@leonoverweel I will need to read through the sources in more detail, but this still leaves me with big concerns.
First off, it seems like Ritchie's main sources are the AI companies themselves. I would like to see some independent information about how they conducted their studies and what might have been left out.
Second, it's all well and good to point to individual usage, but individuals are not using these tools in isolation. And those numbers don't take into account the massive training and background costs involved. The MIT study Ritchie cites, from May of last year, points out that āthe carbon intensity of electricity used by data center was 48% higher than the US average.ā And they project that burden to grow as AI usage does, with a heavy reliance on dirty fuel sources to make that happen.
I know there is some nuance to all this. I'm just frustrated because ever since those individual usage number came out, I keep seeing folks lean on that without addressing the nuance on the other side of the issue.