@futurebird This seems like an extremely NYC question.
Having spent a little time upstate around the Finger Lakes (and other similarly small-village places).
I have lived in a very small town. But I've never seen anything I'd call a "village"
@futurebird I may have different boundaries on the concept.
But I'm not sure what else to call places with a populations of a couple of hundred or less.
I'm in shock I thought it was just people trying to be needlessly cute.
A bit kitsch, but … A for effort?
https://leavenworth.org/the-bavarian-village-of-leavenworth/
@futurebird Interesting. As someone who grew up in the UK but moved to Australia almost 20 years ago I noticed that this is one of the differences between British English and Australian English, too.
In the UK any settlement below a certain size would be called a village, or in extreme cases maybe even a hamlet.
In Australian every settlement smaller than a city is a town unless it consists of only 3 or 4 buildings, in which case it might be called a locality instead. When the word "village" is used in Australia it's usually as part of the name of a strip mall in a tourist destination.
@futurebird
Damascus, Ohio, population 418.
Okay seriously, one of the things I learned doing field work in rural Scotland is that "village" means a small collection of shops. Someone who lives in a small town may say "I'm going down to the village to do some shopping."
Because it's in my mind because of the news, I'm thinking of "downtown" Chimney Rock, NC, which was obliterated by Helene. In the UK that'd have been called a village.
Speaking of "downtown" . . .
Near as I can tell "downtown" is a generalized Manhattanism, which is kind of funny. Like this place on the side of US 64 deep in a river gorge in the southern Appalachians is, from what I can tell, adopting a name given to one of the densest areas of the US . . . a portion of which is locally known as "the village."
@futurebird plenty of them up here in Northern New England.
Generally a secondary smaller “town center” within a larger town, but culturally distinct. Often just a village green, general store, church, and maybe a restaurant, sometimes a bit more.
@futurebird i've not met too many cities except for nyc either
america doesn't like these things. possibly never has
I live in New England, in a small town that is made up of five distinct, legally-designated villages. The entire town is around 2,000 people. Oh and one half of one village is in one town and the other half is in the neighboring town.
@futurebird I think of them as small shopping centers with “Village” in the name.
I village in the other sense suggests to me a place that doesn’t have police and was primarily built before modern construction standards.