There's a disgusting inversion going on right now where people try to justify incel behavior by saying men are lonely. This makes people feel bad about pushing back on this, because it sounds like you're a callous person that doesn't care about the very real pain of loneliness?

No. This is a nonsense trap.

Women get lonely. Black people get lonely. Loneliness is a real problem.

But loneliness is not justification for *checks notes* becoming a literal nazi and electing a racist dictator.

1/N

Loneliness, combined with an extreme sense of entitlement, leads people to believe that they should be able to be terrible people, and yet somehow not lonely. It doesn't work that way.

And a lot of that loneliness is self-imposed!

White US toxic masculinity is a prison where you are your own warden. There are all these silly rules that keep white men in the US lonely and unhappy. Like seriously, we have news anchors telling men not to enjoy ice cream because that's not "manly?" Really?

2/N

Show me a happy white man in the US, and I'll show you a man that rejects most of these rules. "🧔🏻‍♂️Who made that a rule? Who says I have to follow it? LOL! No. 😋🍦"

But then we've got other men:

🧔🏻‍♂️Men suffer so much! The loneliness is real! No one cares about our mental health!

👩🏼That sounds hard! Therapy helped me --

🧔🏻‍♂️No!

👩🏼OK... well talking to friends also --

🧔🏻‍♂️No!

👩🏼OK... wow. Well, helping others can build a sense of community --

🧔🏻‍♂️No!

👩🏼What do you think will help you?

🧔🏻‍♂️ Trump!

3/N

And yes, there are Black incels and manosphere podcast bros, as well.

White US men do not have a monopoly on using "loneliness plus entitlement" to justify mistreating women.

The twisted thinking is the same.

A better way to deal with loneliness, is to understand why you are lonely, and then to address that. Maybe it's depression or another very real mental health issue. Maybe it's your living situation. But I promise you, the cause is never "Not enough fascism in the world!"

4/4

@mekkaokereke
Moar Fascism *CAN* make other people as miserable as they are, though.
@FeralRobots @mekkaokereke
Fascism has a pretty sharp S-curve between 🤷🏼‍♀️🤷🏻‍♂️ and 💀 without much "miserable" in between
@saraislet @mekkaokereke
fair, I should have put a lot more "(or so they think)" in there.
@mekkaokereke truly the Land Of The Free

@mekkaokereke

I wear Crocs, because they're the only shoes that fit my giant feet. I pick fun ones, because they amuse me.

At least once a month, some dude says something about them and my masculinity.

I look them in the eye and say quietly, "I have no doubt I'm a real man."

They wither and flee. Every time.

I go back to enjoying my ice cream.

@mwl @mekkaokereke I was talking to the 19 year old who just started college this year over the weekend. He was dismayed at how common homophobic slurs are at his school. “I guess I just didn’t know since I mostly was around theatre nerds?”

@mwl I never really thought about Crocs and masculinity.

I despise Crocs, because they were the assigned footwear when I was incarcerated. I don't like being reminded of the prison industrial complex.

Admittedly, Crocs aren't unique in this regard. There were other "upgraded" footwear individuals who had copious amounts of commissary funds could purchase. I also despise seeing those footwear.

But, an attack on masculinity? At least any time I was locked up, gender segregation was still a thing, they seem very, perhaps excessively, masculine given that I was incarcerated with other men.

Anyway, if they fit your feet, more power to you!

The real solution to being triggered from PTSD from the prison industrial complex isn't about changing footwear anyway, it's about abolishing prisons.
@mekkaokereke

@teajaygrey @mwl @mekkaokereke

Crocs are also straight-up plastic pollution landfill, if you need more reasons to hate them.

They're also a terrible employer. & suppliers to the prison industrial comples.

I would love to see them yeeted into the sun.

@teajaygrey @mwl @mekkaokereke

But also: abolish prisons 👍

@cavyherd @teajaygrey @mwl @mekkaokereke Abolish prisons? Where would you put murderers? Maybe we need a penal colony.

@mwl @mekkaokereke

my daughter wanted to upgrade her phone

i told her her phone was fine

she kept pestering me

then i noticed her current phone was better than mine

so we swapped: i got her phone, she got the one she wanted

and...

i kept her pink sparkly super girly phone case

i did it because it's funny. but also, i'm lazy

so here i am, an old hetero guy, with a sparkly pink phone case

a secure man doesn't care

but a lot of men out there are insecure. and then they get manipulated

@benroyce @mwl @mekkaokereke FWIW, my phone is pinky purple, and I bought it that way. 😁
Also, I remember my PhD supervisor telling me once that he "wouldn't be caught dead" wearing trousers like the ones I had in that moment, which were indeed dark pink. 😂
@benroyce my husband would totally do the same thing.

@benroyce @mekkaokereke

but you can use that phone case to embarrass your daughter!

Any REAL man understands that takes precedence over any variety of performative masculinity. 

@mwl @mekkaokereke

exactly

you're not a real father if you aren't making your daughter "die of cringe"

so you lean into it

it is the solemn duty of all fathers to embarrass their daughters

unfortunately, she's onto me, and now she just rolls her eyes

@benroyce @mwl @mekkaokereke we need a cure to masculine insecurity

@mwl @mekkaokereke this is my stupid masculinity story

I was at the gym with my friend, me, early 40s, him late 40s. Out of nowhere he made a dick size joke.

I started coming up with a retort about how no, actually I had the larger penis (as one does) but then I had a sudden moment of clarity at the absurdity of the situation.

“Excuse me but I already have six children. Like, what else do you want from me?”

I realized I never have to worry about that shit ever again (and in fact, never did)

Minimal Toe Shoes Banned by Army - Trailspace

Minimal toe shoes, like Vibram FiveFingers, have caught on among running and fitness buffs. But if you're in the Army, forget 'em. The funky toe shoes are now banned for official Army training, because they "detract from a professional military image."

@mekkaokereke They don’t want help. They want to punish others for their pain.
@ramsey @mekkaokereke I have the feeling they don't even particularly want to be right, they just want to frame others as wrong. Doesn't matter in what way, just wrong.
@mekkaokereke this sounds like something they would throw at a woman, tbqh
@Ashedryden @mekkaokereke You can see the double standard when folks are handwringing about “the loneliness epidemic in men” but then also making fun of the “childless cat lady” bc she’s “going to be alone when she’s old.”

@sidereal @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke The only way they know how to interact with women is the Neg them, including the childless cat lady thing.

I remember when I found out the "Spinster" was a term of respect for a woman who had employment and was self sufficient until men got sad and made it an insult.

@sidereal @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke

Why a "loneliness epidemic" only for men?

Anecdotally, though, it seems true. I see a lot of women walking alone these days (even without dogs!) and they seem pretty happy about it

It could be historical discrimination leveling out

Men seem lonely because they used to be able to force women to marry them

Women seem happy because they’re finally allowed to be alone

The answer (as noted) is for men to get over themselves

@peterbutler @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke Gonna be totally honest. It feels like I live in a different universe than some of these guys. It is actually not that hard to meet and date people in the USA in the 21st century. There are like so many specialized dating apps. There are also so many people who are burnt out on dating apps, wishing they could meet someone in person. But you have to be kind, and actually respect women, and some of these fools will never do that.
@peterbutler @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke I honestly think if there is a loneliness epidemic it’s more because people are working too much (and/or spending too much time commuting) to connect with their community/friends/family and do things like go on dates. But people would rather blame women or something. Anything but focusing on the rich people ripping us off 🙃

@sidereal @peterbutler @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke It surprises me to see someone praising dating apps in this context; I find them horribly alienating. I'm also reflecting today on how different people's feelings about sexuality and relationships can be, and it does seem like some people thrive on them.

By and large, I do think there's been a methodical elimination of public social life. Part of it is the deliberate elimination or privatization of any public spaces, including virtual spaces.

@foolishowl @sidereal @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke

I think the internet/smartphones is part of it

I don’t know if that's true, but it *feels* like there are far less people out and about because they’re inside on their phones or computers

The loss of non-commercial public spaces has been happening for decades, but this “loneliness epidemic" definitely feels like a Web3.0 era thing

I also find Internet relationships to have an "uncanny valley” effect — not quite the same as IRL friendships

@peterbutler @sidereal @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke I feel like what I sometimes have heard called "nerd culture" used to thrive on the Internet. It had problematic aspects -- a lot of misogyny in particular -- but I felt that we could communicate in text in a way we couldn't so easily in person. For me at least, autism likely had a lot to do with it.

Early MMOs, for instance, had a significant social aspect to them, that I feel was rationalized away in favor of efficient gameplay.

@peterbutler @sidereal @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke Several times people I knew in MMO roleplaying formed romantic relationships, where they'd actually travel to meet each other, and later lived together. I have a hard time imagining that happening with current MMOs, although there's a lot of online role-playing that I could imagine leading to such relationships.
@foolishowl yeah there’s lots of great research out there about human communication and the positive impacts of technology (the internet in particular) @peterbutler @sidereal @mekkaokereke
@foolishowl @sidereal @peterbutler @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke I found my partner through a dating app. One thing I appreciate about them is that I'm not always great at reading social clues (are they flirting or are they kind?) so I found the inherent directness of dating apps helpful.
@sidereal @peterbutler @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke I would also blame service industry jobs getting people unpredictable schedules too. I'm always missing social events because I can't even tell you when I'm working two weeks out. It literally changes every week what days and time
@fluffykittycat @sidereal @peterbutler @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke yeah all my working kids have this (even the vet has these on call things where a cow can be born at anytime). The ice cream store worker can check on like Thursday for next week; direct social services provider for mentally ill has a similar set up.
@jayalane @sidereal @peterbutler @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke it makes it hard to make plans and impossible to have a regularly reoccurring weekly in personal social activity. imagine how less lonely people would be if everyone's work schedules were regular enough that you could pick a day and time for a D&D sesh or hitting the gym together

@sidereal @peterbutler @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke I had a lot of trouble dating in my youth, back in the 80s and early 90s, and think a lot of my problem was that I got loneliness all mixed up with a ridiculous type of status anxiety. Yes, I got lonely, but I was also deeply afraid that I was a loser for not having a girlfriend, and the quest for a relationship was really partly a quest to level up in guy culture.

The resulting desperation can be really unattractive. Also, if your real audience is not the women themselves but other men, you create obstacles for yourself: that girlfriend had better be really impressive! You get picky in ways that are being externally imposed, nothing to do with who might be a good fit for you.

I didn't have any success until I learned to relax and stop worrying that somebody might be keeping score.

I suspect this is the fundamental problem a lot of these dudes are having.

@sidereal @peterbutler @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke You'll notice that a lot of "manosphere"/"PUA"/"MRA" stuff is about these weird grading and scoring systems: they're obsessed with things like facial symmetry and waist-to-hip ratios, all these "objective" measurements of women but also of themselves.

And that stuff is also a classic element of racist/fascist eugenic thinking. So the latter comes naturally once you're deep in the pit.

@mattmcirvin @sidereal @peterbutler @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke an odd method for overcoming length limits. I hope that's ok, I was not committed enough to splitting into a proper thread. Also not sure about the specific person I was replying to it was more just meant for young and frustrated people.

@jayalane @sidereal @peterbutler @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke I think pop culture of 40 years ago was actually MORE toxic than today's when it came to this stuff; you had comedies aimed at teenagers going on about the age after which boys were basically ruined if they hadn't gotten laid, that kind of thing.

But what there wasn't was the online culture devoted to telling guys who were anxious about this stuff that it was women's fault for rejecting them. They were more on their own, which might have felt worse but didn't actively lead them to these very dark places.

@mattmcirvin @jayalane @sidereal @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke

That sounds right to me. Rape culture and misogyny were far more prevalent in popular movies, etc, but there wasn’t the same online echo chamber reflecting and reinforcing it 24/7/365

@peterbutler @mattmcirvin @sidereal @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke and in real life. The percentage of 18 year olds who experienced sexual abuse or sexual assault in their life has fallen by about fifty percent since then. (E.g in 1986 it was roughly 1/3 girls and 1/6 boys. Now it is half that. Still a lot but definitely a societal change to be proud of. )

@peterbutler @jayalane @sidereal @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke Because it was a pop-culture fad the movies and TV shows spent a lot of time playing up the importance of the jock/nerd distinction, and the older I get the more meaningless I think that is.

It led to the infamous "I'm a nice guy" phenomenon, where straight guys who still had a lot of terrible ideas about women thought of themselves as virtuous because they theoretically valued intelligence and weren't quarterback date-rapists. But that's a hell of a low bar.

@peterbutler The term incel was actually invented by a woman in Ontario who couldn't find a sexual partner. It got appropriated and turned into something else by men who feel entitled to sex with women they view as desirable objects. The problem here is them not seeing people as people and feeling entitled to sex with hot women (without paying for it). It's all grandiosity, narcissism and not seeing women as people on the male incel side. It's perhaps understandable in younger teenage boys who are trying to figured stuff out, which is who the predatory men target, if they don't have someone to help them navigate their social anxieties and learn to become friends with girls. @sidereal @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke

@fifilamoura @peterbutler @sidereal @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke

I gotta ask: why is “treat people like people” so hard for “boys” to understand? Is this a cis binary thing I’m not getting?
(Or am I missing something: Do cis girls *want* special gendered treatment?)

@MxVerda It's not innately hard for most boys. Plenty of boys and men see girls and women as people and equals. Some people, including some female people, see others as objects to be exploited and not fellow people with a right to agency. But our culture and society tends to promote women as objects and has some very weird values around sex and partnership. This is partly religious in origin. This is playing out politically and socially with fascism and White supremacy being the crystallization of these ideas about other people only being objects to be exploited. @peterbutler @sidereal @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke

@MxVerda @fifilamoura @sidereal @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke

I was a reactionary conservative when I was 13 or 14. It’s a dumb age

Not racially — I wasn’t raised with (explicit) White supremacy — but I did grow up with ingrained sexism

For me it was pure chauvinism/male supremacy. Men are tougher, stronger, and smarter, and women are supporters

I eventually grew up

>> Do cis girls *want* special gendered treatment?

Many do, i.e women should be put on pedestals,, e.g. beauty pageants

@fifilamoura @mekkaokereke Yep! And also this involves the kids being actively taught to be that way, because when they're younger they don't need to be taught to be friends with girls. It's not natural for them to *not* make friends with girls, it's the people who surround them (whether that's parents, teachers, friends, clergy, etc etc) who start teaching them they "can't" be friends with girls and set them up to be fed into the misogynists' pipeline.
@peterbutler @sidereal @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke women also tend to be better at friendships and community.

@peterbutler @sidereal @Ashedryden @mekkaokereke I haven't dug into it *too* deeply but the Surgeon General's "loneliness epidemic" reports suggest that women are better at being single than men are. A "lonely" woman develops friendships and community, whereas lonely men do not. What men do instead is what makes the phenomenon alarming.

It's a description of the symptoms of a social epidemic with dire consequences. I haven't seen an official policy solution suggested.