I'm thinking there's a fun research project here, if someone hasn't done it already: measure (this is a sticky but fun part) community enthusiasm or buy-in or financial support or something for a variety of extracurricular (or quasi-curricular activities at American high schools. My hypothesis would be that the more the activities embody direct competition, ritualized violence (or the real thing), and interpersonal domination, the greater the support will be, with men's dominance/aggression sports getting far more support than women's. Further, I suspect both of these effects will vary regionally, with parts of the US that have had high violence rates since forever (one explanation is Nisbett & Wilson's #HonorCulture hypothesis), showing the effect more strikingly.

There would be a few factors to control for, as well. I'd need to work with some people who have experience in this to know what those would be.

I would predict that, on average, the ranking of support etc. would be something like

Highest ranking: direct quasi-violent competition sports:

  • Football
  • Hockey/La Crosse
  • Basketball
  • Next: more stylized violence/domination

  • Baseball, I guess?
  • Tennis
  • Next-to-lowest: team competitions without direct confrontations

  • Track & field events with multiple people directly competing at once (e.g., 500m, etc.)
  • Swimming
  • Lowest: Individual competitions, no direct confrotation/competition

  • Track & field events like pole vault javelin, shot put, etc.
  • I'm probably missing tons of stuff, but this is an interesting #research idea

    Honor culture linked to military recruitment and identity formation

    Recent research found that U.S. honor-oriented states have higher military enlistment rates, military personnel strongly embrace honor values, and these values influence their deep connection to military identity and a "warrior mindset."

    PsyPost

    Fascinating article with interactive maps. The article discusses only the most populous regions, but use the maps to check out the figures on the First Nations region. That is so extreme I think he should have said something about it.

    https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2023/04/23/surprising-geography-of-gun-violence-00092413

    #GunViolence #guns #HonorCulture #RedStates

    The Surprising Geography of Gun Violence

    America’s regions are poles apart when it comes to gun deaths and the cultural and ideological forces that drive them.

    POLITICO

    Enormously good twitter thread about russian "dishonor culture". If you've wondered why russia never ever honors deals, or why russian soldiers ignore their own wounded - well, this is why.

    https://twitter.com/Bunnyrabert/status/1600824180194189312

    #Russia #ethnography #honorculture #dishonorculture #prisonculture

    Just a Bunnї on Twitter

    “Several complementary pillars, of the russian phenomenon, continuously recreate the kind of societal dysfunction, that gives us its genocidal tendencies, its intolerance, its corruption, its imperialism and much more. One among them, is that russia has a dishonour culture. 🧵1/”

    Twitter
    Ruminating on Honor, Dignity, Anger, and Process Addiction

    I don't agree with this essay, "Sovereignty at Stake" or particularly think it has all the facts straight. Nonetheless, I think the last p...