Highest Canadian nerd achievement UNLOCKED I'M SO EXCITED!!!!

QUIRKS AND QUARKS!!!!!!!!

And that was all because of Mastodon, thanks all! (Especially @mayintoronto whose comment got a Quirks and Quarks producer to get in touch with me via BlueSky-Fedi bridge. Wild. WILD.)

I wish I got to go on Quirks and Quarks and talk about a less depressing topic, but hey, this is SUCH a great opportunity to teach a *lot* of people in Canada about the terrible things that are happening in orbit, and in the upper atmosphere, and on the ground due to the wildly unregulated commercialization of orbit.

I just sent probably the most pretentious email I've ever sent in my life to some colleagues: "I'd love to meet up for lunch! But my interview with Bob McDonald for Quirks and Quarks might get scheduled at that time."

(AAAAHHHH!!! SO EXCITED!!!)

I just did my pre-interview for Quirks and Quarks. I am slightly less excited now, just because the pre-interview made it clear how completely fucking depressing this interview is going to be!

I have nothing good to say. I have no concrete actions for people to take. All I have are predictions about how unsafe, destructive, and environmentally catastrophic Reflect Orbital will be.

I sure hope I get a chance to work in something about how incredible the unpolluted night sky is, at least? Ooof.

The stars are still there, behind the clouds, satellites and light pollution, waiting for us.

Just got an email from a astronomer colleague who got asked by their local CBC station to do an interview tomorrow. "Do you know anything about Reflect Orbital?"

Hahah, sorry dude, it's sort of my fault that you have to talk about it. The campaign to reach out to journalists to educate the public about how terrible Reflect Orbital is is definitely working!

Going to add some pretty things to this thread.

Because today is Quirks and Quarks interview day(!!!), and at this point I'm about equal parts INCREDIBLY EXCITED to be on that show, and SUPER PISSED OFF that instead of getting to talk about cool astronomy research, I have to talk about a fucking stupid terrible techbro idea.

We're in a time when one tiny awful company in California can change the night sky for everyone in the world. The only tool I have to fight this is public opinion.

The FCC has explicitly stated that they plan to approve everything https://www.satellitetoday.com/government-military/2025/10/28/fcc-kicks-off-proceeding-to-overhaul-satellite-licensing/. There is no way to stop stupid fucking mirrors from being launched into orbit by US companies.

So, my fellow Canadians (and other non-USians), I need you to get really, really angry about this. Write to MPs, space agencies, senators, to anyone who will listen about this company wanting to shine light on us.

The sky is amazing! We have so much to learn! And it's just right there if we can keep it dark.

And yeah, oh my goodness, there are SO MANY THINGS to fight against right now. Pick one and talk to your government reps about it! If you love the sky, pick this fight. If you love something else that's being destroyed, focus on that. If you have no spoons left, be yourself and fight by existing and thriving!

I'm happy to lead this fight. I hope it works. Thanks for reading and appreciating how incredibly fucking stupid space mirrors are.

Do I need to practice saying "Znamya" just in case I get asked about it? (Because Russia already tried the fucking stupid space mirror thing decades ago and it didn't work: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Znamya_(satellite))

I have never said this before, but I kind of wish I had more meetings this morning to distract myself from overthinking the Quirks and Quarks interview...

Znamya (satellite) - Wikipedia

Here we gooooo
Ok interview done! Will be on Quirks and Quarks this Saturday! (Feels like that was not my best interview ever, they had rather restrictive questions...hopefully they edit it well! And hopefully lots of people will be angry about this)

Tomorrow I have an interview with the New York Times about that fucking space mirror company. Also an interview about Dark and Quiet Skies in general for the Supermassive podcast https://www.izzieclarke.com/supermassive

Wowee. I need a nap after that adrenaline let down (but meetings and afterschool kid things are not going to let me do that...)

Supermassive Podcast — Izzie Clarke

Izzie Clarke

Somehow getting to brag about being on Quirks and Quarks to the lady who works at my small town post office and always asks me space questions made me feel a LOT better about all of this.

(I bet dinner will make me feel even better! Time to get off the computer...)

My dark and quiet skies interview for the Supermassive podcast got moved to next week (totally ok with that) but I still have an interview with the New York Times today about That Fucking Stupid Space Mirror Company.

Other than that, I need to write some things today! The weather is awful (high winds and rain/snow all day) so maybe that will encourage buckling down and writing...

New York Times interview done! Lovely journalist! She's planning to slowly put this story together over the coming weeks as we see what is going to happen with FCC approval (which will require the US government to not be shut down)...
I got one text from a colleague saying they heard me on Quirks and Quarks. I don't think I'm going to listen to this one... let me know how it came out (I hope they edited well, that wasn't my best interview ever... sigh.)
@sundogplanets But but but, when will your interview show up? I want to listen to it.
@mcourcel It'll be up on Saturday!
@sundogplanets Totally listening. Thank you!
@sundogplanets Good luck and strong nerves
@sundogplanets “that fucking space mirror company” 🤭
@sundogplanets
Wow, you are super busy. Thank you for working so hard to make all the knuckleheads aware of the issues with all this "cool" space stuff they're buying into!
@sundogplanets woooo, you‘ll do great, I’ll watch the NYT closely!
@sundogplanets I love ‘that fucking space mirror company’(TM) 😂

@sundogplanets

you'll be fine, and if not the goats say they can distract you....

@sundogplanets

According to Wikipedia the spot traveled at a speed of 8 km/sec (5 mi/sec), that is 28800 km/h.
Pretty useless.

@GustavinoBevilacqua @sundogplanets Yeah, and even if they steered the mirror (which wouldn't be hard, earth observation satellites can track a point on the ground), a satellite in low orbit could only keep the spot aimed at a particular patch of ground for minutes at a time before the satellite disappears below the horizon

An actually usable mirror satellite would need to be in GEO, and that would necessitate a much larger mirror to get a useful spot size

@sundogplanets In another time there was Project Echo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Echo Talk about a big reflector in the night sky! It didn't work too well as a communications satellite but lead to the discovery of cosmic background radiation.
Project Echo - Wikipedia

@sundogplanets
I'm reminded of Sim City disasters.
@sundogplanets
The latest stupid Russian idea seems to be a nuclear *powered* missile, though not as bad as Project Orion.

@raymaccarthy @sundogplanets Hey, Orion was a good idea!

And this latest russian missile is just a worse (only high subsonic speed rather than mach 3 on the deck lol) knockoff of a 1960s US design that advanced as far as successful testing of the nuclear ramjet

@sundogplanets Thank you for all you do Dr. Sam

@sundogplanets I can at least help with pointing to the respective House and Senate subcommittees with FCC oversight and their members:

US House Subcommittee on Communications and Technology
https://energycommerce.house.gov/committees/subcommittee/communications-technology

US Senate Subcommittee on Telecommunications and Media
https://www.commerce.senate.gov/commerce-subcommittees

Read articles on why Reflect Orbital is stupid and make a list of points you want to make. Find your members and write!

#DarkSkies #DarkSkies4all

House Committee on Energy and Commerce

The Committee on Energy and Commerce is the oldest standing legislative committee in the U.S. House of Representatives and is vested with the broadest jurisdiction of any congressional authorizing committee.

House Committee on Energy and Commerce

@sundogplanets Thanks for doing this. Congrats on getting on Quirks and Quarks (such a great title) and thanks for calling out that Techbro.

The night sky is amazing and I miss seeing it in this city.

@sundogplanets Great another new terrible thing I have to learn a out

@sundogplanets

If Reflect Orbital put their stupid fucking mirrors in orbit, maybe we can crowd source a giant laser to push them off course with radiation pressure?

@gregeganSF @sundogplanets

They'll have a communications system, to control them. A nice little challenge for hackers, then. Can you get them to shine at each other enough to break them?

@sundogplanets
Beautiful.
I live in a city. I forget that the Milky Way can be seen like that.
@ldmay65 I highly recommend that you work in a little trip to get out and enjoy it again, if that's at all possible. The pictures are nice, but it's totally different when you're out in it! (I'm so grateful I can access it easily from my home)
@sundogplanets yes, well, not every interview can be about quirks. Some have to be about quarks, and that is OK.

@sundogplanets

It's an interview about the night sky and stars, I'm sure there's a bright spot in there somewhere 😉

@sundogplanets I've got a project like that and a potential co-author's response was that we needed to think of something to offer that went beyond just sadness
@sundogplanets I can imagine how difficult this will be for you, but I am so pleased that it is *you* talking about this on Q&Q and not Reflect Orbital.
@sundogplanets maybe you can use the impending disaster(s) to encourage people to call their govts?

@sundogplanets @mayintoronto perhaps … something constructive people can do is make others aware of the night sky?

What is a generative question folks could ask to start people thinking?
Just an idea.

Disclaimer: I am a professional asker of questions. It's an occupational hazard 😁.

@sundogplanets @mayintoronto you'll be great! And it's McDonald's job to make you great :-)
@sundogplanets more people will be aware of the issues and that’s good!

@sundogplanets "I hope this email finds you appropriately jealous. Please see the below humble-brag for more details."

But seriously congrats on this prestigious award!

@sundogplanets In almost a year you could potentially top the pretention it with,
"I'd love to, but since it's Nobel week, I'd probably better stay close to the phone"

@sundogplanets

Congrats on the upcoming interview! ❤️ Please let us know when the air date is so we don't miss it! 🙂

@sundogplanets

The response should be, "OMG, YOU'RE DOING *WHAT*?!?!?"

@sundogplanets
It speaks highly of your character that this is your most pretentious email

@sundogplanets

Congratulations! 👏
We are big Bob McDonald fans in this house..

#quirksandquarks #cbc

@sundogplanets I would have done the exact same thing. Congrats!

@sundogplanets

That's an appropriate thing to humblebrag about, so I wouldn't view that as pretentious at all!