Debate over an article etc, all you said makes perfect sense. I think the guy is being frustrated about people who provide TikTok videos because it’s also the only source they used, inheriting all the video’s unavoidable simplifications.
There’s another aspect to it - when given a link to an article, it takes me maybe 30 seconds to scan and initially assess its quality (scientific vs popular, sources, references, consistency). When given a 15-60 min long video on YT you are forced to sample it sequentially to see what they’re talking about, and in most cases it’s waste of time.
"Send me the article"
The article:
*"Give us your email and sign up for our news letter! :)"*
*"To read this article, you need to buy a premium subscription!! :))"*
*"Sign up for an account to see more of our drivle!!! :)))*
A social media screen grab from somewhere. A white douchebro called lloydrang opines:
"I'm GenX. We grew up in an all-print world. We read really fast.
"So, my Millenial and GenZ peeps, I beg you for the love of Bananarama, please just send me the article and not the TikTok of the dude talking about the article.
"In Prince's funky name, amen."
At the time the screen was grabbed, this fatuous gobbet of opinion had 12.1K likes, 624 replies, 855 reposts and 302 shares.
@mrundkvist So true. If there's a transcript, I don't bother watching a slow time-wasting video. (Apologies to #TEDtalk people.)
Another advantage of text is that you can scan back to check something.
@mrundkvist
Actual Alt Text without unneeded vitriol:
Tweet by "lloydrang":
"I'm GenX. We grew up in an all-print world. We read
really fast.
So, my Millennial and GenZ peeps, | beg you for the love
of Bananarama, please just send me the article and not
the TikTok of the dude talking about the article.
In Prince's funky name, amen."
@mrundkvist I'm an elder millenial. I read crazy fast and prefer text.
My partner is genx. She's dyslexic, so she often prefers video content.
I've had coworkers who are gen z hating on video. I've got old relatives who love the new world.
From where I'm sitting, it doesn't feel as generational. I get younger folks are growing up on video a lot more, but I'll bet the ratio isn't that different.
@mrundkvist And younger generations are very used to accomodating people with reading difficulties. They almost never assume you're fluent in reading.
We would just shove them on the "short bus" and pretend they didn't exist.
@mrundkvist so while it might be a bit of an ego boost that we have all of these "old people superpowers" younger generations are superior to us in a hell of a lot of ways.
We were angry, neglected assholes.
@mrundkvist Yes, I get the "snark."
The issue is not really generational, but different learning styles. Many (most) people absorb information through audio/visual means (videos, podcasts, etc.), while others do better with written info.
I prefer text, not just because I read quickly (I do), but I do not remember audio or visual input as well as written input. Lecture "at" me, and without my written notes, I would lose most of what is being presented. I find chatty videos boring and/or annoying; "just cut to the chase, quit blathering... bored now."
This. Nearly EVERYONE can read faster than they can view or listen. And with reading, you can skim to find the bit you're actually looking for.
For conveying information*, written text beats every other method hands down. Has done since literacy was invented a few millennia ago. Still does. Always will.
*Communication can be about conveying mood, emotion etc. Information isn't always the primary aim. But when information is the aim, just use text goddammit.
Not Text; Didn’t Read
Also we need the help of ALL GEN X, Y AND Z, Latino, Black, White, Japanese, Orient, Chinese, Europeans, Middle Eastern, Africans all legal immigrants to help save Democracy and Freedoms
AND VOTE BLUE IN 2024.
RID US ALL OF THE STENCH OF TRUMPISM AND MAGA.
@mrundkvist I'm not sure if it's because it was framed as a generational thing, or because it called out a popular social media platform, but it's just amazing how many people this simple concept has apparently offended.
I definitely process text much faster than audio (or video), and can focus on it more easily, so being directed to a video for a thing is immensely frustrating. I was born in the 80s, so possibly this does relate to age? I'd never really considered it, but it's possible
I do read faster than other people talk. I do read faster than I can process other people's words.
Just lemme read the article. <3