I never understood why so many men associate with imagery of predatory animals.

My idealized version of my own masculinity is best represented by a tree. Patient. Immensely endurant. Self-sufficient. Unbothered by trivial, ephemereal affairs. Innately kind to the world around it.

I don't want to be a lion or a wolf or a shark, I want to be an ancient oak whose branches have sheltered countless birds and squirrels.

@renardboy As one of those men who actually does associate and identify with images of predatory animals, i am hella glad you've got an image that speaks to you more.

I'm all for a broader, more positive masculinity that has room for more than aggression and control. It's redefinition means freedom for soooo many of us

@renardboy

Bus. Tree. Happiness.

@ewen @renardboy Bus and tree? I see crash! 😆

@renardboy I prefer to associate my mascuilnity with a beaver.

Vegan high-fibre diet, excellent swimmer, hard-working, builder of habitat-forming engineering projects, likes to live in monogamous pairs with their kids, produces headache cures from their anal glands, communicates mostly through whining.

@dylanleigh @renardboy adorable as hell and water is their number 1 enemy. who needs to shower…

@dylanleigh @renardboy

Hard to go wrong with a butt that smells of vanilla.

@renardboy I like this.
I'm a sparrow.
As you can see.
@renardboy Maybe you could look into it!
@renardboy The answer is in the question. They associate with predators because they _are_ predators.

@jo @renardboy No. We have flat teeth. We are not hunters. Our eyes point forward because we descended from brachiators. That's why you can raise your arms over your head (cats and dogs can't). That's why you can hit a running rabbit with a rock.

We only started eating other animals in earnest when we invented the long pointy stick.

We are much better and much more dangerous than any predator.

@renardboy I'm sure there are lots of bad reasons to see yourself as a predator: I bet sociopaths go for it.

But I imagine it's also attractive to folks who don't have anything like what they want; their inner self feels the need to hunt it down.

@renardboy I want to be more like a ferret, exploring and sniffing new things, occasionally flopping over on my back while playing with an inflated ball four times my size.

@renardboy

They find different meanings in different things, I suppose...

@renardboy
Lots of those guys who relate to predators are actually more in the barnyard rooster, billy goat category
@renardboy
The Dagara tribe in Africa considers trees to be the wisest beings on earth
@renardboy (by poorlydrawnlines.com)
@laubblaeser @renardboy I'm surprised at the "highly fotogenic" point. I find photographs of mountains to be much more boring than the actual things.
@kibrika @renardboy Hm, fair point, at least most of the time. For some great mountain photographs, I *highly* recommend to have a look at Ansel Adam‘s series from Yosemite National Park. :)

@renardboy

Counterargument: Bear.

You get to walk around more, but also sleep a lot. You don't get judged for being fat and hairy. As for food, you get to sit in a river waiting for fish to, sometimes literally, jump into your mouth.

@renardboy People need to stop talking more about
mascunility as if it is a holy product of evelution, and more like a
neccasary evil that it is.
@renardboy Not strong like a wall but strong like a foundation.
@renardboy tbh the "tree" metaphor is kinda common on some circles (Spanish example: https://www.letras.com/jose-larralde/1690545/)
SI DE RABIA NO MÁS - José Larralde - LETRAS.COM

Ande diablos se escuenden las penas / que las quiero achurar y no encuentro / ni una sola que ruempa mis venas / y me corte sin trampa el aliento / Por que

Letras.com
@renardboy Like I’m going to take advice from a bus 😀

@renardboy When I was coming out of being a lawyer, man, I loathed people who even jokingly thought to refer to me as 'the hammer'.

I feel like it's in the same boat as the predatory thing. Gotta be big. Gotta hit hard. Gotta be dangerous.

If somebody called me 'the tree' - yeah. I'd dig that.

@renardboy
I imagine the predator imagery comes in no small part from the notion that men must constantly compete with eachother to be valid. Even though many predators hunt cooperatively.

@renardboy

thank you bus tree you have spawned a great thread 🖖🏾

@renardboy 💖💖💖 I like this a lot! Thank you!

@renardboy I mean, if men want to identify with a predator why not birds... they often mate for life, and build nests, and take care of their young a lot better than male mammals...

But I like your vision. Trees are wonderful.

@renardboy I would settle for a giant panda.
@renardboy
Considering many of these men claim to be "Christian", I like that the Bible compares God to a chicken hen.
@renardboy I would love the speed, agility and climbing ability of a Squirrel or Degu or similar. :P

@renardboy

I agree strongly with the metaphor. However, you may wish to consider that oaks are, biologically, monoecious - they produce both male and female flowers. Not a bad feature for your metaphor, combining male and female aspects, but there are no boy oaks (which I rather like, but the lion, panther, and hawk folks on the thread may have a problem).

@renardboy You're describing Motherhood.
@renardboy @slothrop Can I come sit by you? I won’t be needing the bear after all

@renardboy The traditional, somewhat toxic, ideal of masculinity idealises men as controlled violence. The "Ideal Man" doesn't start fights, but if challenged he won't back down and will proceed to beat his opponent up to precisely the level of injury he judges appropriate for the insult.

If the man doesn't have barely controlled impulses to violence, he is not a Real Man. And if he can't control them, then he is a failure of a man.

That applies to sex too. So goes the traditional male role.

@renardboy you may like the song that the french poet and singer George Brassens wrote in 1956.
I don't know about official translation, but if you don't understand french you can try your favorite translation service.
The title is "auprès de mon chêne" and the first verse of the chorus "I was living happy near my oak" the lyrics are https://www.paroles.net/georges-brassens/paroles-aupres-de-mon-arbre
And a TV broadcast from 1956 is https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q3-_8SblRIQ
Paroles Aupres De Mon Arbre par Georges Brassens - Paroles.net (lyrics)

Paroles du titre Aupres De Mon Arbre - Georges Brassens avec Paroles.net - Retrouvez également les paroles des chansons les plus populaires de Georges Brassens

@renardboy I've never heard a man speak this way and it touched me really deeply. Thank you 🫶

@renardboy

This is a perfect description of the kind of masculinity I'm trying to embody. Kind, supportive, gentle, steady. Slow to anger and inherently protective of the people under my branches.

@renardboy I hope you have children, lucky them!
@renardboy
I love that image, save for the self-sufficient bit (wood wide web), it's the first image of masculinity I've come across that I think I could relate to.
@renardboy trees are good, but have you also considered: masculinity represented as an actual bus

@renardboy I thought, yeah a fox !
A sneaky, playfull, smart and nice fox.

And them, i saw your username.

@ache sneaky, playfull, smart and nice public transit
@renardboy there's a German proverb which loosely translates as "what does the oak care about the pig rubbing against its bark" and I've always aspired to be the oak 👍
@floe Oh, I always thought that was 'imported' by Russia Germans. Maybe it's just my family didn't use that :)

@ctietze @floe what? i never heard that being said, probably more regional or in some circles i have not been in.

i also like the "i will show you where the lobsters hibernate" threat ^^ i think it has eastern europe/russian roots too.

@renardboy

Personally I like to think of myself as a hedgehog: it's a creature that can quite freely move about without having to think about all the dangers that afflict most small mammals.

It may not be the most "catcher in the rye" -thing to do, but to me the animal embodies both the peace of mind I constantly try to pursue in the middle of this late stage capitalism of ours, as well as the privileges I enjoy in society based on my form and shape.