@thatvirtualboy @BasicAppleGuy Dashboard hands down (and not just because I wrote an ebook on building widgets for it).
Sonoma web apps are far better but the utility of Dashboard and its ability to place widgets in a freeform way are two of the biggest things I miss.
@BasicAppleGuy Mac OS X Dashboard has stylistic good looking widgets, but tends to be often forgotten.
Sonoma is more focused on ready-to-use, easily readable widgets, which honestly is more to my liking.
So I'd go to Sonoma for this one, but I do respect the charm OS X Dashboard provided though.
@BasicAppleGuy I definitely preferred Tiger ones!
But not because of their design - because of a separate layer with widgets.
With Sonoma, initially I put a lot of widgets on the desktop to try them, only to realize that I basically never see my desktop because I have windows all over my desktop because that's why I have desktop OS 🤷♂️