"I am starting a petition to no longer refer to AI "art" as AI art but instead as Computer-Rendered Artificial Pictures (CRAP).

Pass it on."

@mthie i like. will adopt that immediatly ;)
@mthie You heard of CAD and CRD, now be ready for CRAP!
@mthie Maybe we can run a dual process & include the general term to replace "AI" - I suggest "Automated Superfast Statistics", or ASS.
UPDATED: Let’s forget the term AI. Let’s call them Systematic Approaches to Learning Algorithms and Machine Inferences (SALAMI). – Quinta’s weblog

@AAMfP @jwcph @quinta @mthie Or let's call them "bullshit generators" as RMS does
@mthie I can definitely get on-board with this idea... CRAP it is, then 😉

@mthie 10/10

We need one for ai music too...how about Synthetic Human-Independent Tunes (SHIT)

@mthie We've been referring to it as a Plagiarising Insidious Synthesis System (PISS)

@Anomnomnomaly
Matches the polish right wing party.

That's just an oversight, isn't it? Or is it?

@mthie

@mthie This is some straight up Richard Stallman type stuff and I'm all for it, lol.

@mthie

AI Art: How can it be expressive if it's not human?

But I suppose, like photography, the expressive bit can come from the selection (which generated image the artist chooses to showcase?) - and from the instruction given to the agent.

It leaves out the ritual and the joy of the process that can only come from making it by hand.

In a world teeming with #AI images, the rare thing, the valued thing, will be the art made by the hand and conceived by the mind of a human being.

@lymphomation @mthie except a person points a camera, adjusts the settings, clicks the shutter, processes (darkroom or lightroom/digital equivalent) and post-processes. They were in a place to capture it.

AI has chewed up every human-produced work on the Internet. It spits out a collage of that theft when someone asks it to.
There is a gulf of difference, and zero skill in the latter.

Indeed I'd say it's just a lack of imagination that leads prompt jockeys to think they're doing something.

@noodlemaz @mthie

I generally agree with all of the issues cited. I don't see the need to demonize people who engage in it ... but I agree that it's not art - it's not expressive, it's too easy - all of that.

@lymphomation @mthie it's using the mass theft for personal gain or, worse, brief amusement. I think there's a big issue with that.

@mthie

More on the topic of #AI as #art - just my take: Are #AI-generated Images Works of Art?
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1wCAgmx3Csqx9C25HD0C_b66HIAOJxQEKuEbMQpYSZew/edit?usp=sharing

Art

DIARY of My ART By Karl Schwartz For inquires: [email protected] "Every good painter paints what he is" - Jackson Pollock Recently added Topics: Biosketch | Professor Gelber’s on my Student work in the MFA program at Brooklyn College Drawing has been my life-long obsession - from life but ...

Google Docs
@mthie I'd even use the hashtag #CRAP for this from now on.
@mthie the term "slop" is gaining traction and I like that.
@carbonara @mthie I use 'slop' a lot, but wondering about 'garbaige', to match 'aidiots' for the people who generate it.

@mthie Also holds just fine for Copilot and such:

Computer Rendered Artificial Programs

@mthie this description seems broad enough to apply to vast amounts of human-created computer art, though. 3d art, algorithmic art, etc. i think more specificity is needed

@mthie

AI= artificial ignorance.

@mthie Rendered is too broad and too generous.

How about regurgitated?

@mthie AI slop has caught on pretty well.
@mthie This. Love it. Even changed my Mastodon filter title to CRAP.
@mthie halfway there, should add based on stolen stuff . So boss-crap
@mthie I call it "EI" which sounds close enough. It stands for "Excitable Intern" which is how a lot of modern LLMs act.. :)
@mthie I’m sure Ai Weiwei approves of this message.

@mthie
I think I'll stick with Sparkling Art Theft.

CRAP is pretty accurate, tho.

@mthie YES!

I also petition that LLM AI stuff no longer be called "artificial intelligence" but "Plagiarism Software", for that is what it is.

Not as neat an acronym, tho 😄

@mthie

Or maybe Computer-Rendered Artificial Pictures For Egregiously Stupid Tossers (CRAPFEST)?

@mthie @cadusilva

Nice acronym, but CGI and procedural art are also rendered by computerers

@mthie
Let me just say, "Boy, Howdy!"
Remember that the operative and defining word in the phrase "Artificial Intelligence" is "artificial." That's the word that puts the "a" in CRAP. 👍 😉
@mthie *Thank you, Helen Ault. Consider that petition signed.
@mthie Totally agree here!
@mthie Surely CRAP deserves to be a hashtag? #CRAP
@mthie
There is nothing "intelligent" whatsoever in "AI" anyway.
It's simply an Analysis>Search>Synthesis (or "ASS") algorithm built on statistical probability.
@mthie I love this so much.

@mthie I find myself physically repulsed, nauseated even any time I am unfortunate enough to come across a piece of CRAP.

It most certainly is not art, and not appealing in any aesthetic sense whatsoever!

@mthie like vegan meat is no meat or wegan milk is no milk. All for it
@mthie CRAP 2.0. Vista Pro was great!
@mthie I also refuse to write 'that' in capitals. It's ai if I have to refer to it.