Siri, show me enshittification
Siri, show me enshittification
Plex reneged on “remote people can stream for free as long as the server owner has a [paid] Plex Pass" and it’s now “remote people _also_ need to have a Plex Pass or a $2/mo / $20/yr sub"
Do not dig it.
(Or, I'm grossly misunderstanding things. Which would be great! But if so, this clause at the top is VERY unclear)
@domserio I don't _think_ that's true anymore.
Happy to be wrong though.
I have a lifetime plex pass. My brother streams from my server and got an email (also confusingly written) that confirms he can continue streaming free from my server.
So good news and a reason to be happy to be wrong.
But on the other side of the ledger, the new iPhone app is a huge footgun.
Way less performant. Many things I previously streamed at full quality now stutter, never play, or cause crashes, and only work reasonably well at 720p. And that’s aside from all the bits and pieces of functionality that were stripped out…
@caseyliss According to the email I got from Plex:
"As a server owner, if you elect to upgrade to a Plex Pass, anyone with access to your server can continue streaming your server content remotely as part of your subscription benefits."
So, it seems like people don't need Plex Pass, only the person serving the content.
@caseyliss If you’ve not looked at Jellyfin, you might want to check it out. It does everything that Plex does, it's free and open source, you can stream to any device you like, there are all kinds of clients and an official app for iOS and iPadOS, and it pretty much works exactly the same way Plex does, right down to the file naming conventions.
I run mine on a Mac Mini and I have more problems with the Mac than I ever do with Jellyfin.
@caseyliss This is one of those crappy sarcastic reply posts. And for that I’m sorry, but anyway:
If I understood Marco and John correctly last week, it’s not enshitification if you can afford it. Enshitification is something for the poors. Otherwise it’s just “the price” and “market fit”.
@caseyliss I think the KEY discussion should always be “what costs money” — I don’t mean you, I mean them
Instead of talking back and forth about the contract and promises made, or the vague and express meanings in the communication …
We should never (pretend to) be surprised about enpoopification if something was never cheap or free to provide in the first place
So — rather than talk about the Plex Pass: Who is this video data routing through? Is there much centralisation or is it 99% peer-to-peer?
The closer that this product resembles BitTorrent with a glossy label, the better the chance of meeting expectations that it can operate like BitTorrent
@caseyliss yay 🙌 good then
@caseyliss it is very unclearly written, but the plans page says the following for the remote pass ”effective option to stream your media—or libraries of friends and family who don’t have Plex Pass—from anywhere”. So if the server owner has Plex pass you’re good?
If that is the case I think it’s better than before where you needed Plex pass to use the mobile or TV apps.
@caseyliss I'm...like 99% sure you're wrong on this. The owner having Plex Pass should suffice.
For users who have an active Plex Pass subscription, remote playback will continue to be available to you without interruption from any Plex Media Server, after these changes go into effect. When running your own Plex Media Server as a subscriber, other users to whom you have granted access can also stream from the server (whether local or remote), without ANY additional charge—not even a mobile activation fee. More on that later in this update.@tomjacob Emby no
Jellyfin yes
Infuse yes
I was unimpressed with both at the time, and AFAIK none of them allow for easy remote streaming to people that are not me.
@caseyliss Yeah, I got an email about that earlier. I don't use remote access to Plex that often. I hadn't purchased Plex Pass, and I'm not sure I will be purchasing it.
I may just go with the "VPN to my computer, copy the files I want, and then AirPlay, or just plug into a TV" instead of using Plex.
I get that there needs to be a cost if you are using their servers for transcoding and/or transport, but if it's only a connection service, it should be VERY low cost, or free.
@caseyliss asking plain money for services isn’t enshitification, it’s the opposite.
Sucks though.