When you live in a country, where the dictator can never be wrong, the only ones left to blame are the citizens.

So now that Putin has killed so many young men, that birth rates are dropping catastrophically, Russian Deputy Minister of Justice Vsevolod Vukolov reports, that new laws will make it illegal for women not to have children.

Do try to keep up, Republicans — you are so much behind the forefront of the dystopian nightmare.

@randahl this dude is a horrifying disgrace and guarantee he hasn't seen a diaper in a long ass time
@randahl Romania under Ceauşescu tried to increase the birth rate in the 1980s by banning contraception. The result was overcrowded orphanages and a lot of kids born with Aids.

@simonwilliamson @randahl

You forgot their getting money by putting those kids up for adoption to Westerners. Orphans were a cash crop. I had friends that adopted 2 of those orphans. Those poor kids had real psychological issues that no one could ever fix. The Ceuacescus got what they deserved.

@randahl To be precise, he doesn’t want to “make it illegal for women not to have children” but ban the “child-free ideology”, which is something really only exists in Russia and mostly in conservative narratives, rather than being a real social phenomenon. They invented an ideology so that they could blame it of declining birth rates and avoid blaming the real causes (e.g. Putin), and then ban it. It doesn’t change anything but it gives the society an impression that “the government is making radical steps”.

@kravietz @randahl I think they also want yet another lever to use against people who speak too much.

They already have quite a variety and one thing they all have in common - their definitions are broad and murky. E.g. "discrediting Russian Armed Forces" can (and is) applied to anything from anti war stance to discussing casualties or equipment problems. "Propaganda of non-traditional sexual relations" isn't just about LGBT but anything sexual or gender related if it is tiniest bit unorthodox.

And in public discussions about demography, social services, school education, expensive housing, whatever people quite often say things like "I don't want to have [more] children in these conditions" and it resonates with many.

I guess the government would prefer people being quiet about this too.

@shuro @kravietz @randahl

OT:

#ClimateChange is one factor for people in western countries to
>> say things like "I don't want to have [more] children in these conditions" and it resonates with many. <<

We should voice this and speak about it more often.

>> I guess the government would prefer people being quiet about this too. <<

(sorry for hijacking this)

@kravietz @randahl
In a way, they are mimicking what they decided against the so-called "LGBT-ideology": officially banning any kind of "advertisement" for it, but in fact ostracising and discriminating against those people for no other reason than the fact that they are homosexual, or even now that they are not parents.

@mariedocet

They did, but it was also very typical for Russian system - the “LGBT ideology” ban resulted in show repressions, show arrests at gay bars… but then you realised that actually all these gay bars were fully operational in the first place, and there were plenty of them in big towns. So the ban was just another selective quasi-legal tool for repressions against some, specifically because it can be applied selectively. And, of course, it did change literally nothing in terms of demography :)

@randahl

@kravietz
Indeed.
That's the first step.
In the long run, the outcome might be "Lebensborn"-like organisations... unless it already exists and we haven't heard about it yet😢
If so... poor kids😭
@kravietz @randahl I don't buy it. They made homosexuality illegal and punished it severely in an attempt to boost births. That you think they wouldn't dare to go that far is to ignore history.

@afilina

Russia has legal duality - the law on paper is one thing, the actual rules are another. Legally, homosexuality itself isn’t illegal but it’s illegal to “promote non-traditional sexual values”. But the law doesn’t matter because when they need, they arrest (as they did in clubs in Moscow) or even kill people for being homosexual (as they did in Chechnya). So we know 1) the formal law doesn’t really mean much, 2) when they want something, they just do it.

But with childlessness it’s a different because it’s about forcing women to do something rather than preventing them. One tool is propaganda, but few women are ready to get pregnant merely for the glory of Putin, so I suspect their methods will be based more on financial pressure - right now a soldier’s wife can get quite rich (in Russian terms), so they may for example add a bonus for soldier’s families where the woman is pregnant.

And I’m not in any way justifying Moscow or claiming they’re moving in the right direction, but it’s important to understand the mechanics of their state correctly because only then we can understand why they do what they do. For example, no sane person would join Russian army so we assumed they won’t be able to mobilise enough soldiers in 2022-2023… unless we saw that they recruit people who were for decades living at $100 per month and now are being offered $10k bonus.

@randahl

@kravietz @randahl This is very well explained, thank you. I'll think about all this.
@randahl So is it illegal to be barren?
The handmaid's tale is not hyperbole.
@randahl What's in that bottle and what's it called again?
@randahl Signed into law or not, unconsentual is grounds for self defense. The 🤬 goes on in these people's vacant heads?
@randahl Relax, it's Tbau mineral water. He just talks like a drunk all the time.
@davoloid @randahl It's a mineral water bottle. But I wouldn't assume that's what it contains.
@randahl Not a coincidence that so much dystopian fiction begins with a decline in birth rates.

@randahl

Even Aunt Lydia didn't see this one coming. Praise Be and Under His Eye to all citizens and Handmaids.

@randahl
Some 10 or even 15 years ago, I knew a (French) kid who had been adopted in Russia around 2005-2008 or so...
I can't help but think how lucky she has been, not remaining in Russia and therefore not living now the life of a 20 y.o. Russian.
Now her adoption by a western family would be impossible, and I think of today's russian-born orphans who might have had a rather normal future and upbringing in some european country but won't because they won't be adopted by european parents😢 .
@randahl so crazy. Do better Democrats and America. Where we're heading.
@randahl Illogical. Putin alone is responsible for his actions; no one else.
@randahl Yup. America is pretty much Russia Lite already.
@randahl ..
SO NOW TEENAGERS WILL BE CONCUBINES ???

@randahl .. very interesting fact is that IT'S an ILLEGAL practice had returned to CHINA about HAVING CONCUBINES ... HIDDEN secrets POLYGAMY

WE call them SUGAR BABIES in many other places women who have SUGAR DADDIES..

THE WOMAN approached by a male confidant of the person doing the proposal & their job is to secure the deal for the man...

Set up apartment & can even involve friends of the female where even husband's can be chosen for the female eventually after so much time ...

@randahl ONLY THING Russia has NO intention of having sugar daddies .. only perverted men having access to any female to give birth to babies ... Russian females or ANY female will NOT BE SAFE IN RUSSIA...
@randahl They're not *that* far behind though - let's not give them credit where none is due.

@randahl

Part of me wants to be snarky and say "and how are you going to enforce women having children", and then realized with horror Margaret Atwood already gave us an answer to that.

@chu exactly. Under his eye!
@randahl @Krosen_nw eeeeeeeeeesh. Roe v Wade overturn is a wake-up call. I don’t even know what to call this.

@ofa_Jeremy @randahl @Krosen_nw It's called Gilead. Coming very soon to a red state near you, since our Republicans get their marching orders from these guys.

There is a reason the GOP platform committee meets in secret.

#GroupiesOfPutin

@randahl
Gotta keep those rabbits breeding.
@randahl The “deputy minister of justice” looks like a ghoul. Russia has won the race to the bottom.

@randahl

Russia, America, Israel, France...#fascism is everywhere. There is no forefront once you fall in craziness. Just a bad trip to the black hole the silly guys are leading you to.

@randahl 😳 *crossing my legs uncomfortably...
@randahl in late communist Bulgaria we actually had a special tax for childless people. If I'm not wrong a fixed amount about 5-10% of the average salary. One of the first things to be removed when the regime fell.
@randahl @spas_kolev Every now and then they talk about this in Russia but so far it always dissipates. Probing the water I guess but it isn't popular idea.
@randahl @nazgul We saw how well that went in 80s/90s Romania.