The Trouble with Harryâs grammar
Alfred Hitchcockâs comedy-thriller The Trouble with Harry (1955), amidst all its talk of murder and romance, has a fun little exchange of sociolinguistic interest between John Forsythe (âSam Marloweâ) and Edmund Gwenn (âCapt. Albert Wilesâ):
Marloweâs correction is notable for being relatively polite. Those who correct othersâ speech uninvited often do so in a rude and judgemental way. Marlowe corrects Wiles gently and off-handedly, as though automatically correcting a child. Indeed, Wiles doesnât even notice and reacts as if Marlowe had merely echoed him. For good measure he adds another nonstandard usage: past tense say for said.
That Miles doesnât pick up on the prescriptive nudge also chimes with what happens when children have their speech corrected â they tend to repeat what they said rather than immediately adopt the âproperâ form. Abby Kaplan, in her excellent book about language myths, Women Talk More than Men, reviews the research and concludes:
Some parents tend to repeat or expand on their childrenâs utterances, but it is unclear whether children actually use this kind of feedback to correct their own speech. Since there are societies in which this kind of interaction is rare, it is unlikely that repetitions and expansions are absolutely necessary for language acquisition.
Of course, Captain Wiles has already fully acquired his language: itâs just that the variety or dialect he uses differs in some respects from standardized English, prompting Marloweâs useless intervention.
The script for The Trouble with Harry was written by John Michael Hayes. I donât know if the same exchange appears in the source novel by Jack Trevor Story, but Hitchcock obviously liked it. He featured another linguistic allusion, to Alfred Korzybski and his General Semantics, in The Birds:
Hitchcockâs interest in usage also manifests in a letter he wrote to Ernest Lehman, writer of North by Northwest, in which he wondered, in a parenthetical aside, if his use of while should be whilst. I covered the whilst, amongst, amidst issue in a previous post.
#AbbyKaplan #acting #AlfredHitchcock #AlfredKorzybski #dialect #EdmundGwenn #ethnolinguistics #film #GeneralSemantics #grammar #humour #language #languageAcquisition #linguistics #prescriptivism #sociolinguistics #TheBirds #TheTroubleWithHarry #TippiHedren #usage #whilst