#NASA 📆 2018 "How we engage will depend a lot on the pace at which those systems and capabilities develop" https://www.businessinsider.nl/nasa-sls-replacement-spacex-bfr-blue-origin-new-glenn-2018-11/

When should they retire #SLS ?

ASAP, stop the waste of taxpayer money
38.4%
When Starship is operational
16.3%
When New Glenn is (also) operational
19.8%
SLS is great, keep it
25.6%
Poll ended at .
NASA 'will eventually retire' its new mega-rocket if SpaceX, Blue Origin can safely launch their own powerful rockets

NASA is building the Space Launch System (SLS) to send astronauts back to the moon. But it will retire it if SpaceX and Blue Origin build big rockets.

Business Insider Nederland
#SpaceX’s #FalconHeavy costs well north of $100 million 💵 per launch. The #SLS about $4 billion 💰💰💰💰 per launch https://www.astronomy.com/space-exploration/by-the-numbers-the-space-launch-system-nasas-next-moon-rocket/
By the numbers: The Space Launch System, NASA’s next Moon rocket

Take a deep dive into NASA's next-generation lunar rocket, the Space Launch System, which is set to soon prove its chops.

Astronomy Magazine
@lori_garver “It got funded as a rocket to nowhere, and we at #NASA had to figure out something to do with it”.
The #rocket is #unsustainable by design, relying on an old and potentially quite expensive 💰 way to get to #space 🌌. Much of #SLS is a holdover from the #SpaceShuttle. https://www.technologyreview.com/2023/01/09/1065143/nasa-artemis-return-to-moon
NASA’s return to the moon is off to a rocky start

Artemis aims to deliver astronauts back to the lunar surface by 2025, but it’s riding on an old congressional pet project.

MIT Technology Review

"Political and #aerospace interests were more than reluctant to embrace any changes which they viewed as a threat to their own hegemony."
The mainstream media doesn’t cover #SpaceExploration and #SpaceScience with the same questioning 🔍 rigor that they reserve for #politics. People writing about space exploration are mostly cheerleaders 🥳 for the cause, rather than independent observers keeping a watchful eye on how our national monies 💰 are spent. https://www.forbes.com/sites/brucedorminey/2022/06/23/new-book-paints-bleak-picture-of-nasas-human-spaceflight-program/

#NASA #SLS #Artemis

New Book Paints Bleak Picture Of NASA’s Human Spaceflight Program

Former Deputy NASA Administrator Lori Garver says NASA is resistant to change and stymied by entrenched special interests.

Forbes
📆 2019 A senior #NASA official had opened the door to NASA flying its first crewed 👩‍🚀 missions to the #Moon 🌙 on a #FalconHeavy rocket 🚀 built by #SpaceX https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/04/nasa-chief-says-a-falcon-heavy-rocket-could-fly-humans-to-the-moon/
NASA chief says a Falcon Heavy rocket could fly humans to the Moon

Falcon Heavy could augment Space Launch System on road back to the Moon.

Ars Technica

When Mr Bridenstine suggested in 2019 that America could return to the Moon 🌙 using #SpaceX’s #FalconHeavy, he provoked a row with Richard #Shelby, a senator from #Alabama who was then chairman of the Senate appropriations committee. Welcoming the #SLS in 2011, Mr Shelby said that #NASA’s exploration of space, “has always been and always will be through Marshall Space Flight Centre [in #Alabama].” https://www.economist.com/science-and-technology/2022/08/24/nasas-space-launch-system-is-yesterdays-rocket

#SpacePolitics #PorkBarrel

NASA’s Space Launch System is yesterday’s rocket

It is powered by yesterday’s technology and brought about by yesterday’s thinking

The Economist
It will become inevitably embarrassing if #Starship is launching dozens of times a year like #Falcon9 is, and #SLS 💰 once every two years. #FalconHeavy is the one SLS was originally in a race against, not Starship. https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/08/former-nasa-official-on-trying-to-stop-sls-there-was-just-such-visible-hostility/
Former NASA official on trying to stop SLS: “There was just such visible hostility”

"I still don't know to this day if my boss, Charlie, was in on the whole deal."

Ars Technica
#NASA’s Office of Inspector General issued a devastating 👎 audit 🔍 of the program, which found that delays to the #SLS booster and engine contracts have resulted in an approximately $6 billion 💰💰💰💰💰💰 cost-overrun. The report further criticizes the use of #CostPlus contracts, a fee structure by which essentially all of the risk is taken on by the government. https://techcrunch.com/2023/07/13/congress-prepares-to-continue-throwing-money-at-nasas-space-launch-system/
Congress prepares to continue throwing money at NASA’s Space Launch System | TechCrunch

Congress will pour billions more dollars into the Space Launch System (SLS) rocket, even as NASA science missions remain vulnerable to cuts.

TechCrunch
The #SLS and #Orion spacecraft projects are of such a scale that they spend money in all 50 states and Puerto Rico, creating #parochial interest in nearly every congressional district. It sounds like a straightforward argument: cancel the slow and outdated SLS and direct its $2.6 billion 💰 per year into novel public-private partnerships like #SpaceX’s #Starship https://www.planetary.org/articles/why-we-have-the-sls
Why we have the SLS

The SLS rests on a secure foundation of political support, a consequence of the U.S. framework of representative democracy and discretionary funding.

The Planetary Society

#NASA found that protective “char layer” material from the heat shield wore away unexpectedly during reentry in more than 100 locations. The material cracked and broke off the #spacecraft in pieces, creating a trail of debris, instead of melting away as it was supposed to. The spacecraft heats 🔥 up to 5,000 degrees Fahrenheit during reentry—about half as hot as the surface of the sun ☀️. Some bolts on Orion also unexpectedly melted and eroded. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/nasas-orion-capsule-heat-shield-wore-away-in-more-than-100-places-during-2022-test-flight-posing-significant-risks-180984296/

#Orion #Artemis

NASA's Orion Capsule Heat Shield Wore Away in More Than 100 Places During 2022 Test Flight, Posing 'Significant Risks'

A new report highlights safety issues that NASA must address before using the spacecraft to send astronauts to the moon, and the agency is already working on fixing the problems

Smithsonian Magazine

#Starliner's #HeatShield is made of #Boeing Lightweight Ablator, a honeycomb-like structure that is hand-filled with the ablator. In areas that receive less heat, the capsule is covered with a mix of thermal blankets and heat shield tiles, both of which have #SpaceShuttle heritage.

The descent through the atmosphere will reach temperatures of 1,650 degrees 🔥 Celsius. Once through the thicker part of the #atmosphere, the heat shields are #jettisoned 🗑️ https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2024/06/starliner-cft-launch/

Boeing's Starliner CFT launches on third attempt - NASASpaceFlight.com

After years of anticipation, Boeing’s CST-100 Starliner capsule has flown its first crew into space…

NASASpaceFlight.com
#Starliner has encountered persistent helium leaks in the propulsion system and several thrusters that stopped working when the capsule was in the final phase of rendezvousing with the #ISS. #NASA and #Boeing officials confirmed that Butch Wilmore and Suni Williams will now return to Earth on 📆 June 26, instead of the originally planned date of June 14 ⏳ https://techcrunch.com/2024/06/20/boeings-starliner-capsule-took-astronauts-to-space-now-it-needs-to-bring-them-back/
Boeing’s Starliner capsule took astronauts to space — now it needs to bring them back | TechCrunch

The delays are not over for Boeing’s Starliner capsule. After years of delays, the aerospace giant finally launched the spacecraft earlier this month, but

TechCrunch

‘Yes, I have #safety experience. But it’s in the dairy 🥛🧀 industry’. #Boeing chief admits the company has retaliated against #whistleblowers 🤔🙄 https://edition.cnn.com/business/live-news/boeing-ceo-testify-senate/index.html

#Starliner #QualityAssurance

‘I know it happens’: Boeing chief admits the company has retaliated against whistleblowers

The outgoing chief of the embattled airplane maker is testifying in the wake of a whistleblower’s allegations of safety issues.

CNN

"The lack of a trained and qualified workforce 👨‍🏭 increases the risk that the contractor will continue to manufacture parts and components that do not adhere to #NASA requirements and industry standards." Seven years late⏳, three times 📈 the original cost 💰 estimate https://arstechnica.com/space/2024/08/a-new-report-finds-boeings-rockets-are-built-with-an-unqualified-work-force/

#Boeing #SLS #Orion #Artemis

A new report finds Boeing’s rockets are built with an unqualified work force

NASA declines to penalize Boeing for the deficiencies.

Ars Technica

#NASA indefinitely delays ⏳ return of Starliner. During a pair of news conferences since #Starliner docked to the station officials have downplayed 🙈🙉🙊 the overall seriousness 😱 of the issues. But they have yet to fully explain why they are not yet comfortable with releasing Starliner to fly back to Earth under normal circumstances. https://arstechnica.com/space/2024/06/nasa-indefinitely-delays-return-of-starliner-to-review-propulsion-data/

#Boeing #HumanSpaceflightSecurity

NASA indefinitely delays return of Starliner to review propulsion data

“We are letting the data drive our decision."

Ars Technica

"The test flight revealed anomalies with the #Orion heat shield, separation bolts, and power distribution that pose significant risks to the safety of the crew. Separation bolt melt beyond the thermal barrier during #reentry can expose the vehicle to hot gas ingestion behind the heat shield, exceeding Orion’s structural limits and resulting in the breakup 💥 of the vehicle and loss of crew.” 💀 https://payloadspace.com/nasa-audit-identifies-significant-issues-with-orion-heat-shield/

#NASA awarded design and development to #Boeing 😱 https://www.space.com/2946-boeing-thermal-protection-system-orion-spacecraft.html

NASA Audit Identifies Significant Issues with Orion Heat Shield

The Orion spacecraft heat shield suffered extensive damage during its first flight that could “pose significant risks to the safety of the crew” of Artemis II, NASA’s watchdog revealed in a report on Wednesday. 

Payload

The #crew 👩‍🚀 will in some ways be human guinea pigs 🐀 (10 days in 9m³).

Experiments will monitor how their bodies are affected by space 🌌. "We want to be able to study in depth the effect of the #microgravity and the #radiation ☢️".

On arrival, the astronauts will begin a #dangerous part of the mission as they re-enter 🔥 the Earth's #atmosphere https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cy7pegvz17yo

#NASA #Artemis #HumanSpaceflight

Artemis II: Nasa plans crewed Moon mission for February

The mission around the Moon will pave the way for a lunar landing as soon as 2027.

The heat shield 🔥🛡️ was not permeable enough during #Artemis I. This led to gas buildup, higher pressures, and the observed cracking. The heat shield for Artemis II is actually more impermeable than the Artemis I vehicle.

#NASA’s data 💽 convinced the IRT that modifying the entry profile for Artemis II would offset the impermeability of the heat shield.

"#NASA is relying on #risk assessments and #simulations to determine the safety of #Orion’s existing heat shield." https://arstechnica.com/space/2024/12/former-flight-director-who-reviewed-orion-heat-shield-data-says-there-was-no-dissent/

After critics decry Orion heat shield decision, NASA reviewer says agency is correct

“If this isn’t raising red flags out there, I don’t know what will.”…

Ars Technica
@spaceflight Sending people into space is such a dumb idea! We could get 10 times the science for the same price, with the added bonus that there's no dick-wagging.
@spaceflight
Well, they had damn' well better fly AT LEAST one more uncrewed mission to validate the corrected design before they risk a crew in that deathtrap.
During the #Artemis I mission in late 📆 2022 chunks of charred material cracked and chipped away from #Orion's heat 🔥 shield. #NASA will likely fly with the heat shield as is. https://arstechnica.com/space/2024/09/after-starliner-nasa-has-another-big-human-spaceflight-decision-to-make/
After Starliner, NASA has another big human spaceflight decision to make

"We still have a lot of work to do to close out the heat shield investigation.”

Ars Technica

"On the way down, it’s all the #HeatShield 🔥 ... There’s no plan B. You know that is going to be your higher blood pressure moment" https://www.independent.co.uk/space/polaris-dawn-crew-spacewalk-return-b2615068.html

#PolarisDawn

Billonaire-funded Polaris Dawn crew share what it was like to go further in space than any human for 50 years

The historic mission paves the way for future trips to the Moon and Mars

The Independent

The #SpaceX mission control outage knocked out mission headquarters, disabling the ability of operators to send commands or perform controls that would normally be standard during a spacecraft's mission. It happened sometime before the Sept. 12 #spacewalk and at least one hour passed before power was restored. Had mission control remained offline, the #astronauts had enough training to control the spacecraft themselves. https://www.reuters.com/technology/space/power-failed-spacex-mission-control-before-september-spacewalk-by-nasa-nominee-2024-12-17

#PolarisDawn

#NASA has yet to provide any additional information on the status of its review of the #Orion spacecraft's heat shield. Engineers found more than 100 locations where the stresses of #reentry damaged the heat 🔥 shield. https://arstechnica.com/space/2024/10/artemis-ii-almost-certainly-will-miss-its-september-2025-launch-date

#Artemis #delay

It’s increasingly unlikely that humans will fly around the Moon next year

We’ve had reason to doubt the September 2025 launch date for this mission, the first crewed flight into deep space in more than five decades, for awhile now.

Ars Technica