I helped build a government AI system. DOGE fired me, rolled the AI out to the whole agency, and implied the AI can do my job and the jobs of the others they've fired.
It can't. But, what DOGE accidentally revealed about themselves in the process is fascinating. ๐งต
From Nov 2023 to Jan 2024 I worked on a tool we called the AI sandbox. Our goal: let federal software devs test out AI tools in a safe way, to discover if they have any use.
Renamed GSAi, the tool has been claimed by DOGE. It is being rolled out on an alarming accelerated schedule.
No one from the new admin wrote a single line of code for it. But GSAi has become their proud "AI-first strategy."
(Previously at my job, rather than AI or any tech we put *people* first. See 18F's work on "human-centered design.")
As my coworker explains in this demo, we knew AI's capability is limited
"The principle is to show you *not* that AI is great for everything, not to try to encourage you to stick AI into every product.... You can get yourself into trouble thinking that it can do things that it can't."
As a fed, I am accustomed to knowledgeable and diverse coworkers who don't get snookered by the latest buzzwords.
But yesterday at GSA headquarters, 6 white guys in suits (one without a tie!) took the stage. They demo'd GSAi like it was pure magic to them.
While saying "this is incredible" over and over, Musk's GSA head Stephen Ehikian asked GSAi to "write me a website." The output was not compliant with federal law. It said "Welcome to Our Company" on it and did not resemble a federal website at all.
๐ This garbage demo had a terrified audience
One viewer said "if this is the tool meant to replace us, thank God"
Everyone is afraid for their jobs, their projects, and their democracy. There is a widespread impression that AI is supposed to replace the people who are fired.
I actually don't think that's the plan. Let me explain:
There is a quasi-religion in Silicon Valley that views AI as godlike. This faith has always been parallel to Evangelical Christianity: it has salvation (transhumanism), the rapture (the technological singularity), and demons (Roko's Basilisk)
Lately the AI faith has fully fused with Christian Nationalism.
Together, these two faiths crave the end of American liberal democracy and government. You can smell it at GSA.
They won't replace us with AI because ๐๐๐๐ ๐ ๐๐'๐ ๐๐๐๐ ๐๐ ๐๐๐๐๐๐๐ ๐๐ ๐๐ ๐๐๐. They want our work to end. DOGE is firing us as fast as possible, and that is the whole plan.
Listen: maybe I'm wrong and this is just the worst software deployment of my career, not actually a conspiracy against democracy.
Maybe these guys just don't see they are frittering away all product and service design knowledge in the agency. And don't even know that they lack this knowledge.
Honestly: From the 2013 failure of healthcare.gov to today, the government *almost* learned how to build software. We were close. Then a bunch of white men in suits swooped in to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.
Maybe they are just incompetent. But I think it's worse than that.
On stage, Ehikian asked GSAi to "write me a plan to rewrite the FAR"
The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations, are laws that control how the gov't buys stuff. They are legendary in their complexity for a good reason: to prevent corruption. To protect taxpayer money from theft by beltway bandits.
The AI's "plan" to simplify the FAR was generic and unusable, of course. But it is a subject that Ehikian and DOGE keep returning to: Contracting. Acquisition. The money.
They want to file the corners off of the process that regulates government spending. They want to consolidate all government contracts in one place. And put AI in charge.
@skiles
Vendor lockin, with a Fort Knox lock.
And they'll have already made enough to fund their other grifts by the time ee are eventually able to "break the lock".
@skiles 1/
Thank you for this account. You may certainly be correct in your suspicion that the objective here is simply to gut government purchasing. But I see a historical aspect to the religious conviction that you describe.
Twenty-five years ago I was part of an effort (sponsored by the UN) to develop a standard environment for the exchange of business documents called ebXML. It was an open-standards internet follow-on to EDI.
@skiles 2/
ebXML was sabotaged by Microsoft as a threat to their proprietary systems, but the creation of something that would work with human business processes was also resisted by a faction of zealots within the project who were working for an environment in which all the actual business transactions were between machines, without the need for human businesspeople at all. I can't help seeing the current push for AI in this space as a continuation of that way of thinking.
>> Twenty-five years ago I was part of an effortโฆ to develop a standard environment for the exchange of business documents called #ebXML. It was an open-standards internet follow-on to #EDI. โฆ an environment in which all the actual business transactions were between machines, without the need for humanโฆ
Then, @timbl and #W3C invented the #SemanticWeb and #OWL reasoners, which I can't help but see as a precursor to the current AI push, and a continuation of that way of thinking
#Trump and #Musk want to run the entire #US Government with just #AManAndADog โ no other humans in the loop.
I had lengthy discussions with an industrialist who wanted to run his heavy mechanical industry with "just a man and his dog" because he had seen modern data centers run in "lights out" mode.
No amount of persuasion was enough to sway his idea that he could fire his workers and replace them with #AI. Fortunately, the Board fired him before he could fire workers
Indeed. FIY, this is exactly why I called AI a "perfect smokescreen" here:
https://fossforce.com/2025/03/ai-is-not-unavoidable-not-this-ai-thats-for-sure/#google_vignette
@skiles Yes yes yes!
(Said the bit in the movie Tron)
The point has never been to increase efficiency, it has been to eliminate AGENCY.
To remove the number of humans that would talk back. The chance someone has a good heart and would not serve, would not stop people getting needlessly hurt etc. To eliminate good conscience.
Why else would you think โChristian Nationalistsโ are going on so hard about: โThe Sin of Empathyโ right now?
Yes, they are calling empathy a "sin."
https://canonpress.com/products/the-sin-of-empathy
... and ...
Elon Musk said
"The fundamental weakness of Western civilization is empathy."
https://www.yahoo.com/news/fact-check-musk-said-fundamental-130000768.html
@JeffGrigg @gimulnautti @skiles I knew about Elon Musk's, er, position on peace love & understanding since his response when questioned about fallout from insisting factory workers carry on in the face of Covid: "People die."
Interesting that it's now being promoted as insightful wisdom.
I dunno. Careful what you wish for, guys.
A lot of pople need to get their heads out of their butts and actually open their Bible to READ IT. For instance John 13.33.
Sorry, but fundamentalist Christians just p!55 me off.
I hear you. These people simply surrender all their intellectual independence to a church or a preacher. Whatever is "recommended" by the lead 'evangelist' is accepted without question.
And it goes on and on. These are cults, pure and simple.
@ParadeGrotesque @fgbjr @JeffGrigg @skiles Any text can be twisted by sufficiently advanced narrative into supporting any belief.
Doesnโt even take thousands of years. A decade is more than enough!
Iโm pretty sure youโre right. Breaking government services so they can then privatize to fix it. Itโs all about the money. Super corrupt. All the while theyโre chanting a mantra against corruption and the MAGGOTS are eating it up, chanting right along.
It's safe to say that no matter what ideology these people believe, greed will be the dominant force.
They can't even help themselves, it's an all you can eat free buffet now. They'll even kill each other for it.
Or, to only leave the humans who control the AIs in the loop.
AIs do not act autonomously. They are trained, deployed, controlled.
It is romantic and popular to assign them agenda - but they act on behalf of people.
Just a very very small group of people.
That s the project here.
@skiles Watching who sits with whom these days, i'd expect Elmo just awkwardly try to hand over the US aparatus to his sugardaddy Peter Thiel and *somehow* let Palantik reign supreme.
Not because of huge tactics but of the most simple thinking - if me, moron, hand stuff to more powerfull person, i'll be safe from my childhood fears.
For Elmo & Trump it is now eiter rule forever or go to jail. So they will do whatever it takes, no matter how weird, confused and evil.
@skiles Sounds similar to when the some people swept into #Chile, where the #SantiagoBoys had *almost* learned running a national economy on #Cybersyn.
https://archive.org/details/the-santiago-boys
Corporate overlords can't stand some actually effective thing benefiting normal people. It'd shatter their saviour complex & fragile egos.
#ProjectCybersyn #ChicagoBoys #StaffordBeer #SalvadorAllende #CalculationDebate #DemocraticPlanning #socialistcalculationdebate
THE SANTIAGO BOYSTHE TECH WORLD THAT MAY HAVE BEENThe Santiago Boys is a nine-part podcast about a group of radical utopians around Salvador Allende, Chile's...
@skiles 15 years ago I was the guy who wrote their "cloud transition plan," in which one of the major risks identified was "vendor will be unable to deliver.". One of the now-retired GSA old farts couldn't believe it.
" but they'll be OBLIGATED to!!"
Yeah, that doesn't fuckin' make them capable.
Kyuu Eturautti
John Skiles Skinner
Hobson Lane
mk30
Ezra Freelove
Jon Bosak
Ramesh #NotGoingBack
Jon A. Cruz
Sharp Leaves
M. Fioretti
Toni Aittoniemi
Frank Bennett ๐ฏ๐ต
Jeff Grigg
Parade du Grotesque ๐
MPFantod
Jay
Morgunin
Graeme ๐ด๓ ง๓ ข๓ ณ๓ ฃ๓ ด๓ ฟ
jules / cowbell as fuck
Leendaal
Sebastian Bรผttrich @ ITU
schrotthaufen
huxley(fur) / Laelia ๐ Furcationland DeadDog
NikitaTarsov
Steve Holden
Nicolas Pettiaux
Jessica D Dooley
Agathe
Magnus Ahltorp
Bill
gittaca
johnny anhedonic
Tim Kukulski
Regine
LR
Tim Ward โญ๐ช๐บ๐ถ #FBPE
The Turtle
Kim Spence-Jones ๐ฌ๐ง๐ท
Oliver Pfleiderer ๐ฌ๐ฑ