How much abuse do you think people should take?
Is the number zero?
Guess what, you're people.
How much abuse do you think people should take?
Is the number zero?
Guess what, you're people.
When I teach the research that shows that spanking is abuse, no exceptions, I always get students insisting that they were spanked and they turned out fine.
No, they didn't. They turned out as people who think it's okay to hit little kids.
Abuse is abuse. People who abuse kids are criminals.
I have had issues all of my life because of the abuse that I suffered as a kid.
When I was born, my mom didn't want me and left me at the hospital. My life went downhill from there.
It wasn't my choice... I had no choice.
@maddad @TeacherGriff @RickiTarr
That is very sad. You must be a very strong person to have survived and triumphed over so much.
As my partner once said when you speak to these people who tell you it 'didnt affect them', they can tell you in precise detail what happened, when and in what circumstances all from 40-80 yrs ago.
If you can remember in such vivid, scented, flavoured emotional detail so many years later, it sounds like they most definitely were affected.
I make that same point preemptively, so nobody embarasses themselves.
Oh, sometimes embarrassment is necessary to get the point across. Along with the kids who get it shouting down the kids who argue in favor of spanking. Peer pressure makes a difference.
@RickiTarr My stepson once said to me, “You should just stop saying things that make my mother hit you…” and “You’re big enough to take it…”
😢
Ooof
@RickiTarr I'm not sure if this is regarding anything in particular; if so, i apologize.
I have only recently come to terms with the likelihood that I'm in an abusive relationship. It's a lot to think about, for sure.
As far as 'not knowing', I'm sure growing up in an abusive household didn't help. Sitcoms (with few exceptions) always seemed an unacheiveable ideal - i knew absolutely nobody that lived like that, so people treating each other with respect seemed to just be more of the same.
I have a lot of theories as to why that might be the case.
@KatLS @RickiTarr Progress toward escape is already being made. I will not be able to care for myself until I get surgery, then 4-6 weeks of recovery time. In the meantime, I've been packing up all of my shit. I'm about a week out from paying for a new house in France, which will be in my name only. Once there I sign over my portion of the Portland house to her, we divorce, no fuss no muss. She can sink or swim and it won't matter in the slightest to me.
I realize this sounds like all hopeful bullshit, but that really is the sum total of what it will take to get me out of here.
I am also still waiting on disability, but having spoken to them last week I am hopeful to have an assessment soon. My heart disease is likely to kill me, so I very pointedly qualify so...<shrug> it's hard not to be hopeful I guess, even though nothing is actually resolved yet.
@RickiTarr None. Set boundaries, enforce them with gentle warnings and then withdraw completely if they’re repeatedly violated.
We should also not be abusers, which you’d think we wouldn’t have to say, but, we do.
@RickiTarr Thing about abuse is that it's completely about a power differential. The person being abused, by definition, doesn't have the agency to stop it.
Should the number be zero? Absolutely.
However, relying on those who are victims with no agency to enforce the stoppage of abuse is folly.
@RickiTarr This is where it gets a bit complicated for me.
How much abuse is unintentional? Not everyone shares the same reality, even with shared experiences. How much mistreatment is a direct result of an abused person learning bad ways to cope with the abuse?
I'd wager: most of it.
While casting blame isnt the goal, the only way to convince someone that they have a problem is to confront them, and that comes with a whole different batch of different reactions.
Not excusing it at all, and starting with ourselves can probably help quite a lot, but I dont think it's necessarily the abused and the abusers so much as everyone (basically) being a bit of both.
@RickiTarr I have to disagree.
When my wife is overruling control of every part of our shared life it's not out of some malicious intent to demean me and reduce my power. It's a response to her lifetime of being raised in a household where she didn't have any control at all, and then HAD to be independent while finishing her teen years and raising a child. I don't blame her for the way that she is.
But, the way that she is is incompatible with the way that I am, and I find some of her behaviors to be abusive.
The gaslighting I can't explain away...maybe there's something similar there, maybe not, but not ALL of the abuse is intended abuse, at least, not in her case.
Make of my opinion what you will. I know how it sounds. I really do pity her, but not enough to put up with it any longer.
@RickiTarr
I read the word "definition" a lot here. The definition of the word "abuse" is not based on the individuals opinion.
Here is a source, to look it up.
@RickiTarr I believe the answer should be zero for me. But I teach what I allow. If I let a bit of it in, it becomes normalized
Some behaviors I was taught to believe it was reactionary due to my behavior (think parent justifying spanking their child). & if I didn't want the abuse I should not "motivate it"
So what I have learned is to set clear boundaries on what I view to be abusive & not tolerable and never budging on it. Once I budge then I am allowing it. (Give an inch they take a mile)
I think everyone is way too sensitive lately about everything.
Personally, my boundary seems to be set at physical assault (also not wild about high volume screaming). Outside of that. I either try to figure out what they are trying to say, or just ignore it.
Racial/ethnic/sexual slurs I try to point out as such.
Otherwise, I welcome all negative comments. They help me improve. I hate praise and compliments.
@[email protected] Wow that's a really good question, one I'm kind of afraid to ask in a public forum. So, I will give you what I use in my personal life, but I'm not any kind of authority. Some abuse is obvious, physical abuse, sexual abuse, if someone lays a hand on you to harm you or does something that takes away your agency. But there's so much other stuff, and that is harder, the first one that is simpler to me is degradation, so calling someone stupid, dumb, going out of their way to embarrass you. Obviously, I don't mean an occasional prank, but consistently mean-spirited actions, acting like even a simple mistake on your part is huge and deeply offensive. If you set boundaries for yourself and they consistently ignore or purposefully violate them, now you can only set them for yourself you can't set them for other people. The other thing I will talk about, at least for me personally, which may not fall into this category entirely, but it's a good indicator, any relationship has to be give and take, so if you're in the situation where you're doing most of the giving, doing, and apologizing, that usually indicates a problem. But first you need to ask yourself if you're asking for what you need in a clear way, or if you are not allowing them to give because of your own perfectionism. Sorry, if that is kinda jumbled.