I usually write this blog 5-6 days/week, but every now and again, I take a break, and when I do, I get massive link backlogs of stuff I want to write about, but lack the time to address in depth. When that happens, I turn my Saturday edition into a #linkdump. Today, I present the sixth in the series - here's the other five:
https://pluralistic.net/tag/linkdump/
1/
If you'd like an essay-formatted version of this thread to read or share, here's a link to it on pluralistic.net, my surveillance-free, ad-free, tracker-free blog:
https://pluralistic.net/2023/09/09/nein-nein/#everything-is-miscellaneous
2/
Why was I offline and away from my blog? I went to the #DirtRave. Yes, I was one of the 70,000+ people stuck in the mud at this year's #BurningMan, and when I emailed my editor at the #NYTimes to say I might be late on the op-ed I was working on, she asked me to write about what this year's mud crisis meant:
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/09/06/opinion/burning-man-flood-playa-climate-change.html
3/
tl;dr:
* Bad weather is normal at Burning Man (it's a feature, not a bug);
* Mostly burners leapt to the occasion, which is what people almost always do in disaster situations;
* This is the second Burning Man #HeavyWeather year in a row;
* The #ClimateEmergency is tipping the #BlackRockDesert from "extremely challenging" to "impossible";
* This isn't the last event, place and tradition that will have to be radically reconsidered in light of the climate emergency;
4/
But now I'm home, in my hammock, with all the laundry done - just in time to leave again. I'm about to head back to my hometown of #Toronto for a book launch. #TheInternetCon, my latest nonfiction (from #VersoBooks) came out last week, and I'll be appearing at #AnotherStory books on Tuesday:
https://anotherstory.ca/events/29283
5/
*Internet Con* is a "#BigTech disassembly manual." It explains how Big Tech got so big (lax anti-#monopoly enforcement, which led to #RegulatoryCapture, which let Big Tech abuse our privacy, #labor rights, and #consumer rights), and how we can use #interoperability so it's no longer #TooBigToFail, nor #TooBigToJail:
https://www.versobooks.com/products/3035-the-internet-con
6/
You can read a long excerpt from the book in #Wired, which lays out some of the shovel-ready legislative, regulatory and technical proposals that are the book's main purpose:
https://www.wired.com/story/the-internet-con-cory-doctorow-book-excerpt/
You can also hear me read the whole introduction and first chapter of the audiobook on my podcast:
7/
That comes from the audiobook, a #DRM-free, independent edition that I financed, produced and narrated myself. You can get the audiobook everywhere *except* #Audible, #AppleBooks, and #Audiobooks.com, all of which have mandatory DRM policies. You can also get it direct from me:
https://transactions.sendowl.com/products/78992826/DEA0CE12/purchase
The DRM-free ebook is available everywhere ebooks are sold (Kobo, Kindle, Nook, etc), as well as in my own DRM-free ebook store:
https://transactions.sendowl.com/products/78992801/9C4FC2B8/purchase
8/
Verso's books are sold in bookstores around the world; you can support your local bookseller by buying it through #Bookshop:
If you'd like a signed copy, there's stock at #BookSoup:
https://www.booksoup.com/book/9781804291245
Now, it was inevitable that I would do a book event for *Internet Con* in Toronto - I've never had a bad event there, and I love my hometown - but the timing of this event was driven by a non-book-related factor.
9/
#TalkingHeads is appearing together at #TIFF, to support the re-release of #StopMakingSense, the greatest concert film in human history:
https://pluralistic.net/StopMakingSense
People often ask me what my favorite book is, and I always tell them that you should never trust people who have one favorite book, as it inevitably turns out to be #TheBible, #TheFountainhead, or #MeinKampf. But while I don't have a favorite book, I have a clear and unambiguous favorite *band*.
10/
If I was forced to listen to no music other than Talking Heads for the rest of my life, I would be perfectly happy. Ecstatic, even. Throw in #DavidByrne, #TomTomClub and #CasualGods and I probably wouldn't even notice anything missing.
There's a running joke among my Burning Man campmates that whenever I'm in charge of the music, I'm just shuffling Talking Heads rarities, and whenever someone puts on anything else, I demand to know which Talking Heads album it came from.
11/
Which is all to say: *I have tickets for the Talking Heads event at TIFF and I could *not* be more excited.*
Continuing on the Canadian theme, one of the annual highlights of Canadian media is the #MasseyLectures, a series of public lectures given around the country and rebroadcast on #CBC. These are always great, but recent years have been *superb* - @rondeibert's 2020 series was unmissable:
https://pluralistic.net/2020/11/10/dark-matter/#citizenlab
12/
This year's Masseys are shaping up to be the GOAT. They're presented by @AstraTaylor, an activist rock-and-roller turned documentary filmmaker who is one of the founders of #TheDebtCollective, fighting for #StudentDebt cancellation. Everything Astra does is *amazing* and her profile on #CBCIdeas gives some background on the role that #unschooling played in making her the powerful activist she is today:
https://www.cbc.ca/radio/ideas/astra-taylor-interview-2023-massey-lecturer-1.6959320
13/
Writer and political organizer Astra Taylor is this year's CBC Massey Lecturer. In conversation with IDEAS host Nahlah Ayed, the Winnipeg-born filmmaker explains how her early years in the unschooling movement shaped her worldview and how Occupy Wall Street taught her that 'thinking' and 'doing' go hand in hand.
There's no question that things are messed up right now, but Astra and people like her shine out like beacons of hope. 17 years ago, self-described "democracy nut" $TomStites gave one of the seminal lectures on the role news media play in democracy:
http://citmedia.org/blog/2006/07/03/guest-posting-is-media-performance-democracys-critical-issue/
14/
17 years later - and from his perch as editor at the essential @icij - Stites presents us a long-overdue, extremely pertinent followup: "Building Civic Energy is the Goal, Not Saving Old News Business Models":
https://banyanproject.coop/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/Hope-College-speech-for-Banyan-website-1.pdf
15/
Stites's intervention is extremely timely, because policymakers all over the world have made the mistake of thinking that Big Tech is stealing the news media's *content*, which is absolutely untrue. It is good, actually, to index news stories and let people discuss, quote from and link to news stories. News you're not allowed to talk about isn't news, it's a *secret*.
But Big Tech *is* stealing from news. They're not stealing content - they're stealing *money*.
16/
The Google/Apple duopoly rakes 30% off every subscription payment collected in an app. The Google/Meta duopoly rakes 51% out of every ad-dollar (and maintain that death-grip through creepy, #privacy-invading #SurveillanceAds). Meta and Twitter hold social media subscribers hostage, forcing publishers to pay to reach *their own subscribers*.
17/
We don't want the news to be Big Tech's *partners* - we need them to be Big Tech's *watchdogs*. #LinkTaxes and other profit-sharing arrangements between the media and tech cut against the civic energy Stites wants to build.
(You can read more about this - along with policy prescriptions for halting Big Tech's rent-extraction from the news - in "Saving the News From Big Tech," my @EFF white-paper:)
https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2023/04/saving-news-big-tech
18/
Download this whole series as a single PDF.Media is in crisis: newsrooms all over the world are shuttering and the very profession of journalism is under sustained ideological and physical assault. Freedom of the press is a hollow doctrine if the only news media is written or published by...
If your spirits are lifted by stories of principled activists achieving important - and improbable - victories, you could do worse than to attend the #EFFAwards on in #SanFrancisco Sept 14 (I'm the emcee). This year, we're honoring #AlexandraElbakyan for her founding of #SciHub, the #LibraryFreedom project and @signalapp:
https://www.eff.org/awards/effawards/2023
19/
In more activist news: @mozilla produced a startling and astoundingly good - if demoralizing - report on the state of digital privacy and security in the automotive sector:
20/
Entitled, "It’s Official: Cars Are the Worst Product Category We Have Ever Reviewed for Privacy," the report reveals just how *absolutely terrible* the automotive sector is when it comes to privacy practices, collecting (and selling) (and giving away) information about your sex life, your geneology, your genetic characteristics, and your *smell* (no, seriously).
Their recommendations for which new car you should buy boil down to "don't buy a new car."
21/
I have been urging consumer research groups to release a report like this for a *decade*. There are whole categories of gadgets - like, say, "#SmartSpeakers" - that are unsafe at any speed. At a certain point, reviewers need to have the guts to say that every manufacturer in an entire sector is a dumpster fire and they should all be dragged in front of a firing squad - or at least a Congressional committee.
22/
Cars, after all, are nightmares of privacy invasion and rent-extraction, the source of #autoenshittification on a massive scale, a mobile form of #technofeudalism:
https://pluralistic.net/2023/07/24/rent-to-pwn/#kitt-is-a-demon
23/
The fact that cars score so badly on privacy is especially ironic given the campaign #BigCar waged against the 2020 #Massachusetts #RightToRepair ballot initiative, in which car manufacturers held themselves out as the *defenders* of driver privacy from unscrupulous third parties who couldn't be trusted to handle the vast troves of data your car collects with every hour that God sends:
https://pluralistic.net/2020/09/03/rip-david-graeber/#rolling-surveillance-platforms
24/
This is a familiar refrain: monopolists often claim that any check on their absolute authority over their users will expose those users to privacy risks. Apple has run a global ad-campaign claiming this, and while Apple *does* prevent Facebook from spying on #iPhone owners, they also secretly spy on those customers in exactly the same way that Facebook used to, and lie about it:
https://pluralistic.net/2022/11/14/luxury-surveillance/#liar-liar
25/
It turns out that giant companies just aren't good proxies for their customers' interests, and that the power they amass through monopolization shouldn't be counted on as a source of user safety. Monopolists won't reliably defend user privacy - that job belongs to democratically accountable regulators. That's an argument I developed in detail with #BennettCyphers in our EFF white-paper "Privacy Without Monopoly":
https://www.eff.org/wp/interoperability-and-privacy
26/
Update, June 11, 2021: Today, we updated this paper with a new appendix, "The GDPR, Privacy and Monopoly," which analyzes the legal benefits of interoperability under the GDPR, where a regional privacy law creates a sturdy privacy backstop for interoperability remedies. This appendix is also...
That is, rather than getting privacy by "voting with your wallet," you need to get it by voting with your *ballot*. "The market" is an election that you vote in with dollars, which means that the people with the most dollars always win. When there are *zero* cars on the market that are safe to drive, you can't vote with your wallet by buying a good one.
27/
On a related subject, the the DoJ #AntitrustDivision has brought the most important tech anti-monopoly case of the century, charging Google with monopolizing search:
Part of the #DOJ case turns on the fact that Google goes to *extraordinary* lengths to keep you from every *trying* another search engine, paying out more than *$45 billion every year* to be the default search on every device, program and service you might use.
28/
IOW: Google spends entire *Twitter's* worth of dollars every year, lighting it on fire to keep you from finding out about rivals.
Google argues that this is fine, actually, because these are only *defaults*, and users can dig through their settings to change their search engine. Sure, Google - and the first 20 search results you serve are only *defaults*, and it wouldn't matter if you were ordered to put them ten screens down, because users could always scroll to see them.
29/
But search defaults aren't the only way that Google locks in searchers - and then harms us by invading our privacy. Google's ubiquitous #Chrome browser ties Google's search to Google's invasive, nonconsensual, total surveillance. Chrome turned 15 this year and Google made a huge PR splash out of the anniversary:
https://blog.google/products/chrome/google-chrome-new-features-redesign-2023/
30/
But all that puffery conspicuously failed to mention that Google had quietly rolled out its long-discredited, new surveillance technology, #FLOC, which it pretended to kill in 2021:
https://pluralistic.net/2021/04/22/ihor-kolomoisky/#not-that-competition
#FLOC is back, rebranded as the #TopicsAPI: this is a system for spying on you so advertisers can target you. Google is spinning this as a privacy *improvement* because it might someday replace #ThirdPartyCookies, one of the creepiest web surveillance systems.
31/
But as #RonAmadeo writes for @arstechnica, Chrome is the last major browser to support third party cookies - both #Safari and #Firefox block them by default. So Google is basically saying, "We are going to improve your privacy by changing how we spy on you, even though all our competitors don't do this kind of spying *at all*":
32/
This kind of gaslighting, where Google pisses in all our mouths and tells us it's raining, is the hallmark of a decrepit, arrogant, crapulent monopolist that needs to be shattered in the courts. Kudos to the DoJ for doing the people's business here - and kudos to DoJ #antitrust boss #JonathanKanter for promising that he will *not* go into corporate law when he finishes his stint in government.
33/
The DoJ isn't the only public agency that's serving the American people. The #FCC just announced proceedings to force #Cybersecurity labels for "smart" devices:
This is long overdue, and it's a welcome action from the FCC, which was hamstrung for years because cowardly Democratic senators joined with homophobic, libelous #Republicans in blocking confirmation hearings for the amazing #GigiSohn:
https://pluralistic.net/2022/12/15/useful-idiotsuseful-idiots/#unrequited-love
34/
Cory Doctorow
Mirishuli