so, in honor of International Non-Binary People's Day, let's talk about AGAB and its relation to non-binary genders.
one of the most striking - and, to my knowledge, under-reported - statistics to come out of the 2022 U.S. Transgender Survey was the fact that, in the American transgender community, there are nearly four times as many AFAB people who identify as non-binary as there are AMAB people. (source: https://transequality.org/sites/default/files/2024-02/2022%20USTS%20Early%20Insights%20Report_FINAL.pdf)
now, under normal circumstances, we would expect the number of AFAB and AMAB enbies to be roughly the same - at most, maybe there might be a statistical difference falling within the margin of error.
but that's a HUGE shortfall that falls along the lines of gender assigned at birth.
so, what might explain that shortfall? well, I have a couple of guesses based on the statistics, and a couple more based on personal experiences and anecdata.
1) there's a full ten percentage points' difference between binary transgender women (35%) and binary transgender men (25%). this gap suggests to me that AMAB transgender people are pushed into identifying as binary transgender women. (there's also the competing possibility that binary transgender men are pushed into identifying as non-binary, but I find that argument less convincing. I'll get to exactly why later.)
2) the percentage of AFAB transgender people (55%) is significantly more than the number of AMAB transgender people (43%). this suggests that there's something pressuring AMAB non-binary people, specifically, to remain in the closet - or, perhaps, that there's something driving AMAB non-binary people away from transgender communities, or shaming us for identifying as transgender.
3) anecdotally - both cis society, and queer communities, typically tolerate variance in gender expression more in AFAB people than in AMAB people. the reason for this gap in tolerance is male supremacy and femmephobia - a "man" shirking their "superior" masculinity for "inferior" femininity is more likely to be seen as a fetishist or predator than a "woman" seeking to dabble in the "superior" gender expression. this lack of tolerance is undoubtedly keeping a great many AMAB trans people, both binary and enby, in the closet.
4) anecdotally - queer communities in particular are far more likely to gender AFAB enbies correctly than AMAB enbies. I personally get misgendered as "woman"/"trans woman" so many times by queer folks of all stripes on fedi that I literally had to put "I am not a trans woman" in my bio. this trend may pressure transfem enbies into identifying as binary trans women simply because queer communities don't consistently recognize AMAB enby identities.
5) anecdotally - queer communities are more likely to see non-binary identities as an endpoint for AFAB folks, and as a stepping stone to trans womanhood for AMAB folks. as much as I like to joke about the "pronoun pipeline" among transfems (and I probably shouldn't so much), transfeminine communities in particular typically see non-binaryhood as a waypoint on the journey from "cis man" to trans woman. (and besides that, my own experience - he/him "cis guy" to she/her trans woman to she/they enby - completely shirks that supposed pipeline.)
"so, Rachel," you're probably saying to yourself at this point. "are you going to come back to that point about trans men being pressured into enbyhood?" well, I don't want to deny that there might be some of that going on - I don't know.
and also, even if we're to assume that we should be seeing roughly the same percentages of binary trans woman and trans men in the American trans community, even if we're to assume that the entire shortfall in percentage between the two were entirely AFAB enbies being pressured out of trans manhood (and I don't think that's the case to be clear, among other reasons because that'd be a pretty damn enbyphobic assumption), then that still leaves a pretty gigantic gulf between the number of AMAB and AFAB enbies. and that also doesn't explain why there's so many more AFAB trans people than AMAB trans people as a whole represented on the survey.
so, to sum things up: if you take anything away from this post, it's that there cannot truly be any sort of justice in queer and trans communities until we recognize that institutional community discrimination against AMAB trans people - not just trans women, but also transfem enbies and non-transfem AMAB enbies - is real, impactful, widespread, and largely unacknowledged, to the point where it's pressuring AMAB enbies into either the closet or binary trans womanhood.
and that's why today, International Non-Binary People's Day, is especially important to us AMAB enby folks.
we're here, we exist, and we won't be shoved into one box or another.