Dr. Or M. BialikI just want to note that on a paper about something in the Middle East, a reviewer (supposedly, a learned individual) gave us the comment: "For non-European readers as well, it would be helpful to include a map of Europe."
Szymon Bęczkowski@Rhodium103 This should be mandatory for the paper reviewers to understand.
I would also add that not all actionable and consequential feedback needs to be instantly implemented. Sometimes it should be bookmarked for future work.
Ulrich JunkerHow do you call this when you are writing a paper and your inner #reviewer2 wakes up and requires revisions?
Bjørn SætrevikI was the quite negative #reviewer2 (justified, I would say), on a manuscript that got a very positive review from the first reviewer. Seems I may have single-handedly killed the submission. Oh, how the tables have turned...
Elen Le Foll 🇫🇷 🇬🇧 🇩🇪This coming Wednesday (!) 13 May ReproducibiliTea in the HumaniTeas is delighted to welcome Andrey Anderson dos Santos to speak about Open Peer Review. After a short input talk, we will have plenty of time to discuss this rather controversial topic!
Join us at 16:00 CEST in room 4.006 of the @unibibkoeln for tea and cookies, or online via Zoom (see link sent via our mailing list: https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/reproducibilitea-humaniteas).
Andrey recently completed his PhD on #OpenScience practices in the #humanities and is coming all the way from Brazil to Cologne, so don't miss out!
Recommended (optional) reading for preparation: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-020-03488-4.
Sascha WolferRE: https://universeodon.com/@zapping/116543941380499579
Ich, wenn das Gutachten von #Reviewer2 reinkommt.
Isabel RichardsI was just COMPLEMENTED by BOTH reviewers in a new #scicomm paper I have coming out (hopefully very soon)?! AND it was about my writing style and approach and how it makes it more accessible for the non-expert to read ++ adds important research about the overlooked contributions of women to the field 😩❤️
I don’t think this will ever happen again so I’ll take it 🎉
smiergahttu@postantiquarian especially, if there are dozen maps/plans of the same site, showing different data.... but then he comes, #reviewer2 ^^'
Adam Coffman@ProfKinyon well, I appreciate all your service to the profession ... It would be difficult for me to be #Reviewer2 without the Reviewer1s.
Gabriel Heinrichs@lakens Perhaps peer review should start including #attorney1 in addition to #reviewer2
But seriously, curious to read whether Nelson discussed anti-SLAPP regulations that are currently in the making, AFAIK.