If the British government recovered fragments of the sword Excalibur and decided to have it re-forged for nation-building reasons, how would they go about it?
Local mediaeval re-enactment blacksmith
3.9%
Outsourced weapons contract for BAe systems
40%
Prime Minister’s chauffeur’s bestie
33.9%
Blade hardened by stabbing a benefit claimant
22.2%
Poll ended at .
@cstross it wouldn't be outsourced to BAe, it’ll be outsourced to Tata.
@StrangeNoises @cstross Infosys surely :) You can bet Lady Penelope of Mordaunt would be first in line to wield it, possibly to amputate the dangly parts of Rishi Rich.
@bobthomson70 @cstross Tata at least does actually make stuff. in steel, no less… On second thoughts, even though the money leaves the country, it's far too competence-adjacent for this government.
@StrangeNoises @cstross like ‘competence-adjacent’, sure doesn’t sound like them.
@bobthomson70 @StrangeNoises @cstross
but only adjacent, because the grade of steel Tata's accustomed to working with would bend the first time someone used the sword on anything harder than a ripe banana.
@StrangeNoises @cstross nah, that would mean sending good Tory money to Yorkshire or Wales, and that’s never gonna happen 😉
@cstross give it to Palantir to stop the elves reforging it and giving it to Aragorn

@cstross the actual British Government or the New Management one?

In the former case, probably by organising the Great British Smith-Off and have the winner fix the sword 😅

For the New Management I'm not sure how they'd handle the smithing, but it would definitely be hardened in a bathtub of blood.

@cstross

I voted for BAe, but I like the other options too!

@ParadeGrotesque @cstross
I liked that one at first, then it occurred to me that it might not directly-enrich a crony.
Then I realized that while Tories were maneuvering to figure out which crony would benefit, someone was gonna go 'sod this nonsense' & just stab the prole.
@cstross I *think* given that Excalibur is kinda used to find for a unified country and against those that oppose it, wielded by a sort-of Paladin, I'd assume the current British government would go to quite some length to destroy and oppress it instead.
@cstross two feasibility studies, one by Capita, the other by PM's brother in law. After £200m spent nothing gets done and sword gets put in storage because there is no display spaces available due to museum budget cuts
@casstr @cstross I have a feeling that after all that happened, the sword would not be put in storage, but rather its ownership would be outsourced.

@cstross Really it could be all four together. Fat contact to BAe who turns around and outsources the work to the local RenFair blacksmith (while skimming millions off the top). But nefarious agencies know that blood sacrifice will poison the will of Excalibur, causing it to become a force for unstoppable evil, so they possess the PM's Chauffeur's Bestie to ensure an innocent victim is "accidentally" killed in the final forging ceremony.

The Laundry is called in, of course. Hijinks ensue.

@zenkat @cstross I read "fat" as "Fae" and while I don't think the fairies are a Stross topic (I stand to be corrected) I see no obvious reason they couldn't be. He's done unicorns, after all
@dan @zenkat There is in fact a very short, short Laundryverse story (New Management, actually) about fairies at the bottom of the garden, in the anthology "99 Fleeting Fantasies" ed. Jennifer Brozek: https://www.amazon.com/99-Fleeting-Fantasies-Fantasy-Anthology-ebook/dp/B0CV7SRL9S
Amazon.com

@cstross They wouldn't,they would be afraid that supreme executive power would be conferred in a bizarre aquatic ceremony.

Too much of a risk.

@cstross

The real answer is that it would be destroyed because Arthur coming back would be completely against Home Office Policy and disruptive to the public good.

I think it was #YesMinister that had #SirHumphrey say that a second coming of Jesus would be disruptive to the Church of England's ongoing mission, at one point.

@cstross Government abandons reforging project, sells fragments to a select list of foreign billionaires as investment-grade collectibles. Offers a no-bid contract for "antique weaponry resourcing” to an American consulting firm which delivers a rusted AR-15 found in a swamp in Florida and invoices the UK for £7.2 billion.
@cstross
But BAE will subcontract to the medieval blacksmith and charge millions per hour for all the meetings and paperwork required to certify it

@cstross Don't see why they would waste a good blade on a benefit claimant when Michael Gove still walks the earth.

"The party opposite is the opposition, your enemies are all around you."

@cstross they’d put the fragments into the British museum first for display where they’d get stolen/sold two or three times and replaced with forgeries, and then someone in the Tory party who thought the fakes were real would be caught reenacting the sword scene from one of the King Arthur movies with three underage girls and an emu, at which point the forged forgeries would be quietly disappeared. At great cost, of course.

@wordshaper @cstross

The real stolen fragments would end up in a vault with the spear of destiny, and a very rich tech bro will buy the collection to help establish a feudal system with them. Our Techbro-King will have AI advisors for all matters of state. It will not go well.

@TonyJWells @cstross Joke's on him, then, the "spear of destiny" is just a busted Dalek eye stalk tied onto a stick.
@wordshaper @TonyJWells @cstross In this construct is the Lancelot/Guinevere/Arthur love triangle a passionate squabble between Siri, Alexa and Cortana?
@dave @TonyJWells @cstross Nah, it's between the emu, the tory peer, and a very confused potted plant. Though to be fair the tory peer is *also* potted, just not quite in the same way. Also likely to be slightly less competent a member of the house of lords than the emu. Or the plant, for that matter.

@wordshaper @TonyJWells @cstross plant is not actively malicious, so the net effect is actually above-baseline.

Give the emu a couple of years of oligarch graft though, and it will be swanning about with anti-immigrant skinheads and scarpering out of meetings to party with Prince Andrew.

@dave @wordshaper @cstross

It's less a round table, more a badly sorted lookup table

@cstross They'd forge a forgery and trouser as much as they could by quietly flogging off the real thing.
@cstross
A public/private partnership is formed to exploit the fragments. They appropriate billions of pounds but divert attention by commissioning Damian Hirst to create a major new work, "hung, drawn, and quartered", to inspire the nation. The work comprises (most of) a benefit claimant preserved in formaldehyde in a tank suspended from a large sketch of Britannia wielding the reforged sword.
@cstross A historical expert who keeps on telling them this is a really bad idea right up until Wales and Edinburgh rise up and finally free themselves of the cursed Saxon yoke!
@cstross They would use a European company, much like they did for the new, blue passports after Brexit.
@cstross Slay all NHS workers, soak the parts in their blood and then attempt the reforge. Nothing happens, of course. Blame Brussels.
@cstross Talking bears. Sword won’t be sharp enough to carve up reality without talking bears.
Note: this is by no means exclusive of the medieval recreationist blacksmith option.

@cstross

E Squadron --> CIA SOG/SAD —> Lockheed Martin for materials research. Nobody needs a jumped-up sword these days unless they’re selling steak knives on TV.

@cstross
There's not a chance in hell the chauffeur's mate doesn't get the job.

All the others stand a chance of getting somewhere.

@cstross BAe systems, who then have to navigate the contract market for retired folks with a particular set of skills via coded posts on Indeed.com, a la COBOL greybeards in IT
@cstross They'd spend £100m and hire McKinsey to study the issue. McKinsey's plan would involve redefining the City of London as "Britain" for the purposes of the reforging...
@cstross The last two are not mutually exclusive
Put it under the throne next to the Stone of Scone, and then act surprised at the inevitable heist movie.

@cstross went with hardening in blood of claimant, as BAe Systems would never get the contract these days.

It’d be lowest bidder, go to some shell company in the Caymans spun up by a Tory peer a week previously with no prior smithing experience, go spectacularly over budget and schedule and eventually deliver an IKEA steak knife

@witewulf @cstross A steak knife which at some point had actually been in the same building as the original fragments. Though not in the same *room*, that would be silly.
@witewulf @cstross The IKEA Steak knife is *chef’s kiss*!
@cstross ...And the reforged sword would not actually have ANY PART of the original sword in it, and wouldn't even actually look like a sword. At least, not like any sword forged by anyone who actually understands how a sword works and what it's for.
@cstross Actually if I were to seriously wonder what would happen in, say, New Management context, they would contract the reforging out to Wilkinson Sword, who would produce a perfectly serviceable and functional sword that looked more like a prop from John Boorman's Excalibur than like the original sword.
@cstross
Should, and current conspiracy-of-fools Would, are rather different.
@cstross fun fact: the chauffeurs bestie IS the CEO of BEA
@cstross No idea, but pretty sure that first of all, they'll blame French for hiding it for all this time.

@cstross

Re-forged in the fires of Mount Doom, surely?

@cstross In practise, they would make loud flashy announcements every six months on how they're going to do it but never deliver.