RE: https://meow.social/@kris_of_pnictogen/115612685261226933

Hm, where was I going with this...

...I've been preoccupied in a kind of futile, circular way with the villainous way in which hardcore #Christians slowly invaded and coöpted the sciences and the medical professions, especially in the area of mental health. Evangelical Christians like to think of themselves as "fishers of men", people who have been designated by their God to sort out the fit from the unfit, the saved from the damned, the sheep from the goats. Thus have a great many purportedly secular professions pertaining to health, both physical and mental, have been quietly colonized by an especially vicious, hyperpolitical, and self-absorbed form of #Christianity, one that sees itself as the ultimate deciders of who gets to live and who ought to be cast out to suffer the pains of Hell. For these Christians have decided that Hell ought to be a concrete thing, something they can see all round them, and thus easier for them to have faith in.

(cont'd)

Thus, I suggest, have extremist #Christians unwittingly committed themselves to a kind of death-spiral of ever dwindling #faith in anything that's genuinely sacred or preternatural, anything that's genuinely outside of themselves. They decry the evils of The World, the perils of solipsism and "moral relativism", and yet they themselves seem like the chief victims of these things. The mainstream political sort of #Christian is apt to be extremely worldly, devoted to purely secular occupations like grubbing for profits and popularity and political power, and yet they cling stubbornly to a purely self-serving sort of faith which tells them, "You're not REALLY a part of that worldly corruption. You're something different, something special underneath the worldly clothing."

I think you can perhaps guess why such Christians are quietly obsessed with idolization of knighthood: they can imagine that their business-clothes and secular jobs are merely an armor, an invisible and invincible barrier between themselves and the worldly corruptions of money and power.

(cont'd)

The extremist Christian secretly screwing with some patient's medical records, or trying to get people fired for the sin of being "woke" in some way, or denying service to a perceived enemy of the faith from behind a drugstore counter, doesn't think of themselves as what they are, i.e. someone betraying the public's trust or doing crimes for shady personal reasons. They see themselves as undercover heroes, as commandoes for Jesus, as sacred paladins venturing out into the squalid heathen wastelands and striving to safeguard civilization and its godly values.

But I'm straying from the specific point I wish to make about how such Christofascists have come to see health in general. In their need to feel as if they see the principles of their faith reflected in the concrete world all around them, they have come to equate sickness, especially mental illness, with sin and diabolism.

(cont'd)

This tendency has long been evident in "Western", i.e. post-Roman Christian, societies in Europe and her various colonies. #Christians have never lived at ease with a purely abstract notion of sin and damnation; too frequently they're driven to wanting concrete evidence that someone is ontologically a sinner, intrinsically damned. That craving for proof of damnation takes innumerable forms, of course, such as Christian misogyny, which is currently fashionable in right-wing Christofascist politics. Only men can be trusted with leadership and decision-making, say the beardy hypermasculine #Christian evangelists such as Dale Partridge and Eric Conn: women are intrinsically erroneous, it says so in the Bible.

(According to my own Christian values, literally every human being is intrinsically erroneous—the most general possible interpretation of "original sin"—but in practice, many Christians prefer to think that there's only certain people who do all the sinning.)

(cont'd)

But disease and insanity have been especially tempting concepts to equate with sinfulness, for a great many #Christian fanatics, because these are things that can afflict someone who once was healthy and sinless. Contracting a disease or developing a mental disorder gives them a way of explaining temptation in a manner that doesn't encourage them to think about their own tendencies to be tempted. Others make the mistake of getting sick or going mad, but the good and pure person, the person of pristine health and sound "genetics", they remain untouched by sin and the wiles of the Devil.

It's been no help whatever, of course, that writers of Christian apologetics such as G. K. #Chesterton and the obnoxious #CSLewis have freely appealed to analogies involving health and sanity in order to justify their own zeal for proselytization.

(cont'd)

Chesterton, straining to explain himself to a possibly disbelieving audience in his monumental but highly problematical book Orthodoxy, appeals to Hanwell (q.v. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St_Bernard%27s_Hospital,_Hanwell still in operation under the aegis of the National Health) as a worldly analogue to Hell. To go to Hell is to go to Hanwell, suggests Chesterton, quite forgetting that Hanwell was only a Hellish place because of the incompetence and venality of the people who saw fit to incarcerate people in such a cesspit.

It was ALWAYS possible to do better than Hanwell, but polite English society was quite inured to the notion that mental asylums were little more than dungeons in which to throw "mad" persons. By equating Hell with Hanwell, Chesterton was unwittingly coöperating with that social failure; he was, as the kids say it, normalizing the notion that insane asylums ought invariably to be nightmarish.

(cont'd)

St Bernard's Hospital, Hanwell - Wikipedia

And that is precisely why the #Christian invasion of #health care, especially in #MentalHealth, is such a dangerous thing. The people who have wiggled themselves into gatekeeping positions in hospitals and asylums and substance-abuse treatment (and a myriad other institutions which give them life-and-death power over sick and vulnerable human beings) have a primary goal for being there, and it's NOT helping people. They're wanting, above all, continued and constant validation of their own repellent belief system. They want to assure themselves that indeed the world is divided between Heaven and Hell, even if they have to send people to Hell all by themselves.

They wish to act, in other words, as angels and demons. They have the cheek to suppose they can compartmentalize their demonic decisions safely away from their angelic ones—if, indeed, ANY of their decisions can be said to be on the side of the angels.

(cont'd)

I am reminded of the characterization of Kingpin in the superb #Spiderman film Into the Spider-verse, in which Liev Schreiber voices a cold and sarcastic corporate boss who nevertheless believes that his "true" self is the loving family man, seen only in luminous flashbacks to his supposedly happy marriage—a marriage which ended all at once when his wife stumbled in upon Kingpin locked in deathly battle with Spider-Man. Stunned to see this hidden side of her husband she flees with their son in a panic, and fatally smashes up her car.

Spider-Man's fault, right? That's how Kingpin sees it. He'd had his life safely divided, like Dr. Jekyll thinking he can let Mr. Hyde do all his sins for him, and Kingpin blamed Spider-Man for upsetting the balance, for destroying the vision of future happiness in which Kingpin had gotten away forever with deceiving his wife about the true nature of his business affairs.

(cont'd)

That's roughly how the terminally worldly and treacherous #Christians, who all imagine themselves as secret soldiers for Jesus as they squirrel themselves away in corporate and government and academic bureaucracies, cooking the books and doing special favors undercover in order to bring the Lord's Kingdom just a little bit closer, feel about their own lives. They break rules and cheat money and betray people and it's never crime to them, it's some other thing that they feel entitled and empowered to do, because they have faith and belief.

They're only cheating and betraying the Bad People™, who deserve it anyway. Their REAL self is radiant with Christian virtues. It's only the corruption of the world which somehow forces them to have this secret other life, in which they routinely do questionable things which absolutely must never be found out, because that would be like handing Satan a victory.

(cont'd)

I bring this at last back to my starting point, which was ruminating worriedly upon how U.S. society deals with #autism, which is—like it or not—largely governed by the fears and desires of the extremist #Christians who have pervaded secular U.S. institutions, especially anywhere there's #children. Right-wing Christians since the 1970s have stoutly asserted that nobody cares more about children than they do; they act as though parenting and child-care are their special area of expertise, and they have (somewhat astonishingly, to me) almost completely erased their obvious and frightening degree of faith in resorting to force and physical abuse from mainstream discourse.

#Christian writers on parenting routinely advocate violent methods of instilling obedience into children, they've been critiqued in the press many times, but they've so far managed to seal themselves into a privileged and protected place in U.S. discussion about children and #parenting. The weasel words "religious" and "faith-based" and "Biblical", liberally applied, seem to dampen all serious inquiry.

(cont'd)

Quite successfully, the Christofascists and televangelists and other #Christian fanatics who've set themselves up as experts on health and psychology and pediatrics (and other related topics) have sealed themselves tight behind a wall of rationales which they fiercely defend. If they sense threat to themselves, any outside scrutiny, they immediately cry out in unison that they're being subject to religious persecution and suppression of their "parents' rights" and so forth, and smear the moral authority of their critics. The method always seems to work: on all sides of mainstream U.S. politics and media, everyone seems to have tacitly agreed that the extremist #Christians get a pass. At worst, they get lumped into "both sides" rhetoric in which leftists are now routinely claimed to be by far the worse zealots. Even the most poisonous and vindictive reactionary Christian pastor or business-leader tends to be passed off as merely "controversial" or "outspoken".

These people have been at the frontlines of U.S. politics for decades now. They are accepted as normal and inevitable.

(cont'd)

That's very bad for anyone #neurodivergent or #disabled or with a #ChronicIllness or, heaven help them, anyone who's #autistic.

Nefarious and abusive #Christian fanatics have been allowed to set up shop as experts on health, upon child-rearing and education, and on mental illness, and even though they've been able to disguise their fanaticism behind a screen of ostensibly professional and non-Christian technical jargon, their ultimate purpose for being in these fields is quite a bad one: they have very definite ideas about what sort of people and especially what sort of #children deserve to get treatment, and which ought to be sent in Hell's direction instead.

After all...in the United States, all institutions pertaining to health and wellness (and schooling) are now immediately adjacent to the cops and the carceral state. The Christian paladins...they don't mind handing people over arbitrarily to the fuzz.

(cont'd)

They make no distinctions. Their perpetual low-level cosplay as secret agents who are truly employed for Jesus, never to any civil authority (except doublethinkfully, when it's useful to them) means that they have no reliable concept of professional boundaries. A patient under the care of a #Christian fanatic, in a hospital or sanitarium or anywhere else, must legitimately always fear that this exemplar of Christian love and generosity and charity might, in all "charity", hand them over to the sheriff's department in exchange for some perceived mortal sin...like being queer, or hinting at #suicide. And once that bit is flipped in their mind there's no going back. They dare not question their own decision to send someone towards Hell, because if they questioned themselves, there would be doubt, and such is the nature of their "faith" that it cannot bear the existence of doubt.

To doubt, is to admit the possibility of sin, and they must never think about that. That way madness lies.

(cont'd)

By tending to equate health and sanity with sinlessness, they have now given themselves that terror: unable now to think of sins as a routine part of their existence, something that will always be a trouble to them (as implied by the doctrine of "original sin", they will never not be vulnerable to temptation) they are driven to much the same extreme as the person who becomes unhealthfully preoccupied with their own sanity. Needing at all times to feel sane (and thus right with God), they define themselves in clear opposition to madness. They MUST have mad people around them, to scare them always back towards perfect health and moral rectitude.

So what happens when one of their own #children seems to be insane? And they do seem, by the way, to be blurring the lines between physical and mental illness. Increasingly they think of mental illness as something catching, something one can acquire from (say) watching the wrong movies.

(cont'd)

Well...they have a way of dealing with that. The #Christian parent has learned ways of regarding their own children as permanently lost to them, damned, DEAD to them even. Satan wrested their child from them, it wasn't THEIR fault!

#Autism seems to have gotten pride of place, in the contemporary American imagination, in terms of...well, being a diabolical affliction. It's freely talked about as though it were worse than death, worse than being carried off by a senseless case of diphtheria, worse than being starved or drowned or otherwise done in by...certain manifestations of Christian love. There's reliable money to be made from the occupation of "autism parent", in selling oneself as a martyr to autism, which took their child's soul away from them.

(cont'd)

And then there's the way in which #autism (and other #neurodivergence but I daresay, autism especially) has been muttered about as being the cause of the #trans phenomenon. Both, of course, are widely blamed upon some easy physical cause. Microplastics maybe, or chemtrails or nanotechnology or strange radiations beamed into cell phones or YouTube hypnotism vidoes or—you name it. "Sin as contagion" is too easy an explanation for them; it's become almost all they can imagine as a cause for any psychological or social mishap. It must be something in the water, something in the air, something broadcast by villains over the radio.

Not that anyone who talks this way really has the will to stop the calamity, mind you. The poisoning or corruption via technology isn't talked about as something that can really be fought except by...culling the infected.

~Chara