Wow. Bluesky has just welcomed and verified ICE.

For anyone still thinking Bsky is a real alternative to Twitter: No, it's not.

Mastodon is. Bsky is just X at its infancy.

#ICE #Bsky #Bluesky #fascism

@Grutjes

Yup, just checked, web profile at https://bsky.app/profile/icegov.bsky.social

Verified and everything 😡

Bluesky are collaborators.

U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (@icegov.bsky.social)

Protects America through criminal investigations and by enforcing immigration law to preserve national security and public safety. ➡️Visit us at ICE.gov ➡️Join our team at join.ICE.gov Privacy policy: ICE.gov/privacy

Bluesky Social
@Grutjes
This is why I dumped the bridge. If they're welcoming and verifying accounts from fascists, they're the Nazi bar. I'm not risking anyone here by "federating" with fascists.
@Grutjes perhaps we need to #fediBlock all of BlueSky?
@craige @Grutjes
That certainly has been the go-to method for dealing with servers that platform Nazis.
@Grutjes not sure what this account is tracking, but my understanding of verification on bluesky is that it just uses DNS records to do the verification. I've verified myself on there before as well. It's an automated mechanism if you control your domain.
@Grutjes nevermind I take it back, BlueSky themselves did verify this, and ICE did not use the DNS approach to verify themselves as ice.gov.
@umer @Grutjes thanks for checking and confirming the behaviour

@Grutjes

Very depressing to see the reaction from Bluesky users on their Reddit, they're basically saying it's fine to host ICE as someone who doesn't want to see it can block it from their own feed.

There's no thought being given at all to the violent dangerous hatred the ICE account will spread to those who don't block it, and the consequent radicalisation.

You can't block someone attacking you on the street, and that's what ICE is trying to make happen.

EDIT: If you don't understand what I mean, please read this https://social.chinwag.org/@FediThing/112581263140051643 about why personal blocking is not enough.

FediThing :progress_pride: (@[email protected])

Imagine a stranger spreads lies about you. They tell everyone you're doing horrible stuff, the worst crimes imaginable. They make videos, articles, livestreams, all pushing the same lies designed to make everyone hate and fear you. Would you "just block them"? What happens when other people don't block them? When other people believe them, follow them, share their lies? What if this turns into real life abuse? If someone attacks you or your family? This is what vulnerable minorities face because of badly-moderated social media: https://www.thebureauinvestigates.com/stories/2022-02-20/facebook-accused-of-letting-activists-incite-ethnic-massacres-with-hate-and-misinformation-by-survivors-in-ethiopia/ 🙏 Please defederate threads.net or ask your server admin to do so. #Threads

Chinwag Social
@FediThing @Grutjes Giving them a platform of any kind also gives them power. I get that Bluesky wants to remain neutral here but this is not the time. Neutrality just feeds fascism.

@drearicheli
They SAY they want to stay neutral, but what they really want is fascism, and to be the social media network that gets the nod from the fascists.

@FediThing @Grutjes

@xinit @drearicheli @Grutjes

I think you're both right!

Drea's right about the folly of neutrality in the face of fascism, but also xinit is right that Bluesky are sucking up to a fascist goverment.

Guessing Bluesky just want money and power, they see pleasing fascists as a way to get both.

@Grutjes wow this is sickening 🤯 but also not entirely surprising

@Grutjes

One more time for those in the back...

The dog is working for the man

@Grutjes Mods should all defedera… oh wait, they can’t. They’re all on the same server owned by the same company.🫠
I blocked on open vibe.
@Grutjes * Bluesky has verified USA gestapo
@Grutjes Verifying an account is not the same as endorsing...

@kwarg @Grutjes

Verifying a bunch of murderers is something they didn't have to do.

Hosting the murderers' account is something they didn't have to do.

They chose to do this.

@kwarg

Why don´t you fuck off kwarg

@Grutjes @kwarg
Hang on a sec. Everyone here is against ICE - for obvious and serious reasons. And Bsky have chosen to not block ICE. But Grutjes, the person you responded to just now is a couple of steps removed from serious wrongdoing here. They didn't denounce bsky for failing to denounce ICE. I think it's fair that you disagree with them about that, but I don't think it deserves such blunt hostility.

@karadoc

Sorry, it's this centrist attitude that got us here, and I have no patience for it.

@Grutjes Yeah I can see that. I understand where you are coming from. But this isn't Twitter. We generally talk in good faith. When you attack neutral positions with as much vigor as you attack hostile positions - it ... well, it's bad for a variety of reasons that I think you probably don't need me to explain.
@karadoc @Grutjes "Neutrality" in fascism means supporting fascism...

@Gryficowa No one here is being neutral to towards fascism. All that happened was that someone said "verifying an account is not the same as endorsing", and was attacked for it. It's neutrality towards a 3rd party's neutrality. Right?

And now, all I'm doing here is trying to advocate for kindness, and you - you personally are saying that I'm a problem on the fediverse because of it. Reflect on that.

@karadoc
Neutral positions that are neutral to whether Nazis are in the bar? Those are false neutrality.
@Grutjes
@karadoc @Grutjes @kwarg Oh my god... There actually is a problem with liberals on the fediverse...
@Gryficowa @karadoc @Grutjes I think you all jump too quickly to conclusions... I despise ICE and everything it stands for as much as any of you. I am just saying that I'd prefed to be able to differentiate what is a verified source from an account that might just be a couple of ICE fanboys. I could also be wrong, but we could at the very least have a conversation and discuss about it. I have a different opinion about who's the problem on the fediverse.

@kwarg

I'm sorry, I shouldn't have reacted the way I did.
There are two reasons why I got annoyed by your reaction.
The first reason is that my point is not about verifying. It's about Bsky welcoming ICE even after they verified them, knowing it was really them.

@Gryficowa @karadoc

@kwarg

The second reason is not your fault, so that's why I shouldn't have reacted like that. Sorry I did.

You were one of many people that reacted as though it is no problem that Bsky allows ICE an account.
I think it's quite stupid not to see why allowing them on Bsky is a problem, but you are responsible for your own words and not for dozens of others.

@Gryficowa @karadoc

@kwarg @Grutjes On a plattform that is radically public, where each block is also public to those being blocked and you do not know how algorithms might behave verifying might be endorsing too.

@kwarg @Grutjes No, it literally means that they endorse the presence on the site. They are not only aware that ICE has an account, but they are alright with it continuing to have an account.

If they did not endorse ICE using their platform for white supremacist violence, they would ban them. Just as they've banned hundreds - if not thousands - of Palestinians, trans folk, and leftists already.

@Grutjes
 "Bluesky is for everyone!"
 "Surely you don't mean that…"
 "Bluesky is for everyone!"
@Grutjes they are exclusively following major news outlets and journalists critically covering DHS and immigration.

@weltschvitz

For now.

@Grutjes @weltschvitz Making a list of places to visit, probably.

@Grutjes

Doubtless they have many accounts already monitoring these sources masquerading as civilians. The only reason for an official government account is to start posting responses / propaganda / disinformation.

@in8sworld

Fascists are gonna fascist.
Bluesky is collaborating, that is my point.

@Grutjes didn't even bother joining Bluesky when it first came out because it was invite-only.
@Grutjes I don't think that's really ice lol

@monkey

Maybe you could check something before "thinking" out loud.

@Grutjes idk just my take that's surreal to me they'd make a blue sky account. Seems like a weird place for them.