So it’s been over a month since iNaturalist first announced using Google's genAI…
…I signed up for the q&a they were going to do, and have not heard one thing. There is also no updates other than a forum post from iNat staff saying they hope to have a working prototype at the end of the year.
I don’t want a “prototype at the end of the year" released and then have it be too late to retract what I have given to the site so it doesn’t get eaten up by a genAI machine. If there is a working demo, that means the data’s already been fed, I would think…?
Thus, at this point, it’s just how long do I wait until I pull the plug? Because there is a total lack of transparency, a lot of double talking, and this is far too big an issue to just leave to chance. And for everyone saying “but science!” we functioned as scientists far before iNat existed, and there are other ways to manage datasets. If you are that conditioned to needing a computer to think for you, maybe rethink being a scientist.
iNat has done great things, getting into bed with genAI is not one of them; instead it is a nail in the coffin of science, thinking, and reason.
#nature #science #ai #genAI #llm #iNat #iNaturalist #biology #ecology