"The Suffering Behind ‘Humane,’ Organic Milk"
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/04/alexandre-farms-treatment-of-animals/677980/
https://12ft.io/https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/04/alexandre-farms-treatment-of-animals/677980/
An article in "The Atlantic" that actually goes after the #humaneWashing going on in the cow farming sector.
<💬>
Cow 13039, the auction affidavit showed, came from one of the country’s preeminent dairy farms: Alexandre Family Farm, a nationwide supplier to stores including Whole Foods. Alexandre cows are pasture-raised, and the operation is validated by California Certified Organic Farmers (CCOF), Certified Humane, and the Regenerative Organic Alliance. Its owners, Blake and Stephanie Alexandre, won the Organic Farmer of the Year award a few years back and have been profiled by The New York Times. For $8, you can buy about a third of a gallon of its top-shelf milk.
The Alexandres sold dozens of grievously ill and injured cows at auction over the past four years, according to a sprawling whistleblower report published by the nonprofit advocacy group Farm Forward. On the farm, the report charges, mismanagement led to “the extreme suffering of hundreds of cows.” One whistleblower contacted the local sheriff and the United States Department of Agriculture, among other organizations, to report animal-welfare violations, but without results. The report is based on hundreds of location- and date-tagged photographs and videos collected over a four-year period by people who worked either with or for Alexandre Family Farm, as well as on affidavits, veterinary reports, and interviews.
</💬>
<💬>
When I met Cow 13039, a dying animal sold to the highest bidder, I thought that the system had failed her. But in reporting this story, I found something far more disconcerting. No system had failed her, because there was no system to protect her in the first place.
</💬>
The only difference between extensive animal farming (which is seen as more humane) and intensive animal farming (which is seen as inhumane) is INTENSITY. They are not distinct systems, but the same system on different levels of intensity. And the purpose of that intensity is money.
Aside from the bullshit of humanewashing, it's important to note that extensive animal farming is by no means "nice" to the animals. Let's just say that you can have very small CAFOs. Backyard CAFOs, traditional ones. And a lot of brutality can be low-tech, based on manual labor, as is often the case in the sector (*those* jobs). Nor is staying out exposed to weather, bugs, and predators "nice". They'll find out soon enough the limits of being outside as the climate gets more interesting.
What we're really talking about is the pastoralist fantasies of and for carnists who simultaneously want to feel better --- about themselves --- and want to get the highest "quality" animal products, because they follow bourgeois tradition and animal products are a luxury, some of the first forms of commodity fetishism (see my pinned thread).
Thus the welfarists will always fail and will always be in the service of animal farmers and against the interests of non-human animals. Eventually, the "welfare" pretense will drop, probably when the prices get higher and people get poorer and demand *any* animal products and no longer care about "humane", even if they get some inferiority complex for it and privately desire to access luxury "humane organic regenerative PURE" animal products. The business will always have priority and all these standards are rarely testable in the final chunk of cooked flesh or bowl of egg mixture or slice of congealed milk fat.
So let's not waste time with welfarism and "stepping stones" that lead to nowhere.
#animalIndustry #dairy #milk #cows #greenwashing #humane #marketing