I'm enjoying mastodon so far but wow, all the comments about how white it is are extremely right. Almost all the other trans folks I've found have been white, and I know that isn't representative of the real world or even likely mastodon as a whole. I'd love to hear more from trans and queer POC (and POC all up, I've just been connecting with a LOT of trans folks).

Can anyone boost this to help me find more voices to listen to? Or recommend some hashtags? I don't even know how best to tag this.

@inherentlee I'm not sure on mastodon as a whole; really haven't found many people of colour yet who i didn't follow on twitter.
@oluoluolu that's been my experience too. And it has seemed like moving off of Twitter is especially hard for people who are more dependent on followers for support... Like folks in a lot of marginalized groups :/
@oluoluolu I just didn't want to discount all of mastodon due to being in a white bubble if that makes sense

@inherentlee yeah it defs does!

I'm sure there are clusters, I tried to find a few when i originally joined so hopefully they have grown and not left

@oluoluolu I hope so! & if you have any favorite folks you follow I would love recs!
*nod*, it's not so easy to identify other marginalized people to form stronger bonds if broadcasting their identity can make them targets. ISTM it would make sense for groups formed elsewhere to organize their own instances in the fediverse: a local timeline can be a useful resource to find people who face similar challenges, and moderation resources can focus on their struggles, maintaining a safe space and fostering bonds between similar-minded communities. there are horrible stories of people who ended up in communities that made room for hate speech, or didn't react quick enough, and caused a very bad impression to newcomers. instances like bantu.social, devoted to portuguese-speaking poc, are not without issues (as in, I've read about their being targeted), but they manage to buffer some of it and offer people a better initial experience, enabling people to find a community, a support group in the fediverse, or even bring their community from elsewhere, which can be quite useful to get acquainted with the tooling and resources available to manage contacts, timelines, and tune the experience to one's needs and preferences. I'd love to see this sort of community replicated for other languages and other social justice causes.
cc: @@jalcine @@timnitGebru @@dobrado @@alnmtt
*nod*, it's not so easy to identify other marginalized people to form stronger bonds if broadcasting their identity can make them targets. ISTM it would make sense for groups formed elsewhere to organize their own instances in the fediverse: a local timeline can be a useful resource to find people who face similar challenges, and moderation resources can focus on their struggles, maintaining a safe space and fostering bonds between similar-minded communities. there are horrible stories of people who ended up in communities that made room for hate speech, or didn't react quick enough, and caused a very bad impression to newcomers. instances like bantu.social, devoted to portuguese-speaking poc, are not without issues (as in, I've read about their being targeted), but they manage to buffer some of it and offer people a better initial experience, enabling people to find a community, a support group in the fediverse, or even bring their community from elsewhere, which can be quite useful to get acquainted with the tooling and resources available to manage contacts, timelines, and tune the experience to one's needs and preferences. I'd love to see this sort of community replicated for other languages and other social justice causes.
cc: @@jalcine @@timnitGebru @@dobrado @@alnmtt

@oluoluolu @inherentlee

I've found some black nerds who have been hiding here for years and I didn't know about them.

@futurebird

I agree. I found many #BlackNerds on #Mastodon . That said, I don't have any issue if #Mastodon #diversity increases

@oluoluolu @inherentlee

@futurebird @oluoluolu @inherentlee

I agree. I found many #BlackNerds on #Mastodon. Increasing #diversity on #Mastodon is ALWAYS good! 😊

@inherentlee I’ve had some luck finding more diverse voices looking through #blackmastodon but not sure how to locate other demographics or PoC creators…
@mariyadelano it's a start at least, thank you!
@mariyadelano @inherentlee
I have an always-being-updated list of hashtags and some might be what you are looking for.
https://toot.cat/@kevix/109464322357861173
Kevix (he/him) :debian: (@[email protected])

Content warning: a log list of hashtags

Toot.Cat
@inherentlee If you want to find more Black Folks on here, use the hashtags #BlackMastodon and #BlackFedi! 😊😊😊😊😊
@AshBeardguy thank you! Following!

@inherentlee

#Follow those Hashtags too!

@AshBeardguy oh that's what I meant!
@inherentlee @AshBeardguy
I not only followed the hastags, I followed everyone who posted with those hashtags. My feed is awesome!

@AshBeardguy @inherentlee

Yes! #HashTags are a great way to find people and posts. This is why it is important for you to use #HashTags in your posts and replies.

@inherentlee I hadn’t noticed. The feeds I follow (quite a lot of academics) are heavily European. I’d say half of the accounts I’ve seen are white. And there’s an entire group for BIPOC LGTBQ+ and supporters but I can’t remember the name off the top of my head. First week of Fall Quarter and I’ve still got one course unpublished in Canvas still.
@schoolingdiana if you remember that group name lmk!
@inherentlee I came across @AlyAlyOutnFree recently who had a thread sharing lovely introductions from trans folks!
@DrVeronikaCH @AlyAlyOutnFree yes, I was on that thread as well - I've been connecting with lots of other trans folks on here but the balance tilts extremely white.
@inherentlee @AlyAlyOutnFree sorry, I've heard this from more people on here 😔 Some hashtags I've seen are #BlackMastotodon #BlackFedi #BlackInSTEM

@inherentlee @DrVeronikaCH ah. Ok.

Well…..let’s change that.

@inherentlee I have to agree. I havent been able to tell if it is to do with the sector of the Fediverse that enters my timeline.... or if maybe Im not looking at the #BlackTwitter #BlackAcademics #BIPOC type hashtags enough.

I do think that one problem with so many people coming here from Twitter is....we tend to bring some of the bad habits (from birbsite) with us. That platform def felt "very white"

@Catwoman69y2k for sure, there is a lot of civility over content and other shit behavior.

I need to remember to follow more hashtags. That's still not default behavior for me 😅

@inherentlee to be fair, it isn't for a lot of people. Even when there was some visibility in the problem of birbsite's shadowbanning and algorithm tweaking, lots of people were not able to see the full power of hashtags.

People may still be used to Birbsite's search engine which allowed you to search for phrases and words

@Catwoman69y2k tbh, I guess I'm in a minority there - I never really used hashtags on birdsite either, or the search. I tend towards following individual people and using their conversations to find new interesting people to follow.
@inherentlee Could try looking at tech.lgbt's server, see if you can find anyone on there?

@inherentlee hey, Lee! We do a #transappreciationfriday thread every week where anyone who’s trans/non-binary is encouraged to join in.

I know I really try to use visibility to connect ALL people in our community, especially BIPOC, to find one another, connect and interact. Also, if you have more tips or suggestions as to how I can be more inclusive, please let me know. I’m open to learn. 💜

@AlyAlyOutnFree yup, I replied to that yesterday. I'll let you know if I have or hear suggestions, but I'm white so I'm still very much learning too.

@AlyAlyOutnFree I am wondering if you thought about the fact that you replied to a post about someone seeing mostly only white trans people here with a hashtag full of almost only white trans people.

I know you say you want to learn but maybe start by thinking about why your trans community might be so white. A lot of trans community can be very focused on particular experiences that do not apply to everyone. For example, it may be even more unsafe for Black and brown trans people to be out in their daily lives, to use accounts that are not pseudonyms.

Is your default understanding of transness a white one? A lot of times white trans people end up being the most visible, to where white trans people don't even question why we mostly only see other white trans people.

And no the answer isn't to go find a few non-white people to pull into our white trans spaces, it's to deconstruct the whiteness of those spaces and to challenge the norms that place whiteness as the default

@RadiantEmber first- thank you for reaching out. I appreciate the response.

I reached out and mentioned the hashtag for a couple of different reasons:

1. I don’t own ‘the trans experience’ for everyone, nor do I represent it, but I’ve been doing TAF for almost two years now, though just recently on this platform, and I share it with as many people as I can so that it includes as many people as want to include themselves in it. That absolutely has to include black trans people.

@RadiantEmber 2. I am white and privileged. I will never know the experience of being black and/or trans, what that feels like, or how it changes the experience of being trans as a whole for black trans people.

I offered the hashtag bc it was mentioned by a follower to them, so I felt an open door to expand on what it’s about and how we’re trying to build upon it.

I’m lucky enough to have the chance to listen and learn. Thanks again for the feedback.

@AlyAlyOutnFree ah that does make sense and I can see why spreading the hashtag might help more people to hear about it, especially as it was mentioned already.

One of the big problems I have noticed is that as white people we often try to invite non-white people into our white spaces to make them more diverse. Rather than creating spaces with them, or joining spaces that they have invited us into, or even just supporting them in creating their own spaces.

The problem is that white spaces don't cease to be white spaces just because there are a few people in them who are not white. We've got to work on deconstructing the whiteness of those spaces at the root

@AlyAlyOutnFree ah I've thought of a practical application for this. There are Black trans people who are already on here creating hashtags used by lots of trans people! That's not to say that yours can't be used alongside theirs but you might want to look for example at tags like #FineFemmeFriday and get to know the Black and Brown trans folks that have already been creating communities here.

I hesitate to recommend to follow this person or that person because there is a real risk of treating people more as a resource than real people, and it's not necessarily helpful to Black and Brown trans folks to just have a bunch of white people following them

@AlyAlyOutnFree it is also a bit unfortunate but it seems like you aren't aware that Friday is widely used on Mastodon for BlackMastodon history and appreciation. Is it possible for you to consider moving trans appreciation to another day? I know you bring it here from previous work outside of Mastodon but it would help not to be obscuring that work with yours.

Fwiw, I'm trans and non-Black poc. And it seems a bit unintentionally rude.

@perigee hey there! Thanks so much for the feedback. Are you aware of any other conflicting issues if I were to move the day to Saturday here on Mastodon?
@AlyAlyOutnFree I haven't bee. Around super long. What I would suggest is asking around and doing your own searches. I think I saw a trans person talking about trans awareness thursdays last week. You can also search hashtags to get a sense of what days people reserve for what purposes. BlackFriday has just been something I've observed Black users and historians use Fridays for.
@inherentlee trans woman of colour here. hi.
@intentionaut I follow you! Found you through hachyderm 🥰
@inherentlee right. hiiii 😅
@intentionaut hi, good to more officially meet you!

@inherentlee

"I'm enjoying mastodon so far but wow, all the comments about how white it is are extremely right. "

But that's not Mastodon's fault - nobody gets stopped at the door...

@keithreeder didn't say it was. Not what I'm asking.

@inherentlee

But it's - verbatim - what you *said*.

I'm just saying that if there's a problem *on* a problem, that doesn't mean it's a problem *with* the platform.

@keithreeder I didn't apply blame anywhere and am not interested in having that conversation with you.
@inherentlee Lee you're white. You need to use hashtags.
@Fayedray I know I'm white, and clearly I know hashtags are useful given that I ask about them.

@inherentlee collecting people based on ethnicity is creepy when white people do it. Just imho.

I hope you figure out how to make genuine connections with people tho. Good luck! This guy above is a #newbie.

@Fayedray I'm trying to see a more accurate representation of transness around me. White transness can be pretty fucken harmful if we're inundated by it and not challenged about it, and I want to learn and grow.

@inherentlee @Fayedray Lee, in my short experience on here, I've realized that you may realize that there are many people here who will tell you exactly how and what to do on here, often using the (flawed and self-excusing) reasoning of good intent (rather than actual effect) to attempt to police your words and actions.

Follow people and interests (hashtags) as you choose, the caveat being *how* you interact, not with who or what you interact, is often most important.

@arden @inherentlee thanks friend! Yes, hi, hello! I be a First Nations (Wiradjuri) Trans guy who’s also legally blind. Trans, queer, disabled Blackfulla over here 🤗
@inherentlee I'm not the person you want to hear from, but #BIPOC and #BlackMastodon have worked for me, in finding BIPOC folks I used to follow on Twitter who have migrated here.
@inherentlee Hi @Lee!! Blqck Non-binary enby here.
@jamfish @Lee omg I followed you on Twitter iirc!! Good to see you here!