Mastodon tackles the problem of β€˜reply guys’ with its latest feature: https://techcrunch.com/2023/11/22/mastodon-tackles-the-problem-of-reply-guys-with-its-latest-feature/
Mastodon tackles the problem of 'reply guys' with its latest feature | TechCrunch

Mastodon's latest update is tackling a problem Twitter users know all too well: the scourge of the "reply guys." A colloquial term for the men who

TechCrunch
@Sarahp big difference from Twitter, who would monetise the Reply Guys and then force them into your feed, then if you complain, the website owner will sue you.
@Sarahp Jesus, that is not going to help.
@Rhube @Sarahp Thanks for being the reply *checks bio* agender so I don’t have to be the reply guy, but exactly this. All of this.
@Rhube @Sarahp except that from the article, there is evidence that small nudges like this can help in some cases. Clearly not claiming to be a panacea.
@Sarahp Nice to see they are attempting to fix the problem.
@brian
I do hope this spreads into other clients. Timely behavior nudges are useful. It's a social UI contract. Not something an open network or protocol itself can enforce.
@Sarahp
@Sarahp oooh nice idea! I like it. Was boosted by @Lazarou into my timeline and now boosted further πŸ™‚
@jon @Sarahp @Lazarou What's happening? I get a "TechCrunch, are part of the Yahoo family of brands" #doorslam on that link.
@mjr @jon @Sarahp @Lazarou I get a connection closed πŸ”’πŸ€·πŸ»β€β™‚οΈ
@mjr @jon @Lazarou it’s something yahoo needs to fix. Out of my hands
@Sarahp @jon @Lazarou perhaps you could mention how they're trying to fix it, for those of us not allowed in? I see nothing relevant on joinmastodon.org - do you feel the headline is accurate?
@Sarahp
Isn’t just ignoring replies a good strategy? It seems that would take away their power. I ignore the occasional reply that seems intent on goading me into an argument. Sometimes it takes substantial willpower but it’s better than the slippery slope of trying to get in β€œthe last word”.

@steve_zeke @Sarahp So your solution is... no solution? If "just ignore them" worked, then we wouldn't be having this conversation.

Open yourself up to some empathy and realize that it's not a viable strategy for everyone, especially when it's constant and endemic to social media platforms. "Reply guys" are a problem for any community that aims to be welcoming to women (or anyone else).

@danielwaechter @steve_zeke @Sarahp the solution is people act more like adults rather than put in tools that create unpleasantness and elitism that will put people off of the site entirely

Muting and blocking is always an option when you do not want to have discussions with somebody and it always will be.

Everyone has self control, yet what's staggering is the amount of people pretending we don't.

@steve_zeke @Sarahp Ignoring replies is an excellent strategy. Many reply guys are narcissists. Letting them have the last word is a great way of ending a conversation that for them is only a mechanism for stroking their ego at your expense.

I really had my eyes opened by Doctor Ramani's videos. Now I waste far less time on conversations that can never be productive.

https://youtu.be/824DpnZpVMk?si=0CLAtXVRGaCiWgj0

TOP 5 hacks for surviving a narcissist

YouTube
@Sarahp
This sounds like a good start. I haven't had this problem (yet) on Mastodon, but am regularly getting guys telling me they like my style, smile whatever... and would I please follow them.

@Sarahp

I follow #Mastodon quite closely on #Github

That said, on mastodon - mastodon-android I can find no mention of this in either Issues (open or closed) or Pull Requests (open or closed) using any search modifiers I can quickly think of - given the time I'm willing to waste looking

And there don't seem to be any mastodon-android Discussions

Wonder if this is another feature that @Gargron has decided on without any extensive input

Here, have a look: https://github.com/mastodon/mastodon-android/issues

GitHub - mastodon/mastodon-android: Official Android app for Mastodon

Official Android app for Mastodon. Contribute to mastodon/mastodon-android development by creating an account on GitHub.

GitHub

@Sarahp

Also, from elsewhere, earlier:

Oh good!

The #TwitterNanny comes to #Mastodon

Been wondering how long it was going to take before @Gargron got around to doing something important

"Remember the human behind the screen"

Always

Always

@Sarahp Great start!  
Hopefully we get to see more small improvement towards something akin to a #QualityFilter which I'm sure content creators with large followings will benefit from.
@Sarahp I remember when XKCD had the bright idea to read the comment back to the poster before posting it on youtube, in order to tackle all the bullshit there. And Google actually implemented it. And it did nothing. πŸ™‚
@Sarahp Just updated the mastodon app, so I'm replyguying to see if there's any difference...
@Sarahp No observable difference. The client hasn't prompted anything before posting my (guy) reply. (version 2.2.1)
@rubinjoni @Sarahp I believe the most current version is 2.2.3, and a side note, the new feature was presented when I replied here.
@rubinjoni it’s only on android right now fwiw. ios soon
@Sarahp @Gargron seems like a convention that mastodon should support as a server side attribute all clients could use
@Sarahp Does it involve a mild electric shock and if not why not?
@Sarahp it already worked for this post for me :-)
@Sarahp I love the 3 months old post feature. I suck at looking at dates and tend to make this mistake all the time β™₯
@fourlastor @Sarahp : how is it a mistake to reply to something "old" ? If your reply is relevant to the topic then I see it as an opportunity to carry the conversation further. If it took 4 months for a toot to travel to you, why shut down or at least discourage interacting with it ?
@ladyteruki @Sarahp a mistake as in, I rarely notice it's old, and am convinced it happened today until @seb makes me notice otherwise
@Sarahp males get "reply guys" too. problem not limited to females. plus the gender on both sides is irrelevent
@Sarahp Heck yeah, because what I need more of with my online experience is pop-ups that I need to click away before I can do something πŸ₯³
@Sarahp Is Mastodon a company or an org? ...
@AdamBishop @Sarahp non-profit LLC
@Sarahp Thanks! πŸ™Hmm, so a bit of both? ... πŸ€” ... I guess, to my ear, calling it a non-profit makes it sound like an org, or a kind of foundation or charity, that makes do with the money it receives, and calling it a company makes it sound more like Twitter or Facebook, or a rival to Bluesky, that continually has to make money to survive .. πŸ€”
@Sarahp Reply Guys sounds like a band name. I think we can all guess what their songs would be about.
@Sarahp too many people replying on Mastadon? Are we sure this is a thing?
@Sarahp this is great news. πŸ‘πŸΌπŸ‘πŸΌπŸ‘πŸΌπŸ‘πŸΌπŸ‘πŸΌ Bravo @MastodonEngineering