#QuestionOfTheDay what's a piece of media/work that you wish had been a success/more successful/more appreciated by audiences or critics/etc because it would have encouraged the development of and interest in more works in the same genre or using a specific style/technique/mechanic/etc etc

#videogames #art #manga #anime #fiction #ttrpg #CCGs #movies #film #television #TV #comics #comicbooks #books #musicals #music #boardgames

@ami_angelwings The Ar tonelico/Ar nosurge series springs to mind. Wow the Atelier series is popular, but most people don't even know those games exist. They recently got a "DX" remake on modern consoles and even though it's probably a zero effort thing, the publisher can't be bothered to release them in English because they assume no one would buy them.

Also, the game has plenty of flaws, but I've always wished that Empyrion had more appreciation. It started around the same time as No Man's Sky and IMO does everything NMS does better, but it never had the marketing or budget, so has always remained essentially indie (or whatever comes just above that.) Most of the flaws and lack of polish would have improved a whole lot more if they'd had the popularity and budget of NMS...

@ami_angelwings Cybersix. I am so disappointed that that fusion style of animation - halfway between Batman and Anime, didn't become a thing.
@AnarchoNinaWrites @ami_angelwings I wish I had discovered that while it was in TV. I saw the ads but it was the year I started sleeping on instead of watching cartoons XD

@ami_angelwings "The Window" #ttRPG system, by MIMgames (Scott Lininger). It's my favorite system of all time, and it's completely free, although the website is defunct. It can be found via the Internet Archive, but to save people the time digging through snapshots, I have a copy of it on my blog site.

https://gcvrsa.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/windowrules.pdf

@ami_angelwings Also, I would definitely say the Disney adaptation of Lloyd Alexander's "The Chronicles of Prydain", which Disney released as "The Black Cauldron" in 1985, and has been widely reviled ever since, even though it's not actually that bad.

Prydain was the very first fantasy series I read as a child, and Eilonwy will always be my favorite Disney princess whom Disney refuses to actually recognize as a "Disney Princess".

@gcvsa @ami_angelwings Definitely the best YA faction, I think. Certainly one of the most mature takes and an arcs for most of the characters, over the five books.

I definitely did not like the Disney movie, at the time or now. But Breadsword had an interesting take, and I’ll watch that plenty. ;-)

https://youtu.be/3rzWdJ4vB8s

The Black Cauldron - Disney's Halloween Masterpiece

YouTube
@cthellis @ami_angelwings What I mean when I say the movie isn't that bad, is that, if you are already a fan of the books, while you will undoubtedly have issues with how the movie is constructed, you already know the plot, so its disjointedness is actually easier to cope with. The movie is not entirely divorced from the books. Some years ago (pre-COVID), Disney reacquired the rights, supposedly to make a better, live action version, but nothing has come of it, yet.

@ami_angelwings And I still can't believe that neither Mercedes Lackey's Valdemar books nor Guy Gavriel Kay's Fionanvar Tapestry have been adapted to films. They are so much better than most of the fantasy works that have been adapted.

Fantasy, in general, is one of the most popular genres that gets disdained and dumbed-down by Hollywood most of the time.

@gcvsa @ami_angelwings I concur with the mention of Valdemar - there’s plenty of decent films there just ripe for the making.

On a more personal note, I wish we had gotten more #RocketGirls, but that’s just my #SpaceMovies fan talking…

@ami_angelwings The Vision of Escaflowne! It was very well received worldwide, but not as successful as hoped in Japan, which I think limited its influence.

it really showed that it's entirely possible to create a series with broad appeal with both boys and girls, combining action and romance. I think if there were more series like it, we'd have less pigeonholing of boys and girls anime today.

@Canageek @ami_angelwings OH ABSOLUTELY! I’ve long thought that arriving in the same year as Not Even A Jelly Donut robbed #Escaflowne of the attention and success it deserved.

Much like #Akira did the same to #WingsOfHonneamise… (yes, that’s the #SpaceMovies fan in me again. I regret nothing).

@ami_angelwings a few things come to mind

tokyo xtreme racer - probably the best and most interesting way to build a street racing game, what with the health bars instead of times or lap counters, unfortunately left by the wayside because up until last year, all the games kinda sucked to play and none of them sold well at all

ace combat - considering how monumentally popular the latest game became compared to everything before it, this might seem odd to say, but the fact of the matter is there is not a single other story-focused arcade flight combat game out there that even comes close, and I think that's tragic, because it's such a fun type of game that's way more accessible than most people think, because they look at it and think "flight simulator" and instantly dismiss the entire concept

crimson skies - the peak of dieselpunk if you ask me, and practically nobody has even heard of it

teppu - I liked it a lot and I wish there was more like it, and I'll never not be mad that it got the axe

yokohama kaidashi kikou - the concept of iyashikei is absolutely not in short supply, but I do believe that the type which evokes feelings like this does
is in extremely short supply. too much iyashikei feels more like empty fluff than anything else, just pure escapism with little to no substance, but this one has a lot more going on and actually makes a lasting impact that sticks in your mind. I want more of that

every short story that offers a full and complete experience that doesn't need to be dragged on forever

last exile

the fediverse

@ami_angelwings There were several U.S. quiz shows in the 1970s that had the same challenge level of Jeopardy! but with different, more interesting game mechanics (The Who What Or Where Game, Split Second, The Big Showdown). None of them made it past a few years at most, and a couple of revivals left out the best parts of them (and also didn't last).

I don't hate Jeopardy!, but I dislike how it's just become THE buzz-in quiz show.

@ami_angelwings In addition to Valdemar and Escaflowne, I’ll add #MoretsuPirates which desperately needed a second season that it never, alas, got. One of the more queer friendly shows out there too…
@ami_angelwings
I wanted Bloodshot with Vin Diesel to be a huge success. The Valiant universe has a lot of comics that would make good movies or tv shows. Quantum & Woody, Shadowman, Eternal Warrior, Archer & Armstrong.

@ami_angelwings

i feel like mass effect partly reinvented what suikoden was doing much earlier with the large cast of missable characters and branching choice structure. writing and directing that kind of game is certainly really difficult, but suikoden 2 and suikoden 5 especially were pretty compelling.

anime endings often do something with a similar catharsis, at the end, so there's something fundamental about the kind of story the suikoden series featured that works, but it's probably also a bit depressing to carefully write a bunch of long tail narrative scenarios that most probably will never play through (visual novels invert this by making discovery of the ending scenarios its own reward).

i do wonder if rpgs as a whole would be a lot different now if suikoden ii had hit just a bit better.

@ami_angelwings Angel of the North
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angel_of_the_North
[alttext for wikipedia illustration: view looking up at giant steel statue with huge flat wings. clouds and blue sky above]
Angel of the North - Wikipedia

@ami_angelwings For me, it’s a couple of cartoons I was in love with.

Thundarr the Barbarian
Pirates of Dark Water

And I’ll never get over Firefly.