@Bam @thetitanborn

Same. To be honest, I'm trying to do more than hope. I'm willing to be here while many parts of it are not yet great for Black users, and work with all the awesome folks that are making it better.♥️👍🏿

I'm following in the footsteps of the Black Mastodon users that have been here for years, who started when it was much less welcoming than what I experienced, so that hopefully the Black folk that join after me, will have an even easier time than me.

@Bam @thetitanborn It's fascinating to see that about half of the replies to @thetitanborn 's post, are cringe-worthy forms of "I haven't seen any problems for Black users / your post is unnecessary / we don't see race here."

So yeah... there's work to do.

@mekkaokereke @Bam @thetitanborn any specific things allies can do to help? My brain jumped to helping finance and support primarily black or BIPOC instances but I’m a bit sheltered/privileged and there’s bound to be a lot I’m missing.

@dave @Bam @thetitanborn

1) Don't ask Black users to CW discussions of their own racism.

2) Don't be on a server where mods mistreat Black folk.

3) Support the mods on your own server, financially and otherwise.

4) Don't engage with sea lions that say "Mistreatment? Here? prove it!" There have been enough threads shared on Black folk receiving racism. Individually convincing each one is exhausting, and expecting that is a tactic of bad faith actors.

@mekkaokereke @dave @Bam @thetitanborn I very much appreciate your openness about the challenges here, and I want to do my part to build a community here consistent with my values. This includes not placing the burden of building and protecting the community on members of marginalized groups that are being mistreated. Are there ways as an end user (beyond reading the server rules) for me to evaluate the quality of moderation of an instance? I'm new and building my fediverse toolkit.

@lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn

The best way today, is to follow a bunch of Black users and see their experience. As I've pointed out this is very insufficient, as it means that many Black users experience N*zis first, then move to a better server.

I've been online for many years, so I'm used to N*zis and their death threats. But for many Black users, this experience is jarring.

Worse than the N*zis, is the "regular users."

https://hachyderm.io/@mekkaokereke/109388611222845153

mekka okereke :verified: (@[email protected])

@[email protected] No, lets! 🙂 I am "bashing" an instance. (If providing useful feedback to protect other users is considered bashing?) The instance I'm bashing is "Mastodon dot cloud." The reason I'm bashing it is because the moderation is insufficient to protect users from a vile instance clearly run by self proclaimed racists for the purpose of harassing Black people, Jewish people, and members of the LGBTQA community. There are better moderate instances users should go to.

Hachyderm.io

@lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn
An instance like mastodon.cloud can say that they don't tolerate N*zis in their "server rules."

But the reality is, a Black user on that server can receive racist death threats complete with snuff images and video of Black folks and women being killed. Flagging for moderation did nothing. The Black person leaving that instance and warning other Black users to choose a better 1st server, gets the Black user blocked.🤡

@lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn

My issue is not with N*zis. Trash people and sociopaths will always exist.

My issue is with the violence inherent in insufficient moderation coupled with a "use CW!" culture that denies the self reflection that would allow Mastodon users to realize that outside of 4ch*n, many Black users' *worst online experience ever*, was on Mastodon.

If you don't follow Black users and listen to them, you would never know this.

@lawyerjsd
How do you mean "wait, what?"

That comes over as though you might possibly be thinking it's nonsense - is that how you meant it?

Or is it more that you want someone to walk you through the previous conversation that's been running for a long time about Black people's experiences of the Fediverse?

@unchartedworlds What I mss as n is that I switched from the hellsite to Mastodon in hopes it would be better here. I’m pained to hear otherwise.

@lawyerjsd @mekkaokereke @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn Harassment is very difficult to track on large instances because most of the time it's done in private messages and the rest are a flood of micro aggressions just subtle enough not to appear racist to moderators.

And local timelines on large instances go so fast that people can never notice that stuff. The only people who notice are the folks experiencing it, and the attackers.

So by the time you document one attack enough to get a single person banned, other 30 are still harassing you. It's an uphill battle and eventually you give up and move to another server or quit mastodon altogether.

So BIPOC folks would need to organize to barely counter this shit, but how to organize when the very tool you need to organize is becoming the tool that harassers use against you?

So, you got what, 10, 20 mods on a server that has over 200,000 users?

A tiny moderation team on a server that large is not gonna do shit.

@lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn Right now, a bunch of white Mastodon users are thinking "Racist snuff images? OMG!!! I didn't know it was that bad! This is awful!"

But a bunch of other white Mastodon users are thinking, "He really should have put mentions of (his own) death threats behind a Content Warning. And... he seems to have moved servers? So what's the problem? Why is he still saying bad things about his old server?"

🙂🙃

@lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn

The paradox is: you only know about my experience and that of other Black users, because we refuse to play the little "Stepford Wives content warning game" when talking about what happened to us on this idyllic little platform. And you don't know how widespread the problem is, because of Mastodon design choices: crappy search, CWs, weaponized politeness, rejection of the very idea of screening servers for moderation.

@mekkaokereke @lewriley @Bam @thetitanborn that’s fucked, I’m sorry to hear that that kind of behavior is going unaddressed.
Re: CWs, I think a lot of folks feel like it’s a blanket to hide the less savory parts of life from people with trauma. Upon some reflection, this scenario reminds me of a phrase used in talking about police and racist Karen interactions: that it’s there to minimize white discomfort.

@dave @lewriley @Bam @thetitanborn If there's a police shooting and there is a video? I put a CW around that. I also put CWs around topics like disordered eating, etc.

But I experience racism almost every day, as do most Black US citizens. I'm not going to start every other sentence with "CW" just to make y'all feel better.

Hiding racism to protect white feelings is just more racism. I won't do it. I do respect folks' right to Block me for that. 👍🏿

@mekkaokereke Worst case, you get blocked/filtered/whatever, and then allies like myself who are not (Quoting India Walton here) tender dicked white men, can take the info you shared, and "filter it" with the requisite emotional labor, and get other white people to see it.

@mekkaokereke @dave @lewriley @Bam @thetitanborn
There is most definitely no need for you to CW your lived experience. Anyone who suggests it is anyway hasn't bothered to think. It might be someone else's idea of politics (meaning racism) but it is your life. (I wish I could underline life).

I very much hope that you don't get many thoughtless and clueless people. Sending you very best wishes.

@mekkaokereke @dave @lewriley @Bam @thetitanborn at a certain point, doesn't this whole discourse kinda just work out to asking you to put "CW: I'm black" on everything? Wtf
@mekkaokereke @dave @lewriley @Bam @thetitanborn What if there was a service that ran on a mastodon instance that scanned all posts and then edited those with offensive comments by adding a CW (i.e.: the first step is not YOU or ME adding the CW, it is a Mastodon service that is based on civics and basic behavioral dignity? Just curious (I 'm not that smart, just wanting to learn more about moderation as I start moderating my instance).
@mekkaokereke @dave @lewriley @Bam @thetitanborn The scanning CW is the first step. What it affords is a filtering to the most offensive. From there, the site administrator will decide on each post that has been CW'd by a scan what the admin action should be.
@mekkaokereke @dave @lewriley @Bam @thetitanborn the attempts to control Black expression of racism by gating it behind CW etc strikes me as just another attempt to shush difficult topics behind a screen of genteel "politeness." I grew up in a white civil rights activist household in the South and I was taught early that much white Southern "politeness" is actually a control tactic used to protect the status quo, and on a gut level this feels like the same thing.

@mrcompletely @mekkaokereke @dave @lewriley @Bam @thetitanborn
Yes!!!
I've thought this, but never felt brave enough to say it. I think CW has gone crazy and is actually preventing discussion.

(I often just scroll over CW posts and don't even open them at all)

@Godfrey642 @mekkaokereke @dave @lewriley @Bam @thetitanborn to be clear, I also think CWs are underused by some of the masto population. I like the CW feature and believe in it, and I'm not weighing in on the argument about where the principal locus of responsibility for filtering content is.

But I want non-white ppl to want to be here, and making room for free expression of their experience is clearly a requirement for that; and silencing that conversation has the familiar stench I mentioned.

@mekkaokereke @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn Sharing this info is a SERVICE to all other users. I doubt I’m alone in my appreciation of it. It’s reaaaaaaaaaal hard at this point to imagine anyone being “unaware” of the copious bullshit a subset of people pull online if they can get away with it (and various sites’ various responses or non-responses). The only person I followed from that instance was a dude who posts a ton (at least on Twitter)about local liberal issues, Dem politics & city govt, that kind of thing. Not a great look for him to still be there, but also not mind blowingly surprising, either

@mekkaokereke

Both of those scenarios suck. What hurts for me as a white person is that far too many other white folks still don't understand or believe that Black folks face a constant barrage of "little" things (little as in perceived less than overt racism and death threats) on a daily basis. The casual and systemic varieties of racism.

I struggle to find ways to get other white folks to understand that someone else's lived experience can be just as real and genuine even though they've never experienced it. Heck, it's been challenging for my past self too.

I've lived in the Midwest my whole life, so no experience with earthquakes or hurricanes, but even though I've never been directly affected by either doesn't mean that hurricanes and earthquakes are not real or are not deadly. Few would argue that hurricanes aren't real, yet many will try to argue that systemic or casual racism isn't real, isn't common, or isn't just as (if not more) impactful.

To help myself understand things I sometimes think of buckets. I think of an analogy with filling up a 5 gallon bucket. If you try to dump 6 gallons into a 5 gallon bucket all at once, it'll certainly splash everywhere, run over, and be a get everywhere. It happens really rapidly and everyone around can witness the violence as the water spills everywhere. To me this is overt racism like N*zis?

But if someone slowly pours liquid into that same 5 gallon bucket over time, it's still gonna fill up and eventually reach a point of overflow. It may not be as immediately jarring or rapid, but that bucket will still be full, weighing a person down, no relief in sight. And if the person or system fills that bucket really carefully, nobody will even notice the bucket getting full, except for the person holding the bucket.

@mekkaokereke @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn the "use CW" doesn't stop me from hearing this. Racism and CW are 2 different topics. Thanks for the knowledge about that shit instance though. Tip: #Fediblock is a hashtag to learn which instances should be blocked. Mastodon.cloud sounds like it should be blocked. I hope hachyderm is treating you well. Mastodon is a mirror of real world so racism is here as well. We can block their home though.

@Callistobeast @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn

You're talking, not listening.

"Use CW" does stop you from hearing it, because some Black users get blocked for not using CWs, but more just leave for social networks that are better for Black folk.

Yes, I know about Fediblock. Doesn't help if when I joined, mastodon.cloud wasn't blocking even the most notorious "only exist to be N*zi" instances.

"racism is everywhere" is a BS excuse.

@mekkaokereke @Callistobeast @dave @Bam @thetitanborn The architecture of the Fediverse does not (yet?) afford simple ways of preventing N*zis and racists taking advantage of weaknesses in the system. The bare minimum we can do now is listen to and amplify the voices of folks who are impacted by these weaknesses. We can also lend our support to efforts to move us in promising directions. IMO, CWs are not for protecting us from seeing our own complicity in a flawed system.
@mekkaokereke @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn Well, I'm reading, and honestly no offence meant, but all I'm getting is that you're upset because your server moderator wants you to prefix your posts with CW? I assume content warnings? And that's worse than 8chan?
Are all the mastodon servers like that?

@Frankc1450 @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn Well, you're not reading very well, because you seem to have glossed right over the death threats part, and being sent racist images and videos of dead bodies and people killing women.

Based on the tone of your message, I'm choosing to disengage from further conversation with you. If that's your takeaway from this thread, I see this getting much worse before it gets better.

Be well! ✌🏿

@Frankc1450 @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn

I'm sure you're a fine person and mean well! 👍🏿

But re-explaining this to half the people on Mastodon one by one gets exhausting, and I'm just not going to do it.

Everything I need to say on this topic is already in this thread.

@mekkaokereke @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn Well please accept my apology. I didn't read your entire thread. I never got to the part about the threats and other terrible things. I really had a hard time following. I don't know what to say, everything coming to my mind just sounds like shallow shit. I'm sorry. I'll stop here.

@Frankc1450 @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn
Apology is very much accepted! ♥️👍🏿

I said I was sure that you were a good person. It feels good to have my faith in people justified!

There are way more good people than Nazis, and we know how to work together and care about each other.

We win in the end.

@Frankc1450 @mekkaokereke @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn oops, now I need to take back some of my compliant. I did the same thing and replied before I read down the thread.
@TheSteve0 @mekkaokereke @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn it's hard to follow threads sometimes, there's threads off of threads. But no problem Steve.

@Frankc1450 @mekkaokereke @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn WTF sir, you not only missed the whole point, you missed the point he made in that sentence. That point about 4chan was that actual black people had the very real experience that, second to 4Chan, mastodon was the most racist (and racism tolerant community) social community.

He went above and beyond by even replying to you. Do better

@TheSteve0 @mekkaokereke @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn so, this was a while ago but you're right. I did miss a great deal of the thread and the point. I'm grateful that he replied and I am trying to do better.
@TheSteve0 @mekkaokereke @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn thanks Steve. I didn't realize the importance of being an anti-racist until recently.

@mekkaokereke @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn It's hard to read this and not flash back to Martin Luther King's "Letter From Birmingham Jail" and his statement that white moderates are more of an obstacle to progress than the hardcore KKK.

The more things change, the more they stay the same. I'm really sorry.

@mekkaokereke @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn I keep seeing the initials CW in posts and haven't been able to find out what it stands for in this use case, which I'm pretty sure has nothing to do with radio transmitted Morse code, might have to do with culture war. Any help, anybody?
@mekkaokereke @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn I'm new to masto, and sorry to hear of this problem. I hope it's getting better.
@Bam @dave @thetitanborn @lewriley @mekkaokereke wow very disappointing. Even at tootn.social that is rule number 1. We believe in #startrek future over here!
@mekkaokereke @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn That series of events would be all I’d need to migrate immediately, tbh. New user here so maybe there are more layers of hassle to the process than I’m aware of, but keeping one’s follows and followers and hitting eject seems like a very basic minimum response to this. Hard to imagine any acceptable reason to continue to be associated with grossness like that, and will tell me something about any users going forward from that instance: that it doesn’t bother them enough to move elsewhere. But looks like there’s a block feature here too, so I won’t need to mull whether they are overtly racist trash sacks or just oblivious
@mekkaokereke @thetitanborn @dave @Bam @lewriley I left Mastodon.cloud when I realized it was being run by a crypto bro who didn’t really care about anything and who had defederated NONE of the Nazi instances.
Oh and here's the notice of the new ownership of Mastodon.cloud if you read Japanese.

https://www.danshihack.com/2020/06/12/junp/mstdnjp-2.html
「mstdn.jp / mastodon.cloud」終了せず、サービス譲渡し継続へ

サービス終了が発表されていたマストドンインスタンスの「mstdn.jp」「mastodon.cloud」が、米国のSujitech LLCに譲渡され、サービスが継続されることが発表されました。「mst…

男子ハック
@Brian Hawthorne; Mastodon.cloud has been run by Sujutech LLC since 2021. It formerly had Japanese maintainers since its inception; I have an account there since the beginning and lived in Tokyo at the time which was the primary reason I began my fediverse journey there.

https://news.mask.io/2021/02/07/the-first-official-application-of-decentralized-social-media-network-mastodon-will-come-online-this-summer-with-sujitech-llc-providing-technical-support

https://news.mask.io/2021/02/07/the-first-official-application-of-decentralized-social-media-network-mastodon-will-come-online-this-summer-with-sujitech-llc-providing-technical-support

https://sujitech.com/

The current maintainers are actually Chinese research students that are located in Illinois and in Japan; they also sponsor open-source initiatives in their native China.

This may be the reason why they haven't defederated from the problem instances... They simply don't know about it/want to maintain an open network with little moderation. Just mute/block on your account and don't worry about the haters (if they're not being malicious towards you.)
Mask — The Portal to the New, Open Internet.

The Natural Law of Privacy, Now Being Enforced.

News
@starrwulfe “don't worry about the haters (if they're not being malicious towards you.)” No, that is exactly the wrong approach.
The haters are not malicious to me because my name and bio and photo tag me as a white man. On the other hand, they ARE being malicious to people of color, and I find that unacceptable. If the admins of mastodon.cloud don’t care about people being abused by haters on their instance, I cannot associate with that instance.
@Brian Hawthorne Last time I checked, I'm of color (black dude from St Louis, MO, bouncing between ATL and Tokyo these days) and in the 3+ years I've had it, I've never experienced any of this there-- @J L Gatewood (StarrWulfe) is my handle there and is my main "professional" account actually.

Really can't say much else because
  • I don't know the context surrounding the attack (was it another user of mastodon.cloud or did the attacker(s) come from another instance?
  • Mass blocking instances doesn't work quickly in practice with all the people coming into the fediverse; when this place was just a few refugees/hackers/alt pilgrims from other spaces, we all collectively coalesced around certain servers that fit our interests and it was easy for us to see who was doing what, where-- bad actors all came from certain hive instances that are easy to block. But now that you have literally hundreds of thousands of accounts on the big servers, it's gonna be hard to tame.
  • Just like being out on the street in public, we all have to be more defensive here on the "open internet" and use the tools provided to police our own accounts. Muting/blocking other accounts from talking to your individual account on X server is far easier and quicker than waiting for the mods to do something (if they even can). This is akin to learning self-defense tactics in the streets-- You're not gonna be able to count on the cops to come rescue you all the time.
  • blaming the instance you're actually on for an outside attack is like blaming your landlord for your apartment being broken into, especially when said landlord gave you -- door locks and an alarm and made you get renter's insurance. As someone who hosted servers for other people, there's only a certain number of things that can be done before it's considered over-reach and also impinges on the other people who are sharing the server too. Think about the other users at mastodon.cloud that interact with other users on whatever instance the attacker used? Now all the sudden they can't communicate with each other because of one bad actor.
I'm not mitigating this AT ALL, in fact I'm highly concerned because I'm a heavy user of that instance, but I also want to temper things a bit -- Never use dynamite where a small scalpel is likely the more appropriate tool here.
J L Gatewood (StarrWulfe) (@[email protected])

409 Posts, 114 Following, 126 Followers · Tokyoite, Atlantan, journalist, photographer, cloud engineer, open-source advocate, ramen enthusiast, train nerd, armchair urbanist, Cities: Skylines player/builder/modder.

mastodon.cloud
@mekkaokereke @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn @seldo what instance? It seems like this should be something that is put out so that instance can be blocked by everyone
@robert_said_what @mekkaokereke It was mastodon.cloud
@seldo where did the attacker come from? The victim is a mastodon.cloud account user if I'm following correctly...
@starrwulfe I mean the problem is not one attacker, the problem is the moderation response at mastodon.cloud. Gotta see the big picture.
@seldo @mekkaokereke thank you. that’s something that should be put out far and wide. That way people know where not to go and that instance can just be excised from the whole or they can fix the problem
@seldo — ok now that I see the big picture, yeah that’s terrible.

@robert_said_what — I’m sorry you had a bad experience at what otherwise has been a really good server to be on — I have been there since 2019 and it was my first (and only to date) mastodon server; I think the admins totally weren’t ready for this massive influx and are overwhelmed.

You can go and block poa . st in your profile settings (along with any user or sever) on an individual level though, but I recommend going to a smaller locally administered instance with 1000 accounts or less if possible so your friendly admin can be more attentive and responsive. The regional communities like the one @Bam is on are on the lookout for that kind of foolishness and are quick to put a stop to it.

Sadly, if your posts are talking about unfair treatment of any marginalized groups, it becomes troll bait quickly… 😔
@mekkaokereke @lewriley @dave @Bam @thetitanborn I left mastodon.cloud bc of bad moderation decisions like that. I saw toots from the admin saying they were working to improve mod training. Is moderation of toots about racism on mastodon.cloud improving, or should I keep directing people away from that instance?