I need to speak to the person at Apple who wrote this UI copy.
@ismh I know it's going to have been written in Swift or Objective C, but I'm noticing it's funny how similar this looks to a default Java dialog you see in a lot of Java programs.
@ismh If only this could be accomplished with some kind of interface element that could be interacted with using a mouse. Alas, no such element exists.
@Chris @ismh There are a finite number of buttons and they have finally used them all up
@Chris @ismh i *guess* this might be because you could be bouncing something very long and wouldn’t want to cancel that accidentally, but even still, that’s pretty dumb.
@Chris @ismh .. Do you know what the memory footprint of an NSButton is!? It’d never fit into those 8Gb of RAM! 😎
@ismh why isn’t there just a cancel button?!
@ismh they once had a HIG that would show an example of how to do views like this or software update views so that things like this don’t happen. Then they got rid of that HIG.
@marioguzman @ismh I bet this hasn't been touched since before Apple acquired Logic 😂
@collin @marioguzman @ismh Command + Period — now that takes me back.
@ismh That is an abomination. How did that get past QA?

@patro85 @ismh My bet is that (the cancel button was vetoed for some reason and) “Press ⌘.” confused people into ignoring the period as punctuation.

Still not the best end solution though.
#cc @jsnell

@ismh 😆 I mean at least they show some sort of dialogue to tell you that's an option. I usually mash button combinations trying to remember what it is if I ever need to cancel a bounce.
@ismh I agree, they should just put a "Cancel" button that when you click on it would say "here's how to cancel, hold down the command key and press period.”
@jsnell @ismh What if pressing the Cancel button sent the same signal as holding Cmd and period?
@jsnell @ismh Can we talk about why “Save as…/Export as…" is “Bounce” in the music industry? Such a weird term. As a Logic novice (even though I'm a musician), I had too look up how to save my songs to mp3 just because I had no idea what bounce meant.
@jsnell @ismh @petergarner
Yeah Peter, a term that goes back to multi-track analog recorders, which, if I had to guess, most Logic Pro users in 2023 have never seen or used. Other oddity is “Bounce in Place” which is super useful in many cases, and is actually closer to what “bounce” meant: mixing and moving (via the recording console) a few recorded tracks to a single one, in order to free them up to record more parts in your production.

@jsnell @ismh Oooh, I can play this game!

This one goes out to the macOS Sonoma UI folks... I hope it pisses you off as much as it does me.

@TPOHolmes @jsnell @ismh Great, now I’m going to procrastinate on upgrading until they stop making security updates for whatever comes before is called.

If I’m inactive I don’t need the thing turning back on after five minutes of blanking. Just stay blanked until I need you.

@dlek @jsnell @ismh THAT's an interpretation of it I hadn't even considered!

I want to know where the batteries with displays are. And why it’d ask for my password 5 seconds AFTER the display turns off? And why one option uses “After" while the others use “For” when neither seems right for the purpose? And is “screen saver" capitalized or no?

How can so many things be wrong with only four options described in only 40 words?

Which brings me to one of my favorite phrases…
Who tested this shit?

@ismh Sure enough, the proper text to convey period is even used in the HIG.
@ismh Also, it's great that they finally told people how to do that (which almost nobody knew), but would it have killed them to just put… A CANCEL BUTTON there?
@marcoarment @ismh woah, that's crazy talk. buttons don't grow on trees you know.
@marcoarment @ismh Logic predates OS X so my bet would be this is a holdover from some absolutely prehistoric event handling code.
@marcoarment @ismh Are you sure there's not a button there somewhere that slowly fades into view when you hover over it for 10 mins?
@ismh Fixed.
@jamesthomson @ismh when people say Siri is bad, it’s because they haven’t tried asking it nicely.
@jamesthomson @ismh “I found this on the web for ‘Top pouncing cheese’”

@ismh Change text to: “Cancelling this operation generally does not work so press [Command/Apple] [Alt/Opt] [Esc] at the same time to force quit this program”

(Of course in Mac OS Classic this would generally crash the Mac too 😂)

@ismh I could almost live with it if not for the inconsistent use of symbols and glyph names. It should be “⌘ key (Command)” or “press period (.)”.
@sentience @ismh I thought that was the whole point of the post, but you’re the first to actually mention it.
@ismh I love the addition of the “.” at the end just to confuse you as to how many times you need to press it!
@ismh Coincidentally that is a system-wide shortcut for something else on my system. I wonder whether it will trigger my shortcut or stop bouncing. Is there a way to know beforehand?
@ismh And odd one, you’re right…so I Command-B and walk away…I bet you do, too.