@downey @viq

The article about the issue in this subthread is now published: https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2026/mar/04/scotus-deny-cert-dc-circuit-thaler-appeal-llm-ai/

To @maxine's larger point in the OP, #SFC is putting serious work in the next few months into issues related to #LLM-backed #AI agents and their impact and implications for #FOSS. Nothing beyond that to report at this very moment, as it's a work in progress, but please watch #SoftwareFreedom Conservancy's website for announcements in coming months.

#copyleft #copyright #GPL #LGPL #LGPLv2_1

SCOTUS Declines to Hear LLM-Backed AI Case Regarding Copyright

No Serious Implications for FOSS from SCOTUS' DenialEarlier this week1, the U.S. Supreme Court (SCOTUS) denied certiorari (cert) in Thaler v. Perlmutter. Thaler contended that an image — generated by a Large Language Model (LLM)-backed Artificial Intelligence (AI) — deserved copyright registration. Since the U.S. Copyright Office refused to grant the registration, Thaler appealed to the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia (DC Circuit). That Court affirmed the Copyright Office's decision. SCOTUS' denial of “cert” means they will not hear the case. Strictly speaking, this denial does not affirm the DC Circuit Court's ruling, but it does mean the DC Circuit decision stands.

Software Freedom Conservancy

Judge Leal got a late start today, and note that #SFC v. #Vizio is not the first case on the docket, so you still have time to hear the oral arguments in today's motion.

Join here:
https://occourtsapp.occourts.org/aci/checkin-results?dept=C33

Follow my live reports today here:
https://fedi.copyleft.org/@bkuhn/115662504393710334

(Proprietary software ⚠️: It's Zoom For Government; its terms are not as bad as stock Zoom, but still very proprietary.)

#GPL #GPLv2 #LGPLv2_1 #OpenSource #FreeSoftware #SotwareFreedom

😲 👀 … Judge Leal in #SFC's landmark impact litigation against #Vizio (regarding their violations of #GPLv2 & #LGPLv2_1) is leaning toward partially granting our motion for summary adjudication.

Such motions are difficult to win, so this is amazing.

Her decision is tentative; join the hearing today (details in linked post) to hear the oral arguments in real time.

I'll live updates of the hearing in this thread.

https://sfconservancy.org/news/2025/dec/04/tentative-vizio-ruling-in-favor-of-sfc/

#OpenSource #FreeSoftware #copyleft #SoftwareFreedom

Judge Issues Tentative Ruling in Favor of SFC

Today, in the Superior Court of California in Orange County, Judge Sandy N. Leal will consider Software Freedom Conservancy's motion for summary adjudication in the Vizio case. The tentative ruling, issued this morning, rules in favor of SFC that Vizio has a duty to provide SFC with the complete and corresponding copylefted source code to the TV it purchased. Tentative rulings are not final; they are issued by the court to indicate how the judge is leaning on the issue, so that oral arguments at the hearing are most effective. The hearing on this issue will take place today, at 10am Pacific time. Information on how to attend is below.

Software Freedom Conservancy