GNOME users, I have some questions for you! This won’t single-handedly drive the design of GNOME (I’m not that influential… yet 😉 ), but anecdata is always nice to help unstick design discussions or just gather insights.

(Polls will follow posts as I can’t share an image and a poll, sadly.)

#GNOMEdesign #GNOME #UX

If you use GNOME, do you use the “Recent” view in the Files app? Note this is NOT the same as the file chooser, e.g. when opening a file in an app.

(Answer in the following poll.)

#GNOMEdesign #GNOME #UX

If you use GNOME, do you use the “Recent” view in the Files app? Note this is NOT the same as the file chooser, e.g. when opening a file in an app.

(See previous post for a screenshot, reply for context.)

#GNOMEdesign #GNOME #UX

Yes, frequently
22%
Occasionally
22.7%
Rarely
24%
Never
31.4%
Poll ended at .

If you use GNOME, do you use the “Recent” view in the file chooser, e.g. when opening a file in an app? Note this is NOT the same as when browsing in the Files app.

(Answer in the following poll.)

#GNOMEdesign #GNOME #UX

If you use GNOME, do you use the “Recent” view in the file chooser, e.g. when opening a file in an app? Note this is NOT the same as when browsing in the Files app.

(See previous post for a screenshot, reply for context.)

#GNOMEdesign #GNOME #UX

Yes, frequently
43.6%
Occasionally
26.8%
Rarely
14.3%
Never
15.3%
Poll ended at .

If you use GNOME, do you use the “Starred” view in the Files app?

(Answer in the following poll.)

#GNOMEdesign #GNOME #UX

If you use GNOME, do you use the “Starred” view in the Files app?

(See previous post for a screenshot, reply for context.)

#GNOMEdesign #GNOME #UX

Yes, frequently
7.5%
Occasionally
12.9%
Rarely
16%
Never
63.6%
Poll ended at .

If you use GNOME, do you use the “Large Text” option in Settings → Accessibility → Seeing?

Alternatively, do you set a different font scaling factor somewhere else, e.g. in Tweaks?

(Answer in the following poll.)

#GNOMEdesign #GNOME #UX

If you use GNOME, do you use the “Large Text” option in Settings → Accessibility → Seeing?

Alternatively, do you set a different font scaling factor somewhere else, e.g. in Tweaks?

(See previous post for screenshots, reply for context.)

#GNOMEdesign #GNOME #UX

Yes, “Large Text” in Settings
8.9%
Yes, larger font scaling set somewhere else
14.7%
Yes, smaller font scaling set somewhere else
7.3%
No, no change to text/font size
69.1%
Poll ended at .

If you use GNOME, do you use “Focus on Hover” or “focus follows mouse” behavior in GNOME?

(Answer in the following poll.)

#GNOMEdesign #GNOME #UX

If you use GNOME, do you use “Focus on Hover” (also known as “focus follows mouse”) behavior in GNOME?

(See previous post for a screenshot, reply for context.)

#GNOMEdesign #GNOME #UX

Yes
12.8%
No
79.1%
Not sure
8.1%
Poll ended at .

If you use GNOME, do you use startup/auto-starting apps, e.g. apps that launch when you log in?

(Feel free to reply for context/nuance!)

#GNOMEdesign #GNOME #UX

Yes, for apps running in the background
41.9%
Yes, for apps that open a window when starting
4.7%
Yes, for a mix of background and windowed apps
18.1%
No
35.3%
Poll ended at .

If you use GNOME, do you use Tweaks for one of these settings, and/or something else?

• Text size/font scaling
• Window focus behavior
• Startup/auto-starting apps

(Sorry this is worded kind of awkwardly… Feel free to reply for context/nuance!)

#GNOMEdesign #GNOME #UX

Yes, ONLY for one or more of the above
10.9%
Yes, for one or more of the above, plus more
39.3%
I use Tweaks, but not for the above
26.1%
No, I don’t use Tweaks
23.8%
Poll ended at .

@cassidy

I imagine a common one a lot of users do is adding back minimise and maximise/restore buttons

Also disabling the "attach modal" setting

@cassidy I used to until mouse acceleration was added to settings
@gnuntoo I love to hear it! You’ll probably notice that we’ve been migrating more and more “tweaks” into Settings proper. These polls are related to ongoing discussions among the design team, and I love hearing feedback like this!
@cassidy You and the team tweak my life for the better, thank you

@cassidy The biggest reason i use tweaks as others have mentioned is to enable the extra window buttons "Minimise and Maximise". However i also use it to change the GTK3 Theme to Adwaita dark (personally i don't know why this isn't changed when going from light to dark in the appearance settings).

Love seeing the ongoing discussions from the Gnome team! Thank you!

@tsoulard @cassidy that's an interesting one - the new "dark mode" switch in settings requires application opt-in.

That's because changing the gtk3 theme out from under applications will make them unusable if they happened to have hardcoded colours in app-specific styles which assumed the default/light theme.

@tsoulard More than anything 'cause the idea is to respect what the apps really support, rather than forcing a theme on them and several ending up half broken

@nahuel That's fair but my understanding that with the default GTK3 themes is they shouldn't cause any issues with theming. As it is "just" a dark theme.

Although i suppose it could cause other issues with app styling i think for me right now my concern is dark mode isn't really "dark mode" in the same way it could be with just a switch to the default GTK3 theme but I'm not aware of the entire picture!

@tsoulard Sure, but then you have programs like MySQL Workbench that make use of GTK 3's foreign drawing to draw parts of their interface "respecting" the user's GTK theme.

After applying any dark theme, you end up with half app in light theme, and half app in dark theme, and even with dark on dark cases

@tsoulard If the app really supports dark mode, let it implement support for the color scheme standard and that's it.
@nahuel ah gotcha that makes way more sense, I knew I was missing something thank you!
@cassidy I also use tweaks to add more information in the top bar clock, and to enable centering new windows by default (I don't think that's the default at least?)
@cassidy i only use it for managing startup apps, but hey i started writing a #libadwaita app to just do only one thing: add, remove and edit startup apps. Considering i am still a beginner, there are a lot of issues where i am unable to know what to do: like how to access app icons outside flatpak sandbox and stuff like that (all the issues i mostly have are related to flatpak sandbox because i would want my app to packaged as flatpak while still having whole functionality)
@hemish hopefully we can move this into Settings in some way that makes sense! I think we’re a little hesitant to add yet-another pane to Settings, but if it’s something people use, it would be good to have one less reason to have to install Tweaks. :)
@cassidy I recall there being some designs around this feature being added to an application setting page under "Apps". Either way, if this gets added, it would be a huge win for novice user's using GNOME.

@cassidy

If I only use it for setting auto starting applications

@cassidy I use it for auto starting apps, modifying top bar date display to include day of week, and setting window close buttons to be on the left side for consistency with macOS which I have to use for work.
@cassidy I have used focus follows mouse since before gnome existed 🙃. I mostly run Ubuntu for desktop systems with gnome, and periodically my focus-follows-mouse breaks on upgrade and I have to go googling to figure out how to get it back. But I don't remember how I did last time 🤷‍♂️

@cassidy No, but:

I would use it to launch my chat apps in the background but only to get notifications (I don't now b/c I don't have tweaks installed). I would also launch things like Syncthing but as far as I can tell it auto-launches itself somehow anyway

I would use it to launch my foreground apps if GNOME supported that natively (not via tweaks) and could place the windows on given workspaces. For instance, I usually have a browser on workspace 1, a terminal on 2, and Spotify on 3

@AdrianVovk if you use Syncthing, then I would say you do use an auto-starting background app, even if GNOME doesn't have a way to configure it natively. :)
@cassidy voted no, but I use Software, and Software launches in the background when I log in, so technically that'd be a yes
@cassidy No, but I would use “reopen windows when logging back in” like on macOS if it was an option
@gnuntoo ooh, I have a colleague deep into a long project to make that possible to actually restore app state instead of just launching all the apps in their default states. It’s a huge undertaking, though!
@cassidy I would love that. My workflow is I keep my system running 24/7, and all my stuff is there, and if my computer shuts off it’s like my house burned down and I have to rebuild my life on a farm
@cassidy I only use it to automatically start Syncthing.

@cassidy yes, but I didn't configure it. I have Nextcloud launching in the background by default.

I also use GSConnect, and you could argue that it is an "application" launched in the background.

@cassidy I don't currently use auto-starting apps, but considering that I manually launch four or five apps every single time I log in, my life would probably be a little better if I did just make them auto-start.
@cassidy Since I discovered the meta-1, meta-2, meta-3,... shortcuts to open apps straight from the overview, I can start everything I need with 5 simple keycombos :)
@cassidy I use systemd user session services, and if the GNOME autostart GUI were an interface to that, I'd probably use it ... very rarely, since I have my setup the way I like it already.
@cassidy I didn't even know it was an option to change such behaviour. But I just tried it and it wasn't for me.
@cassidy Answering this question with yes or no makes no sense.
@kmk it’s a yes or no question, not an either-or. I tweaked the language to make that more clear!
@cassidy Not currently, but I just might start. Frequently I find myself changing workspaces and my focus is unexpectedly in a window on another monitor, so I type in the wrong place. This is especially hellish if I did Ctrl+Q to close one app and accidentally closed another.
@cassidy Technically it wasn't Settings but the Accessibility menu in the top bar, when I first set up the home media laptop connected to the TV, to make the text readable across the room.

@mgedmin ah, good differentiation! That changes the same setting under the hood, just from either the menu or the Settings app. Hm.

If GNOME supported more display scaling options out of the box, would you use that, instead? E.g. being able to set 150% in Settings → Displays → Scale.

@cassidy I tried 125% for a while, after enabling the experimental gsetting. Went to 100% scaling and 120% font size in the end. (Different laptop this time, 1080p at 13")
@mgedmin Fascinating! Why the 100% display scaling with 120% font size instead of the 125% display scaling?
@cassidy Fuzzy text in XWayland apps. I had to use an Electron app and couldn't figure out how to force it into native Wayland mode (back then Chromium and Firefox had flags for this, off by default).

@cassidy I've set a larger font scaling using Tweaks on my laptop, I've found the default UI scaling too small on the FHD laptop screen, and the other scaling options didn't work well.

Fractional scaling works only on Wayland but the XWayland apps become very blurry. I've tried other scaling options as well and they also appear to be blurry.

@ymstnt YES the more-blurry-than-necessary XWayland apps when using fractional scaling is a huge pain, and my main gripe with it. I hope the right people hear this and change the scaling algorithm, at least, even if the apps are at 1×, they shouldn’t be blurrier than running them at 1×. :)
@cassidy ideally this should be part of overall GUI scaling/fractional scaling settings.
@matt one problem right now is that when you scale the text independently from the UI, you get REALLY wonky UI in places. E.g. most places don’t use text-based units for padding, borders, icon sizes, etc. so it starts to get really lopsided.
@cassidy that's a fair point. Isn't this part of the HIG though, to standardize those type of things?

@matt I mean, yes, we could say, “all apps should behave properly with any arbitrary text size,” but that’s… impossible. :)

Right now we support Large Text (1.25× size) and we say apps should be tested w/that, but it’s more a fundamental issue: we’d have to rewrite the stylesheet, every app, and probably GTK itself to use text size for scaling. Which… yeah, that’s a lot.

And even then, it’s not obvious how that would actually be better than just supporting overall fractional scaling.

@matt all that said, we’re looking at how to better support more use cases for text scaling and fractional scaling, and the first step is understanding how and why people use each.

@cassidy

I actually default to smaller text in settings, but I regularly and situationally scale text up based on website, app, light levels, etc. So B and C, I guess?

@tstooth hm, I would consider that the third poll option since you’re setting the GNOME font scaling smaller, but I understand the nuance. Thanks!

@cassidy

The bottom line is, font size is a base-level accessibility issue for me, and I'm just possessed of bog-standard aging vision. For my partner, it's a much more significant issue.