Amateur Hour in the Executive Branch: Veterans on the War in Iran and the Commander in Chief Who Started It
At the end of March, with the Iran war entering its second month and the casualty count already climbing, I attended the No Kings protest in Austin looking for veterans. I found plenty of them. After the piece ran at Slate I heard from several others who werenât at the protest but wanted to add their voice to the record. In early April, I sat down with three veterans I know, including one I served with, for longer conversations.
Kyle Dean served with the 25th Infantry Division across multiple deployments in the Middle East and Pacific. Kyle voted for Trump once, in 2016. Heâs clear about why and equally clear about where he ended up.
âI was fed up with the whole system. Neither party felt like it represented people like me, and I thought maybe blowing the whole thing up a little was worth a shot. A lot of people made that calculation in 2016. Most of us didnât make it again.â
Kyle didnât. âMy opinion of him has declined at about the same rate as his cognitive abilities.â
Trumpâs attempted overthrow of the 2020 election results confirmed what Kyle already knew. âI was completely against him well before January 6th, but that was definitely one of the rubicons for me. It became clear this really was all about himselfâthe weaponization of every federal mechanism toward self-enrichment and the persecution of any opposition.â
Kyle didnât have much patience for Trumpâs performance as commander in chief. âHeâs an insult to everyone who has held the job before or ever served. That role comes with a responsibility that canât be flippantly dismissedânot by treating casualties with âthatâs the way it goes,â not by receiving dead Americans at Dover with a fake tough-guy look in your self-promoting, Chinese-made hat. He refuses to listen to experts, or anyone not from Fox News. Everything is an actâthe tough-guy persona, the ârespectâ for our military. All of it.â
On how we ended up at war with Iran, Kyle sounded like a lot of the veterans Iâd talked to at the protest. âIâm not even sure how this began. Nobody sat at the resolute desk and talked to me at 8pm about why this was necessary. Reasons and objectives change nearly hourly and depending on which sycophant has the mic. We all just woke up one morning and were at war with a formidable enemy. Seemingly not even Congress knows why.â
Kyle had some thoughts on how the war is going so far. âWeâve gone from demanding full surrender to begging the rest of the world to help and begging for negotiations. Right now Iran holds more power than they ever have, and when this ends they will be in a better position than they were.â
On where itâs heading, he didnât hedge. âIt seems almost certain we will be introducing ground troops. With no clear objective. Again.â He paused. âWe basically caught a skunk in a live trap.â
When I asked what he wanted people who havenât served to understand, he didnât soften it.
âPeople who havenât served should understand people like me arenât saying this as pacifists or never-Trumpers. This comes from people that know the costs, who understand what happens in a war and would rather use the military as a last resort or deterrence. The consequences of this will last generations. Go read a fucking book.â
***
Mike Cone is a Marine Corps infantry veteran who served as a mortarman and forward observer in Weapons Company, 2nd Battalion, 8th Marines. He has never had any illusions about Donald Trump. Mike, like Trump, is from New York, and his lack of surprise goes back decades.
âFrom the time I became aware of who he was, as a teen in the early 80s, I thought he was a horrible excuse for a human being. When he got elected the first time, I didnât expect anything good from the failed businessman with no moral compass who only cares about himself. I knew it was going to be a shit show.â
Watching Trump send people to war is something Mike takes personally. âHe dodged the draft during Vietnam, called Marines who gave their lives at Belleau Wood âlosers,â and constantly tries to belittle or fire any career military officer who doesnât agree with him. The man has no right to send anyone to warâespecially an illegal oneâor to be commander in chief for that matter.â
On how we got into Iran, Mike traced the line directly to Trumpâs ego and the people who knew how to play it. âThis illegal war started with Trumpâs ego being played by Netanyahu and Mohammed bin Salman. They got him to start the war theyâve been wanting for the last 47 years. Trump and his sycophant Hegseth went into this with no clear plan or objectives. They underestimated Iran and their capabilities. They had no plan for the Strait of Hormuz and its effect on the global economy, regardless of the lies to the contrary.â
At the Austin protest, Adrian, a former Army captain and war planner, told me about a graduate research paper heâd worked on in 2009 about that exact chokepointâthe Straitâhow critical it was, how catastrophic its closure would be. That paper went to Washington seventeen years ago. Mike Cone, who wasnât at the protest and hadnât heard any of that, arrived at the same place on his own.
The Pentagon personnel decisions landed hard. âHegseth, who is unqualified for his position, has now fired over a dozen senior officers and replaced them with unqualified yes-men.â
On the ground troops question, Mike laid out the geography and the history without much optimism. âIran is larger, more topographically challenging, and more internally unified than either Iraq or Afghanistanâboth countries the U.S. already invaded without achieving its initial objectives. Unfortunately, I do believe we will put troops on the ground, and more soldiers and Marines will die because Trumpâs ego will not allow him to pull out at this point. And through all of this, we have a Congress with no spine, unwilling to even attempt to stop the escalation.â
He had a lot to say about what most civilians donât understand. âI donât think most understand what it takes to serve. They think that by paying lip service and thanking you for your service theyâre doing their part, even when theyâre sincere. I donât think they understand the psychological and physical toll that warâespecially an illegal oneâcan have on an individual. I donât think they understand the difference between obeying a legal order and an illegal one. I donât think they can comprehend the logistics and the cost of war. And I donât believe they understand at all the feeling of being ordered to war by a commander in chief who has no respect for the military. Let that one sink in.â
Mike had one more thing, not for me, but for a specific audience.
âI have one question of my ownâfor veterans who served or are still serving and still support Trump, this administration, and this war: How could you?â
***
Adam House is a medically retired Army combat veteran who served with the 173rd Airborne Brigade in Afghanistan, and has spent years since then living and working abroad, most recently coaching Muay Thai in Thailand. Heâs spent enough time away from the country he served to know how it looks from the outside.
Adam didnât start with Iran. He started with January 6th, and with the fact that it somehow didnât disqualify Trump from anything. âIâm very disappointed in the American people for re-electing Trump as president after January 6th, 2021âthe Capitol insurrectionâand Trumpâs attempt to overturn the election. I thought he should have been disqualified from ever being allowed to run for any office again, according to the Constitution. And I think that itâs a sad comment that the American people were still comfortable voting for him after he has shown himself to be a literal terrorist, because his actions did get Americans killed.â
Adam pointed out that our entry into the Iraq conflict in 2003, another deeply unpopular war, was handled better than this. The bar he reaches for isnât a high one. âWhen I think back to the initiation of the global war on terror under the Bush administrationâregardless of how that played out, or how any of us may feel about how it played outâBush at least put together what at the time we called a âcoalition of the willing.â He did look for support from allies and friends around the world and tried to explain to the American people what we needed to do and why. What I see Trumpâs actions doing is not only lacking in both of those things, but he seems to be disregarding the wishes of the American people and actively alienating our friends and allies around the world.â
Adam coaches fighters and stays in contact with people across dozens of countries. He knows how this all reads from where theyâre standing.
âI know people on practically every continent on Earth, and just from my anecdotal experience, I can speak to the fact that what the Trump regime is doing is unpopular, especially as it relates to the war in Iran, and people around the globe are suffering. And the consequences of this are only just now beginning to be felt.â
âA lot of people who used to have respect for America may never forgive us for what weâre doing right now. Weâre only just beginning to feel the consequences. Theyâre going to be much more severe and much more numerous over time.â
On Americaâs enemies, Adam was direct. âOur enemies are laughing at us. And our friends around the globe right now are crying because of what they see us doing to ourselves. Our allies are horrified and scrambling to see how to pick up the slack thatâs left by the vacuum of leadership where America is no longer showing itself to be a true leader. But Americaâs enemies right now are laughing at us. And I believe many of them are actually exploring their options to see how they can take advantage of this current environment.â
He was of two minds about what that actually means. âOn one hand, if youâre Americaâs enemies right now, maybe you donât want to launch any kind of strikes or terrorist actions or military actions against us, because itâs very obvious that weâre shooting ourselves in the foot right now. And why attack somebody when theyâre self-destructing? On the other hand, I think America probably has other enemies that are looking at this situation and actively trying to figure out how they can take advantage of our current lack of leadership and how they can hurt America.â
I asked if he was thinking about Russia specifically.
âWe know for a fact that Russia and some of our other enemies around the globe, like China, for yearsâeven decades nowâhave continued to launch constant online, digital attacks against the United States. And we know that foreign adversaries are trying to use American political polarization to their advantage. Things like on Twitterâwe know that there are Russian bots, and they donât even care whether youâre radicalizing to the left or radicalizing to the right. Their whole focus is to just create further polarization. So they just want Americans to radicalize against one another. Theyâre kind of inserting themselves into the American body politic to take advantage of our own divisions here and just put gasoline on the fire of those divisions. Thatâs just one hint at how foreign governments are looking at American division and polarization right now, and our lack of leadership and the inept leadership that we have.â
When I asked what he hears from other veterans, across rank and background, the answer was bewildered clarity. âAs far as serious policy analysts, longtime professional military brass, academics in the field who spend their careers actively studying the issues that are relevant to the current U.S. actions in Iranâall the way down to people like me, who are just lower enlisted guys who served in combat years agoâwe all seem to be confused as to what the Trump regime is trying to do, and nobody can really make heads or tails of what theyâre doing. The Trump regimeâs actions are incoherent to everyone, even his own administration and allies.â
âIt just tells me that the Trump regime is chaotic, incompetent, maybe even senile, and negligent, and just basically screwing the pooch at such a level that itâs putting the American people and our constitutional republic in danger. The greatest threat to America right nowâthe greatest emergency that we faceâis the occupant of the Oval Office. Itâs like weâre standing on the brink of potential World War III, and itâs amateur hour in the executive branch of the U.S. federal government.â
Adam kept coming back to Afghanistanâthe interpreters and allies who stood with American soldiers like him, knowing what it would cost them if things went wrong.
âI know for a fact that there are American soldiersâveteransâwho are home living out our lives today because of the sacrifices that were made by our Afghan allies on the ground in Afghanistan. Individual Afghan interpreters and other supporters there literally put their lives on the line, put their families in danger, and some of them were even wounded and suffered a lot of negative consequences standing against their own fellow countrymen with the American military while we were there.â
âI donât care how many of them there areâany of them that want to escape the Taliban regime thatâs currently in power, I think itâs a debt of honor on our heads to help them do that.â
The Afghan allies question connects directly to Iran in ways nobody in Washington seems to have considered. How a country treats its allies in one war shapes whoâs willing to help in the next one. Americaâs record on that front in the Middle East is not a good one. Any future ground operation is going to require cooperation from local populations, informants, people willing to take risks. The calculus those people run is simple: what happened to the last group who helped America.
âIf American military forces are going into Iran or anywhere else in the region, expecting anyone on the ground to join forces or ally themselves with us in any wayâwhy and how could we possibly expect them to do that when they know the way weâve thrown our Afghan allies under the bus? It puts our boots on the ground in danger. If we continue to have American pilots shot down, why would the residents of enemy territory take the risk to help our warriors?â
***
Kyle, Mike, and Adam served in different units, different theaters, at different times, came from different backgrounds and hold different political beliefs, but they arrived at the same conclusions, just like the dozens of veterans I spoke with at the No Kings protest. Iâve been talking to my fellow veterans about Iran since March, at protests, in my inbox, in conversations that never made it into any article. Iâve been listening to podcasts with right-leaning veteran audiences where the hosts and guests are openly questioning and condemning whatâs happening.
Thatâs not a scientific survey, and it would be inaccurate to pretend that every veteran feels this wayâIâm sure plenty support Trump and the war, and Iâm not going to pretend otherwise. But the longer this drags on with no clear objectives and no exit strategy, the harder it gets to find one whoâs happy with how things are going.
Nick Allison is veteran of the Iraq War and a writer based in Austin, Texas. His work has appeared in Slate, HuffPost, The Fulcrum, and elsewhere. Find him on Bluesky @nickallison80.bsky.social, if youâre into that sort of thing.
Featured Image: Adam House, Korengal Valley, Afghanistan, circa 2008
#illegalWar #Iran #IranWar #Israel #politics #trump #Veterans #veteransAgainstTrump #vets #vetsAgainstTrump #War #warPowersAct