It's the 100th Anniversary of the "VAR!" plate, when humanity first had physical proof to understand the scale of the Universe. Happy VARDay, everyone!
#Astronomy #Astrodon #HistoryOfScience #Science #Telescopes #MtWilson #VARDay

What's the VAR! plate, you ask? (I mean, I assume a few of you followed me because I'm an astronomer, right?)

So, did you ever see the #FatherTed clip about cows -- these ones are small, those are far away? Space is pretty much like that. In this case, though, the cow was the Andromeda Nebula. Was it small, but close to us? Or huge and really far away? If the Universe was just the Milky Way, it had to be the former. If the latter? Then the Universe is a whole lot bigger!

Part of the issue is that one guy -- Mt. Wilson astronomer Van Maanen -- claimed he saw galaxies rotating. For such rotation to be seen on human time scales, these would have to be small -- or the orbits would be faster than the speed of light!

Astronomers will tell you that, at this time, there was a great debate -- no, a The Great Debate -- between two leading scholars at the Smithsonian Natural History Museum. This debate ignited public interest and set the stage for what was to come.

(These astronomers are probably *vastly* overselling how important this debate was. People with niche hobbies tend to do that with minor events.)

Anyway, up on Mt. Wilson a chap by the name of Hubble was looking at our neighbor, the Andromeda galaxy. Comparing images taken at different times, he was looking for "novae" -- new stars (now recognized as various transient phenomena, including thermonuclear burning on white dwarfs). On the top right of the Oct 6th plate, he found one, and marked it with an "N". But, upon further inspection, it had already been there -- it just brightened. This wasn't new, it was varying!

There's this relation -- now called the Leavitt Law -- that for stars that have periodic variations (bright, faint, bright, faint), you can connect how long it takes to complete a cycle with how *intrinsically* luminous it is.

If you know the period, you know how bright it is. Compare that to how bright it appears, and you know a star's distance. So, by finding a variable star in Andromeda, Hubble had found a way to directly measure its distance -- and to solve the Great Debate!

I'd like to think that Hubble realized this was a variable, did the math in his head, and could barely write "VAR!" with how excited he was, before running out into the Pasadena afternoon crying "EUREKA!"

This photo is the moment the scale of the Universe changed, from thousands of light years to a bare minimum of millions.

100 years ago we went from a small house among many in a vast country to a tiny pebble of sand in an incomprehensible ocean.

Anyway, the VAR plate is a rare scientific artifact, capturing not just the data that led to the discovery but the human response. It isn't just Alexander Fleming's petri dish of mold, it's also the hole he punched in the wall in his excitement.
On a personal note, I've been fortunate enough to see it in person twice now; it's almost always stored in a secret location, and one of a handful of replicas are displayed for large, public events where it might get damaged. But working where Hubble worked had its perks!

Also, if you're thinking "Hey, I followed you because you're an astronomer, why don't you post more astronomy things!"

--> @ThomasConnor

@thomasconnor thanks for bringing this story back to life! I finished “The Glass Universe” some time ago, it’s a great first contact with Leavitt’s work 😊
@Emiliagnathus We've got an exhibition right now at the observatory (I'm at Harvard now) on the women: "Her Luminous Distance" https://library.cfa.harvard.edu/plate-stacks/exhibitions/her-luminous-distance
Her Luminous Distance

@thomasconnor oh wow, such a fascinating exhibition! I have no chance to see it unfortunately but I hope I will make it to the Wolbach Library and see the plates one day ❤️

@thomasconnor

It's only 100 yrs since that discovery. 100 yrs. (~3 generations), since we know, that we are living in an island galaxy - surrounded by billions of such galaxies.

The human race exists for at least 300.000 yrs. (~100.000 generations).

Not the only hint showing us, that we live in a very special time period...

Another hint in the grafic below!

@thomasconnor Does that star have a name? Can it be seen with midrange amateur equipment, like 5-8" telescopes? What is its period? Might make for a fun #AmateurAstronomy project. #AAVSO

@hendric It's "V1" -- and we've gone back to look at it, since. Hubble used the 100 inch Hooker telescope, albeit with a photographic plate instead of modern CCDs. My wholly off-the-cuff guess would be you'd need something a little bigger than that, all the same.

But there have been follow on projects: https://hubblesite.org/contents/news-releases/2011/news-2011-15.html

@thomasconnor Looks like I just barely missed it in my 80mm f/5 with 30 minutes the last time I did an Andromeda picture a few years ago. https://hendric.smugmug.com/Hobbies/Astronomy/20201221-Dark-Skies-at-Bastrop/
I'm sure it's well within the mid-range of #AmateurAstronomy if a schmuck like me almost got it. I've since upgraded to a much better telescope and mount. I'll give it a try soon and see what I can get!
20201221 Dark Skies at Bastrop - hendric

Pictures taken under dark skies in Bastrop, TX

@hendric You might have also caught it in a faint period. Either, way, clear skies and good luck! It's wild what modern amateur scopes can do!
@thomasconnor Great point! I did find an article from a few years ago discussing capturing it with a 350mm high end telescope. I think my 90mm F/6 should be able to capture it though. It has much better focus and is apochromatic vs my ST80 F/5 "colors lol" old scope.
@thomasconnor I dunno, the zoom image on this is just baffling to me, it doesn't look like the right FoV at all. I didn't find any contact info for the author to ask for clarification on which star is V1. https://www.astronomy.com/science/the-star-that-changed-the-cosmos-m31-v1/ #astrodon #AmateurAstronomy
The star that changed the cosmos: M31-V1

An astroimager follows in Edwin Hubble’s footsteps to prove the utter vastness of our universe using a single star.

Astronomy Magazine
@hendric @thomasconnor Based on what I just learned reading up on this, the variable star that Hubble discovered seems to be in the top right of the plate, not in the area that you boxed. That is why the N in the top right is crossed out and VAR is scribbled down there.
@aetios @thomasconnor Dang, good catch! I'll have to look closer up there to tell *which* star is marked var.
@aetios @thomasconnor Looking closer at the Astronomy article, it has a fuller view of the plate than even Carnegie has on their website. https://obs.carnegiescience.edu/PAST/m31var
Hubble's Famous M31 VAR! plate

@aetios @thomasconnor Well it isn't as pretty as the other FoV, but I can align my crap image with the one from the article now. This image from a Hubble article points out the variable star and has yet another image of the plate with more detail visible. I think the bottom star in the faint triangle is V1. Looks like I didn't get it, but maybe with the better equipment I'll have a chance.
https://hubblesite.org/contents/media/images/2011/15/2851-Image.html?news=true
Thanks @aetios for the clarification on the location!
@aetios @thomasconnor I got it last night after the Annular Eclipse! Now I'm pretty happy! 90mm @ 540mm! 11x180s
#AmateurAstronomy #astrophotography