@neil I feel like I'm being chased around the Internet by a slimy AI slop monster that's insidiously engulfing everything I use. It used to be I could just ignore the rubbish bits of the net I didn't like, but no longer.

I hate being forced to move just to avoid all this, not to mention the time involved in learning new tools. And who's to say the services/products I move to won't also succumb?

It's exhausting.

And it takes a huge chunk of enjoyment out of being a fan of tech and computers.

@gilester45 @neil that is so true! "If you don't like it, don't use it" is not working, because that crap is shoved into my face everywhere.
@JohannaMakesGames @gilester45 @neil same deal with always-online cars. I -do not want- a continuously-phoning-home car. But do I get that choice for any car newer than 10 years old? No I do not.
@saraislet @JohannaMakesGames @gilester45 @neil at least with a TV you don't have to connect it to WiFi if you have something else that does what you need to plug in to an HDMI port. But with a car? They've shoved a SIM card in there and it WILL connect and be damned to you if you don't like that

@http_error_418 @JohannaMakesGames @gilester45 @neil toy got me thinking about the cars and I realize there should be a "taking control of your automotive data" talk at #DEFCON's #CarHackingVillage if there hasn't been already.

In any case #EFF has a good article on the subject, and it may be as easy as removing a fuse.

Also, here Is a guide for different manufacturers

How to Figure Out What Your Car Knows About You (and Opt Out of Sharing When You Can)

Cars collect a lot of our personal data, and car companies disclose a lot of that data to third parties. Itโ€™s often unclear whatโ€™s being collected, and what's being shared and with whom. A recent New York Times article highlighted how data is shared by G.M. with insurance companies, sometimes...

Electronic Frontier Foundation
@http_error_418 @JohannaMakesGames @gilester45 @neil my VW has an "offline mode", but who knows how "offline" that really is. I would like to be able to replace the SIM and reliance on VW's (unreliable) servers with a SIM of my choice and a connection to my own server... Not only because of data protection concerns, but because I don't think manufacturers should be able to hold you to ransom with obscene subscription costs to use the "online" functions of the car you paid tens of thousands for.
@http_error_418 @JohannaMakesGames @gilester45 @neil in the same way as I can choose to replace my brake discs with either official (overpriced) parts or third party parts, why shouldn't I be able to use a third party for the car's online services rather than paying for the official overpriced service?

@steve @http_error_418 @JohannaMakesGames @gilester45 @neil
Oh this so much.

Mrs Sheddi has an electric VW. It has an API that our EV charger can connect to, so the charger can know how full the battery is and can automatically charge by the right amount. (There are good battery-life reasons not to simply "charge until full" every time.)

VW want ยฃ90 a year to give us access to our own car's info.

@sheddi @steve @JohannaMakesGames @gilester45 @neil waitwaitwait

So when it charges, the charger connects OUT TO THE INTERNET in order to know the state of the car it is charging, instead of having a way of directly querying the car through a physical connection you are ALREADY MAKING

@http_error_418 @steve @JohannaMakesGames @gilester45 @neil
Yes, that seems to be the case!

The charger and the car both connect (via their individual cellular data services) to their respective cloud servers, which then do whatever tango they've agreed.

All the while there's a physical (& electrical) connection between the two of them.

@http_error_418 @sheddi @JohannaMakesGames @gilester45 @neil for AC charging, comms is really simple - the supply signals (through simple PWM) how much current it can supply and the car draws up to that current. There is no communication the other way. For DC charging there is a proper digital network and the car tells the charger stuff like state of charge, and can present an X509 certificate to pay.
@http_error_418 @sheddi @JohannaMakesGames @gilester45 @neil the DC charging spec has been extended to support AC charging with proper bidirectional comms, so this problem will go away, but for now that newer standard has not been widely implemented. Smart tariffs like Intelligent Octopus Go need to know the state of charge so they can schedule charging dispatches for cheaper energy prices, so for now that is usually done by checking the SoC over the internet. It's horrible, but will be fixed.
@sheddi @http_error_418 @JohannaMakesGames @gilester45 @neil we have a first edition ID.3 and get the connected services for free. charging for those services was not mentioned at all when we bought the car, bur since they have started charging for some cars it is totally unclear whether they will suddenly impose a charge on us in the future for something that we always expected to be free.
@sheddi @http_error_418 @JohannaMakesGames @gilester45 @neil although IMHO, worse than that is the trend for car manufacturers to build in all the hardware and then charge a subscription to use the hardware that *you already own*. E.g. famously BMW charge people a subscription to use their seat heaters, and I think VW have started doing some of that crap too.
@sheddi @http_error_418 @JohannaMakesGames @gilester45 @neil (and I'm sure if your "subscription seat heaters" physically broke, you would be paying for the repair, so it isn't as if the subscription fee is sone kind of maintenance contract, it is just an excuse to rip off their own customers)

@steve @http_error_418 @JohannaMakesGames @gilester45 @neil well, guess what: @EUCommission made that illegal due to mandating #eCall and "#OTA #Updates"...

  • The only possible solution that won't void #RoadLegality is to literally not buy/own any Vehicle as ver EC Vehicle Class M1 (made after 2017)!

@kelpana @steve @http_error_418 @JohannaMakesGames @gilester45 @neil @EUCommission you never heard of #eCall or "mandatory #OTA Update Support"?

  • Oh and to add insult to injury, not only will your car's road legality be revoked if you remove eCall but if your #Car manufacturer or it's componentbmanufacturer decide so they can just EoL your car and functionality, including disabling functionality, and since that may result in a vehicle less secure than originally approved it'll also not be road legal anymore...

So welcome to the #BraveNewWorld where #CarManufacturers can just decide to make your car illegal and where legislators think "This is fine!" because apparently they don't give a shit about #ClimateChange and how much energy it takes to build #cars and their components!

@steve you're not alone with this. Do you know about https://docs.openvehicles.com/ already?

@http_error_418 @JohannaMakesGames @gilester45 @neil

Open Vehicles Monitoring System โ€” Open Vehicles documentation

@bekopharm @http_error_418 @JohannaMakesGames @gilester45 @neil worth noting that if anything pokes at the OBD II port while my car is locked, it will set off the alarm. So there is a limit to what you can retrofit to replicate the official functions (VW ID.3 1st). I believe that later editions of the car are even more locked down.
@steve yes, this trend is horrible. I don't like it at all. Guess we'll need our own "John Deere" rights to repair campaign.
@bekopharm to be clear: stopping random devices from meddling in a locked car is probably good security, but it does rather bugger up people who have a legitimate reason to do so.
@bekopharm to be honest, I do wonder why they went down the "set off the alarm" route instead of just disconnecting the whole port when locked.

@steve dabbling in car hacking I'm very biased on this ๐Ÿคท

Likeโ€ฆ asking customers twice a year for 90 bucks to re-learn TPMS sensors via CAN - a job of 5 minutes after changing tyres - is imho highly immoral. Yes this is a direct jab at Renault.

@bekopharm Is this not something that the tyre shop can do for you as part of changing the tyres?

But I'll agree that all main dealers are pretty crap when it comes to charging ยฃ150 for "diagnostics", where "diagnostics" means 5 minutes plugging in to the OBD II port and reading codes, which you could do yourself with a ยฃ20 device.

@bekopharm I thought that OBD II was introduced because regulators saw that small garages being unable to work on cars (due to not having access to the proprietary systems that main dealers had) was a Bad Thingโ„ข. So I'm surprised that we're now seeing various functions being locked away from generic OBD II dongles again - I would have thought that would not be allowed by the regulations that required OBD II in the first place!

@steve error codes yes. _Setting_ anything is specific though and manufacturers tend to abuse this and make it a secret so unaffiliated shops have to purchase hardware explicit from that manufacturer. This is especially true when it comes to e.g. TPMS.

And this hardware is expensive, of course. Not because it's complicated and went to new highs of technical engineering - it's simply an artificial monopoly.

Any gorram smartphone can issue ODB commands via serial o0

@steve it's what every official dealer is supposed to charge by list.

Yes a decent tyre dealer will just ask for a donation to the coffee fund. Been there :)

How to kill CarNet (also, what's inside the box and buttons.)

I posted this on Vortex, but figured ya'll may want it here too. --- EDIT: As several people have added to this thread, this is NOT the proper way to take apart your interior trim pieces. The "pull on it" method works, but will break some of the plastic retaining tabs on the AC vent trim and...

GOLFMK7 - VW GTI MKVII Forum / VW Golf R Forum / VW Golf MKVII Forum
@JohannaMakesGames @gilester45 @neil as I get older, I find the never ending treadmill of "spend your time learning whole new tech just so you can carry on doing the same stuff" exhausting. I want to have cool new tech to do cool new things, but increasingly I'm finding tech that works being replaced with tech that does the same thing (but often worse), and that treadmill means I never get time to try the "cool new things". Maybe I'm just getting old and need a child to set up my VCR for me...