The Privacy-Utility Trade-off in the Topics API

The ongoing deprecation of third-party cookies by web browser vendors has sparked the proposal of alternative methods to support more privacy-preserving personalized advertising on web browsers and applications. The Topics API is being proposed by Google to provide third-parties with "coarse-grained advertising topics that the page visitor might currently be interested in". In this paper, we analyze the re-identification risks for individual Internet users and the utility provided to advertising companies by the Topics API, i.e. learning the most popular topics and distinguishing between real and random topics. We provide theoretical results dependent only on the API parameters that can be readily applied to evaluate the privacy and utility implications of future API updates, including novel general upper-bounds that account for adversaries with access to unknown, arbitrary side information, the value of the differential privacy parameter $ε$, and experimental results on real-world data that validate our theoretical model.

arXiv.org

Our paper "The Privacy-Utility Trade-off in the Topics API" is now available!

https://doi.org/10.1145/3658644.3670368

#TopicsAPI #Google #PrivacySandbox #Cookies #Privacy

The Privacy-Utility Trade-off in the Topics API | Proceedings of the 2024 on ACM SIGSAC Conference on Computer and Communications Security

ACM Conferences

@oblomov My initial gut reaction was the same. And I still think it may be wise to opt out of this experiment until it is better understood.

But what if this initiative could indeed serve as a privacy-preserving replacement for #tracking? It looks better than all the terrible ideas Google came up with to replace cookies (#FLoC #PrivacySandbox #TopicsAPI) let alone #browserFingerprinting.

Here is my take on Mozilla's #privacyPreservingAttribution aka #privateAttribution: https://suma-ev.social/@christian/112761712837712799

Christian Pietsch 🍑 (@[email protected])

#Firefox 128 is here. With it comes a new section in the privacy and security settings called "Website Advertising Preferences" containing a ticked box labeled "Allow websites to perform privacy-preserving ad measurement". The help text linked there sounds promising: https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/privacy-preserving-attribution #Mozilla to provide a surveillance-free alternative to #tracking? Technical explainer: https://github.com/mozilla/explainers/tree/main/ppa-experiment What do #privacy experts think? #ppa #dap #privateAttribution #privacyPreservingAttribution

suma-ev.social
Google вимкне сторонні cookie для 1% користувачів Chrome з 4 січня – масове розгортання Topics API очікується протягом року https://itc.ua/ua/novini/google-vymkne-storonni-cookie-dlya-1-korystuvachiv-chrome-z-4-sichnya-masove-rozgortannya-topics-api-ochikuyetsya-protyagom-roku/ #TopicsAPI #Браузери #Новини #Chrome #Cookie #Google #Софт
Google вимкне сторонні cookie для 1% користувачів Chrome з 4 січня – масове розгортання Topics API очікується протягом року

Незабаром Google почне реалізовувати свій задум щодо блокування сторонніх файлів cook

ITC.ua

#Chrome s new update also includes “Privacy Sandbox,” rather controversial new #privacy #killer.

#FirefoxMigration

@arstechnica:
"Don’t let Chrome’s big redesign distract you from fact Chrome’s #invasive new ad platform, ridiculously branded #PrivacySandbox is also getting widespread rollout in Chrome today. (It) will track web pages you visit and generate list of advertising topics it will share with sites, and built directly into the Chrome browser. In news previously as #FLoC and #TopicsAPI

As a reminder, whether you disable Chrome's new #TopicsAPI and #PrivacySandbox (read: "Privacy" "Sandbox") or completely switch to another browser (I suggest Firefox on Windows and Safari on Mac), INSTALL AN AD BLOCKER, because Google et. al. will still know what you're doing either way unless you do.

uBlock Origin (for Chrome, Firefox, Edge): https://ublockorigin.com/

1Blocker (Safari): https://1blocker.com/

(Yes, I have an ad blocker installed even on Safari because Apple's tracking prevention still only goes so far.)

uBlock Origin - Free, open-source ad blocker

uBlock Origin is a free, open-source ad blocker. Block ads on YouTube, Twitch, and across the web with low CPU and memory usage. Available for Firefox, Chrome, Edge, and more.

uBlock Origin

The history of #BOINC and distributed computing looks so much like the history of the #internet. It started out as a novel idea for collaboration and sharing of resources. And for a time, it was good.

Then people went and monitized it. The changes to #Google #Chrome with #FLoC / #topicsAPI are just the same progression.

https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2023/09/googles-widely-opposed-ad-platform-the-privacy-sandbox-launches-in-chrome/

Google gets its way, bakes a user-tracking ad platform directly into Chrome

Chrome now directly tracks users, generates a “topic” list it shares with advertisers.

Ars Technica

Is now a good time to be smug about being a Firefox user for the last 20 years?

#PrivacySandbox #TopicsAPI

(And yes, fellow aged pedants, I know it was called Phoenix/Firebird right back then)

But all that puffery conspicuously failed to mention that Google had quietly rolled out its long-discredited, new surveillance technology, #FLOC, which it pretended to kill in 2021:

https://pluralistic.net/2021/04/22/ihor-kolomoisky/#not-that-competition

#FLOC is back, rebranded as the #TopicsAPI: this is a system for spying on you so advertisers can target you. Google is spinning this as a privacy *improvement* because it might someday replace #ThirdPartyCookies, one of the creepiest web surveillance systems.

31/

Pluralistic: 22 Apr 2021 – Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow

#Business #Reviews
Google bakes an ad platform directly into Chrome · Chrome now directly tracks users via a ‘topic’ list https://ilo.im/1566oz

_____
#Google #Chrome #Browser #Advertising #Tracking #Privacy #PrivacySandbox #TopicsAPI #ThirdPartyCookies

Google gets its way, bakes a user-tracking ad platform directly into Chrome

Chrome now directly tracks users, generates a “topic” list it shares with advertisers.

Ars Technica