@mattnolan Good points… still, when rats do foraging in 2D, they can have very nice grid cells, but as soon as they move on to 3D, still foraging, the grids break down… 🤔
Roddy (from Grieves et al 2021 says that he’s not aware of any continuous attractor model of grid cells that has been extended to 3D but there should be 2 options: 1) either the grids can integrate movements in the z-axis and that should give rise to columns in 3D, or 2) they can’t and the grid should completely break down in 3D. However, the data showed mostly randomly-located spatial fields that were more spatially-stable than chance, so neither of those 🤔 (similar findings by Ginosar et al., 2021 but for MEC cells that were not necessarily grid cells). But maybe there are now more recent CAN models that we are not aware of!
This reminds me that Gily has a new review paper on the role of #GridCells for #Navigation that I #Need2Read: Ginosar et al., 2023