. Robins; #Section230 ; #NetNeutrality ; and the former #FairnessDoctrine
    The Argument For The Internet As A Utility: Is It Time To Change How It's Delivered? (2020) https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbestechcouncil/2020/06/17/the-argument-for-the-internet-as-a-utility-is-it-time-to-change-how-its-delivered/?sh=918915772958 The article is still relevant as the #Senate struggles to confirm consumer advocate Gigi #Sohn as #FCC chair. The pandemic has made obvious what disabled people already knew: #Internet service is as crucial now as wired telephony was in the 20th c. and should be regulated as a utility, not a luxury. #NetNeutrality #utility #CommonCarrier
    The Argument For The Internet As A Utility: Is It Time To Change How It's Delivered?

    The internet is increasingly entering the category of essential utilities -- a fact reinforced by the current pandemic the world is facing.

    Forbes