In case you needed a playbook for responding to would-be dictators. From the NYT:

"The funny thing is that there’s a playbook for overturning autocrats. It was written here in America, by a rumpled political scientist I knew named Gene Sharp. While little known in the United States before his death in 2018, he was celebrated abroad, and his tool kit was used by activists in Eastern Europe, in the Middle East and across Asia. His books, emphasizing nonviolent protests that become contagious, have been translated into at least 34 languages."

“I would rather have this book than the nuclear bomb,” a former Lithuanian defense minister once said of Sharp’s writing."

"A soft-spoken scholar working from his Boston apartment, Sharp recommended 198 actions that were often performative, ranging from hunger strikes to sex boycotts to mock funerals."

“Dictators are never as strong as they tell you they are,” he once said, “and people are never as weak as they think they are.”

"The Democrats’ message last year revolved in part around earnest appeals to democratic values, but one of the lessons from anti-authoritarian movements around the world is that such abstract arguments aren’t terribly effective. Rather, three other approaches, drawing on Sharp’s work, seem to work better."

"The first is mockery and humor — preferably salacious."

"Wang Dan, a leader of China’s 1989 Tiananmen Square democracy demonstrations, told me that in China, puns often “resonate more than solemn political slogans.”

"The Chinese internet for a time delighted in grass-mud horses — which may puzzle future zoologists exploring Chinese archives, for there is no such animal. It’s all a bawdy joke: In Chinese, “grass-mud horse” sounds very much like a curse, one so vulgar it would make your screen blush. But on its face it is an innocent homonym about an animal and thus is used to mock China’s censors."

"Shops in China peddled dolls of grass-mud horses (resembling alpacas), and a faux nature documentary described their habits. One Chinese song recounted the epic conflict between grass-mud horses and river crabs — because “river crab” is a play on the Chinese term for censorship. It optimistically declared the horses triumphant."

http://nytimes.com/2025/05/21/opinion/authoritarianism-democracy-protest.html

Opinion | ‘Dictators Are Never as Strong as They Tell You They Are’

Dissidents around the world have plenty of experience challenging authoritarian regimes. Here are their secrets.

The New York Times
@briankrebs can you share a gift link?
Opinion | ‘Dictators Are Never as Strong as They Tell You They Are’

Dissidents around the world have plenty of experience challenging authoritarian regimes. Here are their secrets.

The New York Times
@BillySmith @BPariseau @briankrebs By sharing this in my favourite, us-based discord, I encountered the perfect metaphor.

@BPariseau @briankrebs
Sharp's 198 methods
https://nvdatabase.swarthmore.edu/browse-methods

I once asked Gene Sharp about the way swadeshi was dropped from political nonviolence since the death of Gandhi & it's profound function in Gandhian or nonviolent economics. He didn't have much to say about the topic.

Notes on my readings on this topic are available through http://hubeventsnotes.blogspot.com/2014/04/sarvodaya-swaraj-and-swadeshi.html

Browse Methods | Global Nonviolent Action Database

@briankrebs

on the humor and mockery point:

"Why Nazis are so afraid of these clowns

Clowns have an impressive track record of subverting Nazi ideology, de-escalating rallies and bringing communities together in creative resistance."

https://wagingnonviolence.org/2017/08/nazis-afraid-clowns/

Why Nazis are so afraid of these clowns

Clowns have an impressive track record of subverting Nazi ideology, de-escalating rallies and bringing communities together in creative resistance.

Waging Nonviolence

@joriki @briankrebs Court jesters are one of the most powerful individuals before royalty and nobility assuming they are cunning enough not to get fired or beheaded.

They can slowly influence public opinion and turn it against the ruling family

@briankrebs I prefer to use the CIA playbook on destabilizing governments and toppling them. The manual is very detailed
Simple Sabotage Field Manual

@algaeman I've read through this a few times, and while the general principles remain sound and are still useful, much of the detailed advice is out of date, or not as useful as it was at the time. (Trains no longer use journal boxes, for example.) A big one is that it's from a time before modern surveillance: Many of these suggestions are much harder to get away with now. The social principles later in the book are timeless, though, because people don't change.

@workmagic @briankrebs

No offense, but you probably haven't read Gene Sharp's work. The CIA manual is some random list of pranks, more or less, that you pull on the establishment, but has nothing to do with a strategic framework.

@briankrebs Apparently NYT has no appreciation of irony given their role in bringing Biden down and sanewashing Trump. Fuck them
@lawyersgunsnmoney I think maybe it's okay to take the good with the bad, given the alternatives.
@briankrebs I’m familiar with Sharp and the OSS guide - don’t need them for a goddam thing. NYT WaPo are dead to me. They trot out a marginally useful piece of information along with a torrent of misinformation, propaganda and dreck just try to maintain relevancy. People are on to Sulzberger and Kahn’s scam. I hope Pam Bondi and Ka$h lock their asses up and ship them both to El Salvador. Fucking Quislings both of them
@lawyersgunsnmoney Okay. I understand your position. But please don't throw the baby out with the bathwater. It's foolhardy to expect the media to disrupt everything and then get upset at them not being able to pull that off. IMHO, a lot of protest energy is wasted on stuff that has zero impact. Lampooning and ridiculing this president resonates, if not with POTUS then with protesters.
@briankrebs To be clear, I’m not rejecting commercial news organizations - that would be throwing the baby. NYT and WaPo, CNN, NBC (remember MSNBC hiring Ronna McDaniel) CBS, are all fucking *collaborators* that put a Fasicst in charge. They are the *same* as Dudek the inside shill for doge at SSA. They are fucking Quislings that sold us all out. They are the bath water and I’m not drinking it. If you can’t see it, that’s on you but people here do.

@lawyersgunsnmoney @briankrebs

Kristof is one of the good ones. Surprised he's still there really

@lawyersgunsnmoney @briankrebs

Ah, kids these days, who think this is new.

From "Fools for Scandal", the way the NYT harped and harped and harped upon Whitewater, which turned out to be a nothing, to the way they piled on Al Gore, the way they took all of Bush's claims against Iraq seriously. (How could they miss the Al Qaeda was Saddam's bitter enemy that wanted to depose him? He was going to give THEM a nuclear bomb??)

It's a permanent fixture of their reporting.

https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2007/10/gore200710

Going After Gore

Al Gore couldn't believe his eyes: as the 2000 election heated up, The New York Times, The Washington Post, and other top news outlets kept going after him.

Vanity Fair
@RoyBrander @briankrebs Indeed. I remember all of that.
@briankrebs for people in the Twin Cities, the Hennepin County Library has multiple copies of several of his books.
@briankrebs It would be nice if said book came in any other format than Kindle. 😠

@klausfiend @briankrebs https://books2read.com/u/492ZYw for his most recent, several alternatives exist.

Books2read.com is nice; put in an ebook link and get a link back that lists all the major ebook sellers for that edition

Available now at your favorite digital store!

From Dictatorship to Democracy: A Conceptual Framework for Liberation by Gene Sharp, Gene Sharp

From Dictatorship to Democracy - Wikisource, the free online library

@briankrebs Trjumo and his regime live on lies, whereby other people die. The lies must be disarmed.

@briankrebs 💯

This is great. The maga crowd doesn't respond to facts and logic. They're being manipulated using shame and fear, just like any other cult followers. That's why it's more effective to make them feel ashamed to be a part of that movement, and/or to give them another movement they can join (ours) where they don't have to be ashamed.

@briankrebs Yea, and if there's anyone who knows how to respond to fascists, it's the NYTimes.
@briankrebs Almost-offtopic song stuck in my head: Tim Minchin – Three Minute Song
"And I won't make fun of the Chinese / fo' China is a *Country*, that can bring us to our knees…"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=58mE7Vy1Xrc
Tim Minchin's "Three Minute Song" - Ruth Jones' Easter Treat - BBC

YouTube
@briankrebs Mockery, you say? I'm on that. I call everyone appointed or brought on as "meritocracy hires". Only the best and brightest!
@briankrebs "That's part of our policy, is not to be taken seriously, because I think our opposition, whoever they may be, in all their manifest forms, don't know how to handle humor. You know, and we are humorous, we are, what are they, Laurel and Hardy. That's John and Yoko, and we stand a better chance under that guise, because all the serious people, like Martin Luther King, and Kennedy, and Gandhi, got shot." - John Lennon
@briankrebs My dad once told me that Hitler was more afraid of Chaplin than he was of Churchill.
@briankrebs like this design for a tshirt?
@sven I don't see why T-shirts with this emblem should fail to sell at any infosec/nerd conference.
@sven @briankrebs hey @jerry, you adding other modeling to the OnlyFeet hustle?
@fencepost @sven @briankrebs the bills keep coming but the paychecks aren’t… so I’m game
@briankrebs Humor was working for the Harris/Walz campaign until the assassination attempt. That event, which could not have been staged or timed better, made the target appear both sympathetic (stopped the laughter) and strong.
@briankrebs I'm minded of how a character responded to the accusation that they were threatening someone: "Threats are for people who don't intend to make good on them.". When the fascists make threats, it's because they really don't want to make good on them because they know what'll happen if they do. If they really had the power to do what they threaten without blowback, they'd skip the threats and get right to carrying them out.

@tknarr @briankrebs

Oh this is good:
‘ "Threats are for people who don't intend to make good on them.". When the fascists make threats, it's because they really don't want to make good on them because they know what'll happen if they do. If they really had the power to do what they threaten without blowback, they'd skip the threats and get right to carrying them out.’

We (speaking for myself here!) really need to understand way better the nature of power & how it works, & how we can use it better, much better. 😐

@briankrebs Let the mockery and humor begin! Or continue, as the case may be. Increase. Yeah!

@briankrebs

NYT still has no credibility left.

@briankrebs

See also

198 Methods of nonviolent action, Albert Einstein Institution, https://www.aeinstein.org/198-methods-of-nonviolent-action; and

The Politics of Nonviolent Action (three volumes, 1973) by Dr. Gene Sharp, overview at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Politics_of_Nonviolent_Action; and

How Nonviolent Struggle Works (2013) by Gene Sharp and Jaime Bernal (a condensed version).

198 Methods of Nonviolent Action — AEI/ Empowering Humankind

AEI/ Empowering Humankind
@briankrebs only the extremely weak tell you how very strong they are.
@PetterOfCats @briankrebs Just as only doddering idiots tell you they are very stable geniuses.

@PetterOfCats @briankrebs

So true, what PetterOfCats says: “only the extremely weak tell you how very strong they are.”

🙂

@briankrebs

Here’s an archive link past the paywall: https://archive.ph/zELFj

@briankrebs I remember that Mussolini was regarded as a saint, but it all ended with italians just hanging him and throwing his body like a bag of trash that he was. What people need are the consolidation

@briankrebs

This resonates like the big bells in the cathedral!: “Dictators are never as strong as they tell you they are,” he once said, “and people are never as weak as they think they are.” —Gene Sharp

Thank you so much for sharing this! 🙂

@briankrebs 'a vulgar word that would make your screen blush', man if they clutch those pearls any tighter they might make diamonds. Grass mud horse = 肏你媽,fuck your mother. Scaaaary stuff.

Getting so flustered over a 13 year old internet meme, this writing is embarrassing to read. Are they writing for a church social newsletter? Sometimes I wonder if Americans really are this small-c conservative.

@briankrebs

If the wave is big enough, nothing can stop it.

Just ask the French, or perhaps recall the collapse of the Berlin wall, where the armed soldiers just stood and watched, as the 'wave' walked past.

@briankrebs the book is "From Dictatorship to Democracy : A Conceptual Framework for Liberation"

Find it where ever you... find your books

@codebyjeff Thanks! I just bought the book.
@briankrebs Im’ not afraid of dictators. I’m afraid of the brainless and spineless morons following him and I’m afraid of the opportunists making money when they support „their“ dictator.
@briankrebs I would love to write a manual "How to topple a dictatorship" without writing a manual "How to destroy a democracy". The line in between is probably thinner than most people believe.
@masek @briankrebs the problem with democracy is that people want to vote for an outcome, but they have to vote for policies. We don’t know if a policy will achieve the desired outcome, and no politician is held accountable for whether a policy actually achieves what people wanted. Example is that people want shorter waiting lists on the NHS. A policy is implemented to limit immigration to reduce load on the health system, but this causes a staff shortage due to lower immigration.