If Mastodon diehards want this to be The Next Place after Twitter, the move is to bend over backwards to listen to disabled and Black community about what they do and don't need in social media space.

Even if it's challenging.

Even if it makes you uncomfortable.

These are power user communities, whether folks like it or not.

@gwensnyder Sadly a lot want it not to be that. They want it to be their private gated suburban retirement community where you can only chat about "pleasant" things. They're happy to sit around eating lotuses while the world burns.
@dalias @gwensnyder I think we can find a middle ground between not discussing important issues at all, and constant doomscrolling. A lot of us just don't want that constant toxicity here.

@zorinlynx @gwensnyder You can find that by using all the great features Mastodon has:

Time limited muting of an account.
Disabling boosts for an account.
Unfollowing an account.
Setting up filters to hide some posts based on patterns.
Etc.

Not by tone policing people you're a rando to and trying to control others' experiences.

@dalias @gwensnyder Oh yeah, absolutely I would never try to tell someone they can't talk about what's important to them. That's the nice thing about the lack of an algorithm here; you don't get a lot of content you don't want.

@zorinlynx @dalias @gwensnyder
I'm in agreement and would like to add:

- You can oppose the push to make this "the next Twitter" and still agree with Gwen's opener (I do)

- The #SmallWeb push isn't necessarily the same as cloistered privilege

- The current tools and culture are great! That doesn't absolve us of listening to feedback and making improvements.
1/2

@zorinlynx @dalias @gwensnyder
What if #Mastodon is the scaffolding and cranes? Nothing about us without us; some communities weren't present when today's status was made quo. What if the best thing Mastodon does is bring us together, shows us that more things are possible, and provides a space to coordinate building what we really want / need.

Feels like we'll look back and see a stepping stone and that's great actually.
2/2

@dalias @zorinlynx @gwensnyder

how do i disable boosts for an account? i've never come across that function and i'm the type who explores

@meganox @zorinlynx @gwensnyder It's in the ... dropdown menu on their profile.

@dalias @zorinlynx @gwensnyder

not on web on my instance, thanks for the info tho, i'll poke around some more

@meganox @zorinlynx @gwensnyder It has to be an account you're already following to see it. It's for hiding boosts where that account is the one boosting it, not where they're the original author.

@dalias @zorinlynx @gwensnyder

ah of course, thanks for taking the time to explain

@meganox @zorinlynx @gwensnyder No problem. Glad to help folks getting settled in here figure out how to make Mastodon work best for the experience they want.
@dalias @zorinlynx @gwensnyder Is there a difference between “tone policing” and calling a poster out for being racist? Political correctness can certainly go too far, but I find nothing objectionable about criticizing shitty things that people post. Maybe I’m not understanding what you mean by “tone policing.”

@johngove @zorinlynx @gwensnyder Yes there's a difference - they're pretty much opposites.

One is a matter of content considered unacceptable because of how it causes harm and because of specific history of power relationships.

The other is a matter of declaring the means of expression by which someone informs about and organizes against those power dynamics unacceptable because it's unpleasant for you to hear.

@dalias @zorinlynx @gwensnyder Ah, understood. You’re not objecting to legitimate criticism of harmful opinions (like racism). You’re criticizing those who object to the way that legitimate criticism (of things like racism) are expressed.

@dalias @zorinlynx @gwensnyder

THANK YOU @dalias for saying so. Your voice of reason is appreciated.

There are so many people who keep saying "nothing political" but aparently the fact that I exist is political. It's very strange. It's like a white picket fence. I genuinely don't understand what we are supposed to post. Flowers & sunsets?

It feels like control freaks on here just seem angry at everything and everyone and keep telling people to be nice without following the same advice.

@zorinlynx @dalias @gwensnyder interesting you call it doomscrolling and constant toxicity
@gwensnyder @dalias @zorinlynx @BabsSheKing Right? What some call “doomscrolling” and “constant toxicity” I call “marginalized people speaking openly about our lives” and “listening to and amplifying each other.”

@loosestrings @gwensnyder @dalias @BabsSheKing I absolutely agree that the discourse needs to happen. But it's also a mental health issue for many. It's telling that my depression goes away when I'm off social media a few days.

We just need a better balance I think. I wish I could just have a "catch up on the discourse" period each day, and the rest of the time sharing cat pictures etc.

@zorinlynx @loosestrings @gwensnyder @BabsSheKing The problem is when someone decides other people's actions to change oppressive conditions they live under have to go on pause or be "less attention-seeking" (i.e. completely ineffective) for the sake of their mental health.

Mastodon gives us much better tools than other social media did to put that on pause *just from our own view* while not interfering with the needs of others to speak in a manner that's effective.

@zorinlynx @loosestrings @gwensnyder @BabsSheKing Beyond the built-in tools like filters and temporary muting, the open protocol makes it possible to create all kinds of new mental health oriented accessibility tools.

Grouping filtered posts into a digest queue, to consume at a time when you feel able to deal with them, is totally doable as a client app feature or an instance feature.

@loosestrings @gwensnyder @dalias @zorinlynx @BabsSheKing

𝓣𝓱𝓪𝓽’𝓼 𝓽𝓱𝓮 𝓬𝓻𝓾𝔁 𝓸𝓯 𝓽𝓱𝓮 𝓲𝓼𝓼𝓾𝓮.

@zorinlynx @dalias @gwensnyder

𝓔𝓷𝓸𝓾𝓰𝓱 𝓶𝓲𝓭𝓭𝓵𝓮 𝓰𝓻𝓸𝓾𝓷𝓭 𝓷𝓸𝓷𝓼𝓮𝓷𝓼𝓮 𝓫𝓮𝓽𝔀𝓮𝓮𝓷 𝓸𝓹𝓹𝓻𝓮𝓼𝓼𝓸𝓻 𝓪𝓷𝓭 𝓸𝓹𝓹𝓻𝓮𝓼𝓼𝓮𝓭.

♥️
#JohnMastodon

@dalias @gwensnyder

On Twitter users could browbeat the corporation to allocate resources to address issues and add features.

But on Mastodon there's no parent company or corporate sponsors.

End users either donate for software development or they don't.

There's been a big surge of financial support. It's now... 21,000 Euros a month.

Mastodon's main dev works 14 hours a day and is paid 34,000 Euros a year.

@Jollyspaniard @gwensnyder This has what to do with the thread you replied to?
@dalias @gwensnyder I don't let those people have their way. I say something. So far, they haven't had a response for me.
@gwensnyder I've been saying the first platform that makes itself safe for Black and Brown users will win for about a decade now.

And we're seeing Masto repeating those same mistakes while banging the drum about how 'different' it is.
@gwensnyder and beyond the practical reasons, providing a safe, welcoming space for these folks is just the right thing to do

@gwensnyder

Do you even realize how old the Fediverse is? Nobody is going to bend over backwards. Just do your thing like everybody else and enjoy.

@roelfrenkema @gwensnyder how old, chump?

@mawhrin
@gwensnyder

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fediverse

I started of with identi.ca had Gnu social running, Friendica diaspora and now Mastodon. IMHO the best implementation yet. But it could be superseded by Nextcloud as it is simpler to install.

When newcomers start blowing of their tops what has to change and that we have to bend backwards to facilitate it, that irritates me whatever your cause is or how important you think it is.

Just settle and watch for a while discover how everything works. Find the limitless possibilities the Fediverse offers you. Be amazed how many minorities you will find here peacefully coexisting.

Then when you want changes find out how to make them. It is up to you and not some cabal to make the changes you want. You make them nobody else.

Not satisfied with the culture? Run your own server.

Not satisfied with the software. Go to github make requests or fork the software.

It's really easy. Don't demand. Participate and contribute. It's that simple.

Fediverse - Wikipedia

@roelfrenkema @mawhrin @gwensnyder are you blind and using a screen reader? Don't demand alt text or supports! Just go code your own system to describe images to you. /S

It's great that this is decentralized and interoperable, so people can use whichever things best fit their needs/wants and still connect with others. It's absurd to assume everyone can just do it all themselves.

@ladyunicornejg

You need to re-read my message. Nowhere have I said you are om your own. We are a community and have a culture. I for one try to use alt whenever I don't forget and even use the reminder robot. Maybe you should read the OP to read my message in context. But even out of context you are stating things I never said.

@[email protected] @gwensnyder

@gwensnyder not sure what its going to take to get people to realize that there is no coherent group that's out trying to make mastodon "The Next Place after Twitter", but yelling at strangers on a platform you just discovered isn't going to help you anyway. Take this kind of attitude back to twitter, where you were correctly ridiculed for how tendentious and loudly wrong you were, often, about seemingly everyone on the left. And before you try to label me a chapo (or whatever) know that I am not, and don't care in the least for them or their dogshit fan base, I just can't stand people like you digitally barking at everyone unfortunate enough to see your posts. You slandered quite a few decent hard working socialist, for years now, to come here and then try and dictate terms and I for one am not going to listen to it quietly.
@count3rmeasure @gwensnyder Like, who is she "yelling" and "barking" at? She published a post to her followers. It's fine if you disagree with her, but that whole "go back to..." has some ugly connotations, particularly for people of color. She has a right to be here and share her thoughts just as much as you do, so just mute her if you don't want to hear from her.
@Meme she isn't a person of color though, and the constant slippage between that and white people who want ventriloquize on behalf of people of color is exactly the point. She can mute away at her hearts content as well, fwiw. And finally, the reason I took the time to comment, and am leaving that comment up is because she lied and slandered quite a few serious activists and socialists on twitter, for years, because they simply didn't share her increasingly unhinged opinions. She is welcome to say what she wants, and...wait for it...so am I. She can get the push back for lying about people for years...and I can get people like you to invoke invisible POCs as a talisman to scare away legitimate critique of her and words (and actions). She is not the only person to have been hunted by fascists, she is not the only person to have done life threatening antifascist work. Maybe take some time to educate yourself about the person you're jumping to defend.
@count3rmeasure Well *I* am a woman of color, and I feel "go back to" is a shameful and all-too-convenient response from those in the majority. Clearly your issues with her predate her post, and that's like fine, I guess. You can criticize her, and I can defend her right to say what she said in that post as something other than "yelling" and "barking" and also defend her right NOT to "go back to" the bird site. Pretty simple.
@count3rmeasure this and the preceding post are perhaps the most reported we’ve had. I am trying not to knee jerk react. Can you give me any additional context behind the comments?
@gwensnyder As far as I understand this is not the end goal for Mastodon.
I'd argue that giving space to the disenfranchised would be more of a goal.
Still I'd would not disregard the challenges.
@gwensnyder that last part. Black people pioneered Twitter's humor quite frankly
@gwensnyder Every post i see from a non-white person that makes me uncomfortable makes me want to read into whatever made me that way. Internalized racism makes me uncomfortable so i need to dive head first to eliminate the discomfort with education.
@gwensnyder Personally speaking, the next twitter is the last thing I want. I left twitter for a reason, to get away from all the millennial culture wars.
@C0_WAV @gwensnyder millennial culture wars?

@mawhrin @gwensnyder Indeed. Personally, my belief is that if we all agree not to be arseholes to each other, we'd no longer have to worry about whose group is most important.

Whether humanity is capable of that is another question, but it would be better than dividing ourselves in squabbling groups and letting the powers that be steal all our money and put it in the Cayman Islands while we're distracted with hatred for each other.

@C0_WAV @gwensnyder fascinating. didn't realise that reminding white folks they're responsible for their shit is such novelty approach.

@mawhrin @gwensnyder Well, I can't speak for white folk, but personally I try to deal kindly with everyone regardless of melanin production. Everyone else is as human as I am.

If you have a specific charge to bring against me, then do so. I'm many things, but a racist is not one of them.

It shouldn't matter, if you're black, white, yellow, red, gay, straight, bi, pan, trans.. whatever. Everyone should be treated with a fundamental respect. If they commit crime, then put them on fair trial.