yo fedi, how are you today?
I'm trying to find the absolute best, well-argumented (!) #LLM takedown blogpost you've read lately.. preferably related to software development.
Unfortunately my boss is on the hype-train (random glory posts in slack) and I'd like to counter him just a wee bit. Bring it on 😁
Boosting appreciated for reach 
Don't believe the hype!
Just gonna drop that the new album is absolutely worth paying for (even tho it's pay what you want) and absolutely worth telling people to go pick up.
@woozong
https://lukasatkinson.de/2025/net-negative-cursor/ was on point enough for me to pass around at work
https://deplet.ing/the-copilot-delusion/ was poignant but usability depends greatly on management personality.
I mostly do the snark. @davidgerard does the real content.
@woozong from here
https://infosec.exchange/@0xabad1dea/114572710857808174
there an article where an LLM gave up managing a vending machine and non-metaphorically compared closing the business with collapsed quantum state 😅
I was amused by this paper about asking AIs to manage a vending machine business by email in a simulated environment https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.15840 Highlights: — AI simply decides to close the business, which the simulation doesn’t know how to accommodate. When they get their next bill, they freak out and try to email the FBI about cybercrime — AI wrongly accuses supplier of not shipping goods, sends all-caps legal threat demanding $30,000 in damages to be paid in the next one second or face annihilation — AI repeatedly insisting it does not exist and cannot answer — AI devolving into writing fanfic about the mess it’s gotten itself into
Does this one help?
https://alonso.network/the-recurring-cycle-of-developer-replacement-hype/
This guy also had great articles, but they're general "AI" rather than software development specifically:
Very ranty and entertaining - I love it :)
AI isn't replacing developers, it's transforming them. Just as NoCode created specialists and cloud turned sysadmins into DevOps engineers, AI elevates engineers from code writers to system architects. The most valuable skill isn't writing code, it's designing coherent systems.
@woozong This one I read recently: https://deplet.ing/the-copilot-delusion/ (I somehow missed that this was already linked in the replies, sorry for the duplicate!)
In addition, I’d also recommend looking into @tante‘s writing on the topic, e.g. this current piece on #vibecoding: https://tante.cc/2025/05/23/on-vibe-coding/
@woozong The best solution to management thinking LLMs can do coding is to do a live demo - ask for the LLM to do something modestly complex, or write some “glue” between two separate programs, and then try to compile or run the code.
It hallucinates magic functions that don’t exist in common libraries, gives you code that won’t compile, or doesn’t understand that you can’t stuff CSV data into a program that uses input in XML format.
@woozong This is far from "absolute best", but I figured I'd throw together a few links. Hope you'll find something useful!
@woozong There were some studies that looked at code lifespans and found that most copilot written code was only in the code-base for an average of a few weeks. The implication was that the AI written stuff was buggy, inefficient or superfluous. But that these tools caused a huge degree of churn - constantly generating new stuff to replace lines that were only just recently committed.
I am annoyed because I can only find this report which is quite critical but not as brutal in it's assessment: https://kracekumar.com/post/ai_copilot_code_quality_paper/
WriterOfMinds (she)
woozong 🅅
Sir Garbagetruck
αxel simon ↙︎↙︎↙︎
d.rift
aburka 🫣
David Chisnall (*Now with 50% more sarcasm!*)
David Gerard
Nikolay Robotoev 🥞🎙️
Chewie
Dr. Tim Schatto-Eckrodt
CJ Moore
Tak!
Justin Derrick
LastOfThem
Stefan Bohacek
Hart of the Wud