France calls new Olympic gender testing 'backward step'

The IOC announced on Thursday that only 'biological females' will be allowed to compete in women's events, preventing transgender women from competing.

Le Monde
@alice
It's technically my second reason to not watch. My first was that displays of nationalism always bothered me somewhat.
@alice Preparing the popcorn for the backlash when they'll realise that the people it'll impact at 100% are cis women.

@transcendentempress @alice

Ahem, that Algerian fighter (Imane Khelif*) is fucking cis.

Her father had to show her birth certificate to the world to prove she is and always has been a girl.

Angela Carini can suck it. I don't care if I'm Italian too, she's a shame for my country, she's a shame for the whole Italian military corps.

* thank you, @linuxandyarn I've edited my post

@anominominominous yeah, the quote from Rowling in that article is bonkers, like how can she be so wrong and yet so smug about it?

@transcendentempress

@alice

That is a venomous, spiteful and slanderous thing to say. Imane is a woman, and always has been, and has proven to be by her family and state authorities. Algeria should sue Enoch Blyton for ever last penny.

@anominominominous @transcendentempress

@alexadeswift one of my country's top newspapers (in printed numbers, not quality) called Imane Khelif "an intersex athlete", they did that while publishing her photo and added the title "transgender women out of the Olympics". I felt sick reading it.
@alice @anominominominous @transcendentempress

@jt_rebelo ugh, it's like their feelings don't care about facts. Another example of self-tattling.

@alexadeswift @anominominominous @transcendentempress

@alice

They have never cared about facts, it is all about them and their revulsion against difference. It is akin to "uncanny valley", they see a woman who doesn't pressent " correctly" as a woman and they are instantly revolted by what they see, or more accurately, perceive, and go instantly in to attack that person. The use of dehumanising language here is deliberate as well, as this means that they do not see us as human beings. Amd that further enables their vendetta of hate.

@jt_rebelo @anominominominous @transcendentempress

@anominominominous @transcendentempress @alice And the whole controversy over Imane Khelif began because of sour grapes and Russian corruption.
https://apnews.com/article/olympics-2024-khelif-russia-boxing-b53b1edda21139d14a572bd35ca440e6
Imane Khelif outcry fueled by banned boxing body with Russia ties

The allegations that Olympic boxers Imane Khelif and Lin Yu-ting failed an eligibility test for women's competition have been made by only the International Boxing Association. That's also the only governing body that has ever been completely banished from the Olympics. The entire boxing world has already learned to expect almost anything from the Russian-dominated organization, whose untransparent tests have been seized upon by those criticizing the female boxers amid wider clashes about gender regulations and perceptions in sports. The IOC has decades of bad history with the beleaguered governing body, and it has exasperatedly begged non-boxing people to pay attention to the sole source of the allegations against Khelif and Lin.

AP News

@anominominominous @transcendentempress @alice Birth certificate doens't count. It's a genetic test for sry which in and of it self isn't conclusive either.

I wonder what support and councelling services they'll offer to people who suddenly find out that their 23rd chromosme pair isn't what they thought, in at least some of their cells, regardless of what sort of body they have.

None, of course. Being arbitrarily cast aside, and having your life turned upside down is the point.

@hypostase

Blah blah blah.

They should test the "men" too then.

But trans* and intersex men don't even exist in bigots' deranged world.

@anominominominous Absolutely. If they test one athlete they should test all regardless of sex or gender presentation.

But it's not about fairness, or justice or even reasonable moral choices, it's about entertainment for profit so that the billionaire class can suck up every more money.

@anominominominous @transcendentempress @alice And Imane Khelif was banned by her father from boxing as a child because it was 'not a sport for girls'.
@anominominominous @alice @linuxandyarn Never meant in any way that she isn't, what I wrote was in the sense that this kind of shitty policies is aimed, in the twisted minds of those behind them, at trans women, and like 100% of previous ones, it'll have impact almost exclusively on cis women.
@transcendentempress @alice it will also disproportionally affect non-white cis (and interssex) women. transphobia is also white supremacy, let's not forget.
@cairobraga have you read today's Jornal de Notícias front page? I felt physically sick with that one.
@transcendentempress @alice

@alice I haven't watched the ESC and latest olympics because of those *pesky* zionists,

I haven't watched the latest world cup because it was bathed in workers' blood.

I won't watch the next world cup because, let's be fair, fuck Trump and his deranged entourage and politics.

Now this is another solid reason why we should boycott any international event. Fuck them, fuck everyone involved.

Trans lives, workers' lives are way worth than any international event.

@alice @oddtail "may have exceptions for those who are not effected by the performance enchancing effects of testosterone" weird how "testosterone" isnt what their checking for then
@alice the only punching I would cheer would be anyone punching Rowling's smug, bigoted face.

@alice I got bothered by the commercialism and the artificiality a long time ago, and the disconnect between amateur sport for peace and professional support for the other.

It's long been a showcasing of power, and the sooner it (and other professional entertainment sport stuff) dies the death so that we can find better ways of enjoying physciality as a society the better.

But I won't hold my breath.

@alice it's a pearl how the Coventry is like "yeah, if it's illegal there, let's just do it somewhere else" like "killing a person is illegal, but you know if we go a country where killing is legal... not a big deal?"

@alice

Any "benefits" disappear once someone is on HRT.

The IOC said there may be "rare exceptions" for DSD athletes who do not benefit from the performance-enhancing effects of testosterone.

Fuck them and their disengenous bullshit.

@jrdepriest @alice Every day I hear about how I am a degenerate or something but also how I also have an unfair advantage over olympic atheletes and an unfair advantage over chess grand masters, etc. etc.

@ra6bit trans folx are Schrödinger's villain—simultaneously weak little snowflakes *and* more powerful than trained Olympians.

It's fucking ridiculous.

@jrdepriest

@alice @ra6bit @jrdepriest

'cuz we're not real to them - we're a spooky story they make up in their heads, and they aren't even talking about the real-world people involved; this is all about the imaginary person they made up to be mad at.

@ra6bit @jrdepriest @alice and the thing about 'unfair advantages' is, it's only considered a problem when a woman is perceived to have it.

Michael Phelps absolutely had unfair advantages that had nothing to do with fitness and training, and everything to do with genetics, body proportions and other innate factors. Nobody ever sought to disqualify him for the unfair competitive advantage he had. Nobody ever really called it an 'unfair advantage'. He was 'lucky' to be born that way. It was all hard work and discipline.

And his fellow swimmer Katie Ledecky was similarly successful *without* similarly unfair advantages. Lo and behold, there must be something wrong with her. She's not a 'real woman'. Maybe just make sure.

It's just so massively hypocritical.

@rainynight65 @ra6bit @alice

Michael Phelps was a mutant. Perfectly natural. God-given.

I am an abomination. Completely unnatural. From the Devil.

@rainynight65 @ra6bit @jrdepriest @alice (semisarcasm on) Phelps is a WHITE MAN and therefore can do no wrong, those who are not WHITE MEN are subhuman. This is white patriarchal thinking. (semisarcasm off)
@alice I wasnt watching them already because of the blatant corruption, but happy to have another reason not to

@alice

Let us just remember the complete list of trans woman who have qualified for in their own right, and competed in, the Olympics as the women they are:

And all those trans women who have gained medal places:

And not forgetting all those trans women who gained a place due to cis women having to pull out:

Laurel Hubbard - Aeoteroa New Zealand - finished last.

@alice Secondary to the obvious transphobia: imagine forcing all women olympians to get (some of) their DNA on file for such a trivial reason. No privacy for women I guess. Also, lots of cis women have sex chromosome variations. This will be such a shit show. I feel bad for the women having to suddenly end their career for some stupid DNA recombination quirk.
@alice It’s not the first time the IOC has done this. I’m reading a book called The Other Olympians that covers transmasc athletes competing in track and field during the 1930s, and how the IOC bowed to the original Nazi party when they pressured them to test because they were embarrassed their athletes were being beaten. It didn’t work then and it won’t work now.
@alice so cis woman that have higher testosterone levels then the average would be less of a woman for the Olympic staff ?
@alice the olympics have been bad for a long time. this is just *another* reason to avoid it
@alice well, it's just another reason for me, albeit a very sad one.
Sports, in particular high competitive clubs, always were a nest of harassment and sexual abuse, with tons of old testimonials coming to light in the recent years and tons yet shadowed by the patriarchy.