People who rant about how terrible it is that you can't buy a non-Smart TV any more.

You know you don't have to plug the TV into the Internet, right?

I've got two. One acts as a big monitor for my laptop. The other one has a media player box & games console connected.

You're allowed to use a heavily subsidised device in a different manner from which it was intended.

@Edent a lot of them can’t skip the initial setup that requires internet
@graphite Which ones?
All of mine have worked just fine.
@Edent @graphite yeah, I've heard this too. If I need to buy a TV I'll be carefully checking before I buy, to make sure I don't buy a useless device. And I'm annoyed that I'll have to do that research or take that risk! Even if it turns out OK, it's an extra complication of buying one I could do without.
@Edent for now you can. Prey they do not alter the deal. Ideally by buying non smart to prove the market

@falken
But if you buy a non-smart TV and don't connect it, they'll know that X% of their customers don't use smart features.
That's just as powerful a market signal.

(ITYM "Pray".)

@Edent that assumes they actually have a metric for that. Usually we only see cut down featuresets when a company wants to do market segmentation or there is an actual production cost for parts.

In the TV realm that would mean you cut off a continuous revenue stream for extending the life-time of a Device, why would you do that, when you could also offer a 3€/month subscription to get rid of ads and sell the same devices?

@Edent honestly wouldn't trust it anyway. Only a matter of time before they make you connect it for updates "for your own security" or does some other bullshit I can't even conceive of until it happen
@engravecavedave
How would that even work? If it isn't ever connected, how would it know there were updates?
What bullshit do you think a disconnected appliance can do?
Idk man. Any apple device automatically adds you to their interconnected mesh grid if you have either Wifi or Bluetooth. They even have a new feature where airdrop continues to transfer files on 4G even out of range from your friend who sent it. Amazon devices automatically do that. What if you got a Samsung TV, doesn't connect to internet but has Bluetooth capabilites on ... and it connects to other Samsung devices in your vicinity and sends it data. I don't trust these companies at this point
@engravecavedave
I suggest checking your carbon monoxide alarms.

@Edent will do

Edit: Look, I know it sounds incredibly paranoid and tbh I would've thought it sounded crazy myself a few years ago as well ... and it probably is tbf. We're just at a point in time where pretty much any out there conspiratorial tin foil hat surveillance theory that would've been laughed at decades ago keeps being revealed to the public or found out in studies.

I'm at a point where I just wouldn't want a smart TV in my home, disconnected or not

@engravecavedave the simpler idea would be: it could just force you to update after X months and stop working till you do. I don't know of anything that does that though

@Edent

But if I don't connect it to the internet, how is it going to update to the latest version of it's OS that protects me from attackers that come from the internet?

I also hate how it spies on me constantly, all I want from it is to learn my every preference and desire so it can suggest what show should I consume next.

And I need it connected to the wifi so I don't have to get up and plug a cable to show my guests the funny video of my private life that I shared publicly on my socials!

@Edent the main problem I have with them is how flakey and slow the OS is for them these days. My TV takes ~30 seconds for me to be able to switch to a different input (on the times it actually works and doesn’t mysteriously close the input selection window).
@Marcus
You should return it as defective. All the smart TVs I have switch pretty much instantly.
@Edent I’ve had it a few years now. 🤷 Which makes have you gone with / recommend?
@Marcus
Most recent is a 4K Hisense. A 4K Toshiba/Vestel. And an old 3D Panasonic.
@Edent A lot of them bug you every time you turn them on if you do this. I suppose there's probably some way to fix this/jailbreak/whatever but... that's more than I want to mess with it really
@tomw
Which ones do that? I have a Hisense, Panasonic, and Toshiba. None of them bug me.
@Edent Been a while since I had one but Samsung did
@Edent Aren't smart Tv stupidly slow to bootup and all that though?
@lanodan
No. Mine switch on about as quickly as my "dumb" monitor.
@lanodan @Edent Yes, and in the case of Sony the last pre-Android TVs running Sony software were slower still. Best used as a monitor for a raspberry pi LibreElec client.

@Edent

True, but there is the possibility they will automatically connect to any open wifi around you.

@FuckElon
I mean, sure. And maybe they have snuck in a SIM card and cellular radio, or perhaps a satellite phone, or sending psychic signals back to the manufacturer 🤔

If you're at that level of paranoia, wrap your TV in tinfoil.

(Also, where in the world are you that your neighbours have open WiFi?)

@Edent

I mean, sure, it is not like we have a history of them doing sneaky things....🤔

https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/blog/2017/02/what-vizio-was-doing-behind-tv-screen

(Also, where in the world are you that your neighbours have open WiFi?)

1.Many business have open wifi. Many people live close to those business.

2.Clueless people + semi-clueless people who support clueless people and are tired of the calls asking for the password.

3. People who proclaim privacy is not important because "I have nothing to hide". Aka clueless people.

@Edent I saw a report some brands (Roku?) have started nagging or flashing LEDs when they’re not connected. You can obviously cover an LED but the software could start making things obnoxious for you if the manufacturers want.
@foobarsoft
Where did you see that report?
@Edent there was a hacker news thread a while ago and someone was reporting that they’re smart TV did that and they had to cover the LED
Bought a samsung and a roku tv. I don't know which one it was - but, for one of ... | Hacker News

@Edent @film_girl that doesn’t entirely solve the problems with them though. All that OS/UI adds noticeable startup time to the device and adds tons of buttons to remotes and adds lots of useless UI baggage to navigate whenever you have to do anything.

@Edent yep. The only thing on my Hisense Tv is that every few weeks, I will see a message saying the inbuilt Netflix app can’t connect.

My hope is that TVs don’t get more aggressive with the popups if you choose not to put it online.

@Edent for most I imagine it doesn’t occur to them that the option to not connect is available.
@Edent @film_girl Last I heard, if they don't have an ethernet connection, they will form adhoc insecure networks to try to make any sort of connection they can.
@apontious @Edent it isn’t that complex. If you don’t connect it to a wifi network and you don’t allow your apps to connect to other devices (easy to say no to or turn off), it’s literally a dumb terminal. If you want to use AirPlay or cast stuff to it, yeah, you’ll need to connect it to a network. That’s a trade-off and the super paranoid can get a pi-hole or similar DNS-level blocker service if so inclined. Or you know, don’t AirPlay or Cast to the TV but plug in a third-party box.
@Edent yes but I wouldn't be surprised if Smart TVs eventually come shipped with SIM cards or sneakernet devices like Kindles
@devnull
What do you mean by sneakernet?
@Edent I used the wrong term, I was referring to first and second generation Kindles that had 2G and 3G chips, and we're always connected to Amazon
@Edent I’ve been telling my friends and family something similar for years. My progress has been a mixed bag, but I persevere!
@Edent Yup, and buy a 10 dollar universal remote to go with it. Will be a better experience.
@Edent Not always possible. A former coworker's smart tv updated and started showing ads after it connected to a neighbor's unsecured wifi.
@Edent more and more of them give you no choice but to connect them, and some like the ones with Roku self connect to any open network near by automatically, I see this a lot from business free wifi portals catching Roku devices on networks I manage.
@anthonylee
How so you know that the TV owner hasn't deliberately chosen the open network?
@Edent tvs where display tvs in a buisness, setup new mesh network with a open network attached to a portal that users needed to accept usage to be a guest, all Roku tvs in the building auto connected to this new network, had a new not used network name.
@Edent first hand checked, I was the one who setup the network and had to go around and force the TVs to connect to a hidden network with no internet access as their kept hitting the guest network throwing non accepted client errors.
@Edent could have been that specific tv brand doing it but it had embed Roku tv in it. I have had smart TVs where the picture is not calibrated and bad and requires you to connect to the network to update and get a better picture.
@anthonylee Is it possible to physically disconnect all networking chips from a #Roku? (Ideally in a reversible way that can be successfully hidden when exercising warranty, if such a thing exists.) I only found https://community.roku.com/t5/Wi-Fi-connectivity/Physically-Remove-WiFi-Module/td-p/850131 so far.
Physically Remove WiFi Module

Good morning, I work in a facility that prohibits wifi devices.  I have a Roku Ultra and and am looking to physically remove the wifi module, like you would in a TV.  I'm pretty sure I have ID'd the module.  My only concern is, that wifi direct is likely on the same module.  If so, that would take a...

Roku Community
@Edent I don’t rant - but I do see “acceptability border creep” setting in. Today, you can disconnect, yes; but what about 2 years from now ? Once every supplier makes conx-only devices, what’s stopping them from forcing a constant server ping to use the device ? Marketing signals won’t work anymore since, hey, this is the market now.

@Edent I’m actively looking for a non-smart TV at the moment. I’m well aware that I can leave a smart TV disconnected, but also that this may limit functionality, or in some cases have the TV actively complain. Knowing which TVs will support this is a challenge.

I think the frustration is more that I’m (along with many other people) willing to spend money on something that is not easily available (but does exist).

@Edent @film_girl

You are going to find people asking you recommendations for sets that don’t automatically log on to wifi networks, or brick themselves if they cannot get on Internet.

@Edent Until those fuckers start putting LTE modems in them like they do with cars.
10 Best Dumb TVs (Non Smart Features) For Every Need In 2023

What To Know Dumb TVs prioritize privacy without internet connections, but can still be enhanced with smart features using streaming sticks. For up-to-date tech, devices like Roku or Amazon Firesticks provide the latest features, including

PointerClicker.com

@Edent @film_girl
When I purchased my last tv three years ago the first thing I did was to disable internet access.

But what would prevent tv makers from requiring internet access (and display ads) as a condition for using the tv?

@freediverx @film_girl
What would prevent you from returning it as defective and buying one which didn't do that?

@Edent @film_girl
Well for one thing, TV makers might all go down the same path as printer makers, to the point where eventually there are few if any good options remaining.

All these manufacturers seem to have decided to sell TVs at or below cost and make their money via data collection and advertising.