Reliable Witness [Sermon]
Thomas.
Who was called Didymus.
Which means Twin.
Thomas comes from the Aramaic ta’oma, which also means twin.
Twin of… whom?
There’s a thought that Thomas Didymus looked like Jesus, or was spiritually similar to Jesus.
And now we don’t think of Thomas the Twin. We think of Doubting Thomas.
Let’s go to God in prayer.
God of wisdom, may the words that I speak, and the ways they are received by each of our hearts and minds, to help us to continue to grow into the people, and the church, that you have dreamed us to be.
Amen.
Eyewitness testimony is highly valued in court cases, because someone SAW It.
Unfortunately, eyewitness testimony can be inaccurate. Studies have shown that every time we remember something, we risk having that memory altered.
It is like when you open that letter in your word processor to review it, and then close it. Sometimes your word processor asks “do you want to save your document?” And in that moment, you think “well I don’t want to lose it” and say “Yes.”
But that means anything that changed got saved. Maybe you accidentally clicked something, or pressed a key. Now that letter is changed.
So just remembering something can change the memory. And sometimes the eyewitness is not considered reliable.
Like…
The women who, in our readings last Sunday, told the disciples that Jesus had risen from the dead.
You thought I was going to say the Disciples.
Well, the women were disciples too, so you could be excused. But the men disciples dismissed the testimony of the women disciples, perhaps because they were women, or maybe just because it sounded… implausible.
Whatever the reason, after Jesus appears to the disciples, saying “Shalom” (that’s peace be with you, or hello, or goodbye) they tell the Twin, Didymus, Ta’oma, Thomas, that Jesus appeared to them, and he’s not accepting their testimony.
He’s called “Doubting Thomas” for doubting the men disciples who doubted the women disciples.
If anything, I would think the disciples behind locked doors might have doubted Jesus at first, at least before “he showed them his hands and his side.” – John 20:20 NRSVue
After all, if Thomas looked like Jesus, it might have been Thomas.
“Since the crucifixion, has anyone seen Jesus and Thomas together?” they might have asked.
But they tell Thomas what they saw.
We don’t know how many disciples there were in the room. There were more than one, because the word is plural. There may have been ten of the twelve closest disciples: everyone but Thomas and Judas. There may have been more: there were disciples who followed Jesus who were not in his inner circle of twelve.
But Thomas had more than one witness, and he needed more proof.
We are two thousand years after these events. We have no eyewitnesses. And we have over two and a half billion Christians in many different communities of faith, with many different ideas about what actually happened.
For some, the Bible is the Holy Word of God and is inerrant. So whatever it says is true.
For some, the Bible we have is not the original writings, and we try to get as accurate translations as we can from the earliest texts we can find.
For some, we try to understand the writings in the culture they were written.
And we come to different places with how the resurrection happened, what it means to us, and how it affects our faith.
Some of us simply think we need to believe that Jesus existed.
Some of us think we need to believe in the resurrection in a specific way.
Some of us think we need to believe that the crucifixion and resurrection is what brings us grace.
Some of us think the crucifixion and resurrection are what demonstrates that the grace was already there.
But what we all ought to agree on, if we are going to put any faith at all in the four accounts of Jesus’ life that were accepted into the Christian Bible, is that Jesus taught us to love each other, over and over: to love our friends and enemies, to love our countrymen and foreigners, to just love people.
And that’s why I think John 20:23, where it says
If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you retain the sins of any, they are retained.
John 20:33 NRSVue
Is not a grant of power, but a warning.
If we love one another, even the people we don’t like, how can we decide people need to retain their sins? If Jesus said to the men who were about to stone the woman accused of adultery
“Let anyone among you who is without sin be the first to throw a stone at her.”
John 8:7b
how much more is Jesus’ saying that to us now?
If the Gospels are reliable witnesses to anything, they are reliable witnesses to something on which they all agree, and something we know in our hearts to be true: That we should love one another, as Jesus loves us.
So maybe it’s time to give a little grace to the twin, after two thousand years of retaining his sin of doubt.
My challenge to each of us this week is to think about how we are forgiving or retaining the sins of people we ought to love, that is, the sins of everyone.
Forgiveness is not permission to cause harm again, but recognition that what has been done cannot be changed, even if the heart has changed.
May you believe in grace, and have life in the name of Jesus.
Amen.
Let’s sing CH 344 I Have Decided to Follow Jesus
* Scripture quotations marked NRSVue are taken from the New Revised Standard Version Updated Edition. Copyright © 2021 National Council of Churches of Christ in the United States of America. Used by permission. All rights reserved worldwide. https://www.friendshippress.org/pages/about-the-nrsvue
* Scripture quotations marked KJV are taken from the King James version of the Bible.
Follow this blog on Mastodon or the Fediverse to receive updates directly in your feed.
#doubt #grace #twin #witness