Warning! This post contains spoilers, marked and unmarked, for I Saw the TV Glow. Proceed at your own risk⦠and if you havenāt seen the movie already, I encourage you to stop reading and go watch it before proceeding any further. Itās a film that benefits from being seen unspoiled.
0. before i saw the glow
The day after my 51st birthday, I took myself out to an actual movie theaterāa rarity in this peri-pandemic worldāto see Jane Schoenbrunās 2024 film I Saw the TV Glow. My social media feed for weeks prior had been filled with multiple commentators, mostly trans (and specifically transfeminine) people alternately waxing rhapsodic about the movie and decrying how emotionally devastated it had left them: sobbing in the theater or the car afterwards, staring blankly into space for days afterwards, and having lots of Thoughts⢠about the movie, what it means, and what it has to say about queerness and transness. After a few weeks spent dodging spoilers for the film like a hyperflexible gymnast/secret agent infiltrating a high-tech laser security system, I finally gave in and took myself out to the movies to see it, and now I too have thoughts.
Oh boy, do I have thoughts.
What follows is not a review, and shouldnāt be mistaken for one. Iām not especially qualified to review the artistic or technical qualities of a film and, other than under very specific circumstances, Iām entirely unqualified to say whether a given person āshouldā see a film or not. Artistic appreciation is an intensely personal experience, and I can think of few films which demonstrate the personal nature of art as emphatically as I Saw the TV Glow.
So, rather than a review, this post is me thinking out loud: a record of my own mental processing of a film which traumatized a number of people on my social media feed and managed to work its way into my dreams before Iād ever seen more than the admittedly well-crafted trailer, and about which Iāve since made the debatably humorous comment that it gave me psychic damage.
1: starburned and unkissed
I suspect the way a person feels about I Saw the TV Glow will depend entirely on a variety of factors, including their own relationship with gender, sexuality, identity, and ā90s youth/teen pop culture. I could easily see this movie leaving a viewer baffled, confused, even angry. I can also see it leaving a viewer sobbing in their seat during the credits, or in the theater bathroom afterwards.[1] I can even imagine, however dimly, someone sitting through the entire 100-minute runtime and responding with a diffident, āwell, that happenedā shrug.
That last reaction is the hardest to envision, though. Iāve rarely ever seen a film which more openly squares off with the viewer and demands they engage with it on its own terms, and I have never in my life seen a film which more fully deserves the adjective ādreamlike.ā I Saw the TV Glow conveys its unrestrained, yet weirdly quiet dream logic with a visual style which relentlessly bombards the viewer with weapons-grade strangeness while consistently drawing us in. The film wears its artistic antecedentsāBuffy the Vampire Slayer, various Nickelodeon shows, Twin Peaksāon its sleeve, but rarely in a direct, obvious fashion. It reads very much like a coming-of-age teen drama directed by David Lynch⦠but I doubt Lynch could have made a film as defiantly, unrelentingly queer as I Saw the TV Glow.
Of course, it takes more to make a film queer than proximity to queerness. If that werenāt the case, simply noting the queerness of the filmās writer/director would be sufficient. Observing Maddyās explicit lesbian identity or the ways in which Owenās depression and isolation can be easily read as an incapacitating gender dysphoria[2] would be more than enough. However, a film can have queer characters or be made by a queer filmmaker and still fundamentally reify cisheteronormative attitudes about queerness. What makes a film queer, at least in my not-a-film-studies-major-but-having-a-gender-women-and-sexuality-studies-degree opinion, is the extent to which it fundamentally pushes back against those cisheteronormative attitudes and ideals. In other words, it doesnāt matter how many gay folks are cast, or how much the soundtrack slaps: does this movie depict a queerness that queer people can recognize? Is this a movie that looks at queerness from the outside, or a movie that shows queerness looking back at the world?
In that sense, I Saw the TV Glow is the queerest movie Iāve seen in a very long time, and quite possibly the most trans movieāand specifically the most transfeminine movieāIāve ever seen.
I realize how bold that statement is, and if I were a real movie reviewer, I might start quantifying the queerness of the film in an effort to trying to justify that claim, to argue you around to my way of thinking.
Iām not gonna do that, though, because as stated earlier, this isnāt a movie review. This is emotional triage.
Well, that doesnāt look ominous.2. feeling like a psychic wound
Iām not going to bother with writing a synopsis. Theyāre all over the internet, if you want one. (Then again, if you havenāt see the movie yet, you really oughtnāt read this.) If weāre gonna talk about I Saw the TV Glow, though, we kinda have to talk about that ending.
If you look on the internet, youāll find dozens of actual reviews of the movie, along with multiple commentators analyzing the movie itself, independent of any critical assessment. If you do just such an exploration, youāll find that much of the hubbub youāll find centerās around the movieās third act, which can be said to start roughly about whenā¦
ā¦a massive spoiler happens in the movie. Iām serious. Donāt expand this if you donāt want to have the ending of the movie revealed to you.
ā¦Maddy tries to take Owen out past the football so they can bury themselves in the earth, believing that if they do so, theyāll wake up as Tara and Isabel in the world of The Pink Opaqueāor, as Maddy/Tara insist, the real world. However, Owen shoves her to the ground just past the 50-yard line and runs away, locking himself in his house for days afterwards.
From this point forward, Owen narrates his life for us in classic television-main-character style, speaking and often looking directly at the camera. He sketches over the next few years of his life in dismal detail: his father dies, he stays in his parentsā home, he ostensibly starts a family (referenced once, and never shown on-screen), he loses one job and gets another. At one point, he rewatches The Pink Opaque (now on streaming!) only to realize the show is nothing like he remembers: silly, cheesy, childish, and kind of stupid. Itās also notably nothing like the clips he (and we) saw earlier in the film: no Isabel, no Tara, no mythology, no genuine horror, no ābig badā in the form of Mister Melancholy. Itās just a silly kidsā show.
Just a silly memory.
A twenty-year timeskip later, Owen is looking rough: grey, wan, dissolute, shuffling around his job at the Fun Center (ha!) where all the games appear to be based on references to The Pink Opaque. We see split-second visual signs that things are dire indeed, such as the āmoney tornadoā game with an LED scroll above it reading āYOU ARE DYING.ā Of course, only Owen seems able to see it, and it affects him not at all⦠until he has a total freakout during a childrenās party, screaming that heās dying and begging for help, while the entire room freezes. Later, locked in the bathroom, he cuts his own chest open with a boxcutter. Earlier in the movie, he tells Maddy that heās terrified that, were he to be cut open, thereād be nothing at all inside him. Now, though, he literally does so, only to reveal coruscating light, static, and sound. Voices. The Pink Opaque lives inside him. He laughs, looking almost ecstatic, and thenā¦
ā¦and then we see him dress in his uniform and walk back into the Fun Center, shambling like a zombie, mumbling apologies to everyone he passes, none of whom see him or respond to him.
Smash cut to black. Credits. </end>
So, like, not to be overly harsh here, but what the fuck, movie?
Really, movie? Youāre just gonna do us like that?3. the apparition knocking at my door
Welcome to the uncomfortably personal part of the blog post. Please, help yourself to an ice cream.
So, hereās the thing.
I was born in 1973. My teen years spanned the ā80s and early ā90s, so the setting of I Saw the TV Glow is a little after my time, but itās close enough that I can feel the breeze as the bullet goes by. I didnāt grow up with Are You Afraid of the Dark? or Goosebumps as childhood touchstones, but I came to Buffy and Twin Peaks in my twenties, and I still vibe with the soundtrack. In many ways, I carried my adolescence well into my twenties, perhaps into my thirties.
Thatās what being a closeted trans girl can do to you.
Childhood is a scarier place than most of us remember.I almost transitioned when I was 28. I spent hours on the internet with search terms like transsexuality and transgenderism, poring over dense blocks of text and being distressed by medical photographs. Eventually I stopped, noting that everything Iād found suggested that surgery was the end goal of transition. If I didnāt want to pursue surgical sex reassignment, I thought, I must not be transsexual, or transgender, or whatever the right word was. Whatever the particular experience or state of being was that made these women pursue biomedical transition, I must not have it.[3]
Iāve spent most of my life struggling with dysphoria. Of course, I didnāt know that word until relatively recently. I just felt as though there were something intrinsically wrong, with me or with the world, something broken or misaligned or out-of-sync on some fundamental level.
I didnāt learn the language I needed until I went back to college at 41. As it turns out, a gender studies degree is an excellent way of both hiding from your own gender issues and training yourself in the tools youāll need to deal with them when they come roaring back with a vengeance.
And they will, my friends. They always do.
I was 46 years old when I realized, or admitted, that I was a girl. Iāve told that story elsewhere, so I wonāt repeat it. I will merely note that my egg was cracked by a question to which, on some level, I already kinda knew the answer.
Like many trans people, Iām quite good at hiding from myself things I donāt want to know, or donāt feel ready to cope with yet.
I was 47 when I legally changed my name, when I started taking the feminizing hormone estradiol, when I came out to the world at large. Iād already told many of my closest friends and family, and I let everyone else know through the time-honored method of making a Facebook post⦠on Transgender Day of Visibility, no less.
I was 51 when I sat in an empty movie theater and watched the last few seconds of I Saw the TV Glow, then sat in the silence of the blackness before the credits rolled, stunned and reeling and very, very still, the only thought in my head being, that couldāve been me.
That wan, grey ghost. That broken shell of a human. That couldāve been me.
Oh, Owen.I could have died never having admitted the truth to myself, never having actually known myself. I couldāve spent my life never having been Tamsin, to myself or my wife or my daughter or the world. That couldāve been me.
It wasnāt, of course. I avoided that outcome. I found the courageāprompted by my wifeās question, true, but answered under my own volitionāto embrace myself, at long last. My story is not Owenās, or Isabelās. I reclaimed my own heart, and the world in which I live now is as magical and beautiful as any I could hope to find.
In the final seconds of I Saw the TV Glow, I see a vision of what my life might be if Iād taken the other path, if Iād never come out of my eggshell. I feel the breeze of the bullet as it goes by, and I know just how close I came. A few inches to the left, a smidge less courage or will or whatever force drove me to finally admit the truth about myself, and that couldāve been me.
4. my heart is like a claw machine
One of the most brilliant things about Schoenbrunās film lies within the central metaphor of the film, the conceit on which the whole film turns.
Being an egg or a closeted trans person, Schoenbrun suggests, is like being the central character in a kind of reverse-isekai drama. Youāve been transported from the real world into an alternate reality, an unreal world⦠but rather than being a mundane human thrown into a realm of pure fantasy and adventure, youāre a magical being ejected from the fantasy world, imprisoned in an ill-fitting suit of raw flesh, incorrect assumptions, awkward silences, and depression. Your true self has been taken from you, and you are left, hollow and false, to move through the midnight realm in which you find yourself trapped.
The metaphor is especially poignant because, in the world of I Saw the TV Glow, thereās never any confirmation of what we suspect to be true, what we desperately want to be true: that the world of The Pink Opaque actually is the real world, and the decaying suburb through which Owen shambles is nothing more than a psychic prison. The movie encourages us to embrace hopeāthat Maddy really is Tara, that Owen really is Isabel, and that there really is a way out, if only Owen/Isabel can find the courage to embrace itāwithout ever once confirming that hope is anything more than wishful thinking at best, or a dangerous, self-destructive delusion at worst.
The film never gives us this confirmation, becauseāand lean in here, kids, this is importantāno one can tell you if youāre trans or not.
No one can tell you your truth, because no one else can know it. They can guess it, they can suspect it, they can be pretty goddamn sure, but they canāt know. The most they can do is suggest it, or maybe ask some well-aimed questions.
The only one who can know, of course, is you. As cheese or cringe as it may sound, you have to be the hero of your own story. You have to find the courage first to tell yourself the truth, and then to choose to embrace it. Maybe you arenāt literally a psychic heroine buried in a shallow grave, poisoned with Mister Melancholyās Luna Juice and dying by inches⦠but as metaphors for being a closeted trans person go, that oneās not bad.
4. believe in me as i believe in you
As I coast towards the end of this particular blog post, I want us to glance outside the present film for just a moment.
The trans allegory of The Matrix is well-trodden territory, so I wonāt belabor the point, but thereās a scene in Lana Wachowskiās The Matrix Resurrections (2021) in which we are shown Neoāfirmly trapped in his āThomas Andersonā personaāsquatting on a toilet in a public bathroom. While doing his business (hilariously set to a orchestrally augmented version of Jefferson Airplaneās āWhite Rabbitā complete with tuba accompaniment), heās shown staring at the heavily graffitied stall door. In the midst of all the other marginalia is a line from Don DeLilloās 1971 novel Americana, written with a paint pen in classic Matrix green: āIt is so much simpler to bury reality than it is to dispose of dreams.ā
The profundity of the quote in a crudely quotidian and intensely gendered space was deeply poignant in the content of The Matrix Resurrections, but resonates even beyond that movie, or even the franchise as a whole. The line is practically the beating, coruscating-static-light heart of I Saw the TV Glow, and could easily have been the filmās epigraph. It depicts the figurative and literal burial of reality as a way to dispose of the dream of being beautiful, powerful, or authentic. Of mattering. Of being real, at long last, when all youāve ever known is a disconnected abstraction of life.
Art always has a message, a meaning, regardless of the claims of the artist. We may agree or disagree with the message, but itās intrinsically there. Even art that purports to be āabout nothingā is, in its own existence, saying something to us. While still allowing for individual interpretations, Jane Schoenbrun has been quite explicit in interviews as to what meanings they intended when making I Saw the TV Glow. It is an explicitly queer, trans film[4] with a messageāone which, while potentially universal in its applicability, has a special resonance for us.
At multiple points in the film, we see the streets in Owen and Maddyās suburb covered with multicolored pastel chalk scrawls, not unlike static. Images appear in them, but they too are largely an abstraction. The one moment we are shown these childlike chalk drawings unequivocally, explicitly communicating a clear messageāalmost certainly from Maddy/Taraāitās both desperate and hopeful: there is still time.
Time to do what? To admit and accept the truth, of course. To disinter yourself from an early, unwelcome grave. To reclaim your heart. To live.
There is still time.
Drifting through Void High Schoolās halls, Owen passes āmotivationalā posters stenciled in red and yellow, all bearing macho mottos about strength and courage, but courage isnāt fearlessness; itās doing what needs to be done, even when youāre afraid. The world is filled with terrors and torments, but also with comfort and pleasure and a wild, ecstatic joy. To avoid the risk of the former is to amputate the possibility of the latter, encasing yourself in a shallow grave: what iconic lesbian comedian Robin Tyler calls the āvertical coffinā of the closet. If youāre still breathing, there is still time. Any moment can be the right moment. Do it forcefully or quietly, in defiance or with support, with a voice firm with conviction or quavering with fear, to the whole world or to those you trust most or only to yourself.
It is never too late to come out, to be real, to embrace your authentic self⦠even to transition, if thatās your path. Itās never too late, until the moment youāre dead. It may not be easy or painless, but if this is your truth, if youāre reading these words, I promise youānot a rhetorical āmeā or āyou,ā but the real me typing these words, the real you reading themāI promise you, on my own heart, you can do this.
There is still time.
coda: the things that i say in the dark
I rarely do this, but something niggling at the back of my brain is prompting me to add this post-script:
Iām not a therapist or any other mental health professional. Iām just a middle-aged nonbinary trans girl who came closer to living the Bad Ending of this movie than I like to think about⦠but I didnāt. That doesnāt make me any better than anyone else, but it does give me a certain perspective. If youāve read this post and want to talk to someone about it, you can find me at any of the social media links in the header or footer of this post, or you can email me from this contact form.
I canāt promise to have any answers, but I promise to listen, and if I can do something to help, I will.
š¤
[1] This outcome doesnāt take any particular insight to imagine, however, since I first heard about I Saw the TV Glow through several social media posts from transfeminine people stating they did exactly this.
[2] Which is [SPOILER ALERT] alleviated only in a brief moment of euphoria while dressed as Isabel, one of the two main heroines of The Pink Opaque, the TV show over which Maddy and Owen bond. Itās notable that this is the only scenes I recall from the film in which Owen is seen smiling.
[3] This, by the way, is one of the dangers inherent in the lie of transmedicalism. It actually convinces trans people that theyāre not actually trans, which makes it not just factually untrue, but needlessly cruel. Itās a tool of oppression, and I will never stop hating it, or being disgusted at the ways itās used to harm trans people.
[4] And yes, there are multiple readings for the film and its ending, and yes, those readings can be much more universally applicable than a strictly transgender reading⦠but Iām wary of the impulse to immediately brush aside the trans reading of a trans creatorās explicitly-and-by-design trans-themed film in favor of something more āuniversallyāapplicable, i.e. something cis people can appreciate. To phrase it more succinctly, I Saw the TV Glow is emphatically a trans movie: made by one of us, about us, for us. Iām truly happy that cis people can get something out of it too, but to disregard or dismiss the inherent trans content of the movie is a bit like ignoring class warfare in Saltburn, sexism in The Handmaidās Tale, or racism in Get Out.
https://reimaginedgirl.com/2024/06/24/the-glow-holds-me-now/
#film #howToBeTrans #iSawTheTvGlow #janeSchoenbrun #thinkyThoughts