If you were searching for a new church community, what are the top 3 things that you would be looking for?

@timamor
I have never met a church that encourages childless people, all the infertility stories end with "and then Jesus gave us a child because he loves us."

Which implies no child = no use to this church, and Jesus doesn't love you either. Got that message loud and clear many times over.

@BritishKoalaTea ouch! I’m so very sorry!

Churches have responded to the idolatry of sexual satisfaction with the idolatry of family, marriage, (& sexual satisfaction within those boundaries).

The way of Jesus has always had a special place for those who have no other family or children etc.

I lament that we’ve lost that.

@BritishKoalaTea @timamor oof, Alison, that is so heartbreaking. I am so sorry. I wish the Church was better in so many ways and particularly in this way.
@timamor I’m biased, but one that isn’t tied to not will be tied to the three B’s: buildings, butts, and budgets
@timamor
Good welcome on first visit.
Good teaching on every visit.
Good leadership with clear vision.
@timamor As a pastor who may someday be looking for a job with a new congregation:
1. Welcoming of all, with the participation in the congregation visibly matching the community they are in
2. Congregation actively discipling one another, learning how the Triune God is calling them into the world
3. Knowing that change is a constant and the attempt to hold to some imaginary past, present, or future is fraught with unneeded loss. @theology

@timamor

1. Excellent stage performances
2. Great children's ministry
3. Lots of programs specialized for me personally

Joking! 🙃

@timamor
1. Biblical teaching. If there's no reading, if the Word is an afterthought, or if sin is a dirty word, I'm out. If we can't talk about sin, then we can't talk about why Jesus died. It's not the personal power hour, it's the celebration of His resurrection.

2. Welcoming humanity. My wife and I were looking into church options a while back and at some of them we were stared at rather than welcomed.

3. Separation of Church and State. A local pastor has used the term "woke" unironically in a sermon from the pulpit, complaining about the "woke agenda." I can't be guided by someone so misguided. It's one thing to have an opinion, but to borrow a right-wing slur (as it's being used in that context) to drive a point is a pretty big line.

@timamor
1. Expository Bible teaching. Non-negotiable. Teach what God says in the text. If it ain't expository, it ain't preaching.

2. Understands the complexity of sin and evil. Understands that people suffer because of sins they didn't commit and doesn't treat that suffering as something to repent of. Call it "trauma-informed".

3. Spiritual friendship. Members care for each other practically *and* have gospel-flavored conversations freely.

@timamor I thought of a fourth one that might actually be a tie for third.

Poor people can be full members. Discipleship isn't paywalled. No studies they're excluded from because they can't afford the book, and no afterthought announcements ("if you can't afford the book, come see us"). Doesn't rely on expensive outside events for spiritual growth.

(Abuse prevention and response is the zeroth item on my list, for the record. I'm not shopping for it; I'm just demanding it.)

@WordyAnchorite @timamor Rebecca, when you find a church, let me know. I've never been a good church shopper - the emotional burden of trying to choose a pile of people to do life with is overwhelming - but now I'm just plain afraid to walk in the door because of the many reasons I'd have to walk out. 😕
@JulieB *hugs or preferred equivalent*
@WordyAnchorite @timamor @JulieB wait, are you local to us too, Rebecca? If so, I’m also interested if you find a good church. :) we have many of the same things on our church shopping list, including the zero abuse tolerance.
@jfslicer @WordyAnchorite @timamor I was being a bit mouthy . . . like at this point I'd move. My apologies for getting your hopes up, James!
@timamor @JulieB @WordyAnchorite no worries. Sometimes I think it’s be easier to start a new church for all us in this camp. Like it shouldn’t be hard to find a church that cares well for the abused.
@jfslicer @timamor @WordyAnchorite Exactly. I see home churches in our future . . . and in our first century past. I see no reason, personally, for more than 20 people. Much bigger and you have to get organized and paid and hierarchy etc. Just my opinion. Not even really calling it Biblical for sure. 🤷‍♀️
@timamor @WordyAnchorite @JulieB in the book Letters to the Church, Francis Chan argues for house church model. He moved to doing something like that in the San Francisco Bay Area. There is still leadership above the house churches, which I think is good as it gives you someone to go to if your leader is being inappropriate.
@jfslicer @timamor @WordyAnchorite Yes! I know I'm not far off but wanted to assert gently since I'm sipping coffee in my garden, deadheading old buds and taking pics! Not exactly in a position to make any kind of stand if someone gets fussy at me! 😉 I am now getting up from the boulder and finishing my tasks. Have a good day all! 🥰

@jfslicer @timamor @JulieB I don't think the size of the congregation matters as much as the power distance. There are small groups and house churches that are little cults and bigger gatherings that are healthy.

I think it is helpful to have a particular group of people who are your "cell", the first friends you call, the people you're closest to. But as a single adult, I've experienced both care and exclusion under that model.

Basically, I'm size agnostic.

@WordyAnchorite @jfslicer @timamor @JulieB We are in the process of leaving our home congregation of over 20 years due to "progressive" teaching. Roughly 180 members in the center of Houston, everyone knows everyone. It caters to the 20 or so millionaire members to the exclusion of the other 90% and is averse to change. The leadership team is fabulously wealthy and largely agnostic.
The church to which we are moving is 17 miles closer, preaches the Bible as written, has 3500 members, and leadership spams the race and wealth gamut.
I feel more at home in the midst of a massive crowd than in the intimate setting of my previous congregation. As Rebecca suggests, they offer resources from the congregational budget rather than force people to buy stuff we can't afford.
@StoneKamino @WordyAnchorite @jfslicer @timamor At work. So much to say but it will have to wait. 😔
@StoneKamino @WordyAnchorite @jfslicer @timamor Yesterday was a never-ender. My apologies for the drama of 'so much to say'. I did not recognize the thread into which Pizza spoke - I just read about leaving a church and all the feels came up but I knew I could not afford to feel them because the day I knew I was about to have. All of that to say, Pizza, I am happy for the change you're making and the fit it already is and also sad about the losses that will also occur as you switch families.
@JulieB @WordyAnchorite @jfslicer @timamor thank you Julie, it's tough on all of us. But this is a place I feel comfortable to open up to the men's group - lay it all out. AA, family problems, spiritual struggles...and they truly care.
@StoneKamino ", they offer resources from the congregational budget rather than force people to buy stuff we can't afford." i'm intrigued by this comment, can you elaborate please? @WordyAnchorite @jfslicer @timamor @JulieB
@cleopas @WordyAnchorite @jfslicer @timamor @JulieB
In her post, @WordyAnchorite mentioned that some churches (like my previous congregation) hosted studies where members had to purchase books or study guides. Little known fact, if you said, "I can't afford it," they would provide one for you.
My new congregation spares the embarrassment. They hand out the resources to those attending the class without requiring repayment.
@cleopas @timamor @JulieB @WordyAnchorite @StoneKamino when I ran a Bible study, I told them it was a suggested donation of x and to find me later if they wanted to pay. I didn’t want anyone paying in front of the group.

@jfslicer @cleopas @timamor @JulieB @StoneKamino I like this approach better than "tell me if you can't pay". I will say, though, that "suggested donation" language is still rough on me when I can't afford it; I still fear being quietly judged, or like I have to double check that it's really okay, and sometimes that's too much to face, so I just sit it out.

I'd feel better about something like "Please sign up if you're interested so we know how many copies/tickets we need to get. If you'd like to help us cover the costs, see Jane." That makes it clearer that there's not an expectation of payment.

@JulieB @WordyAnchorite @timamor @StoneKamino @cleopas we also said they didn’t have to pay. I get it it, it’s rough when you don’t have the money, but we never thought twice about it if someone paid less or couldn’t pay at all.

@jfslicer @JulieB @timamor @StoneKamino @cleopas Right, it's less about what's in *your* head than what's going on in the *hearer's* head. People can carry a lot of shame that you didn't put there. Part of carrying one another's burdens, I think.

Similarly, a Chinese student and convert told me that one barrier to Chinese people accepting an invitation to attend church is that they think they have to pay to attend. He explains to people right up front that the offering plate is for members who choose to give, not an admission fee. My home church tradition explains that every week, too, to take that burden off. It's not that anyone *told* them that putting money in the plate was expected (like the "suggested donation" box at the entrance to Publix museums). It's just that people bring preconceptions and prior experiences with them to church.

@jfslicer @timamor @JulieB Not unless "local" is "in the Caribbean" 😁
@WordyAnchorite @timamor @JulieB That's not local, but that seems like a great place to move to for a healthy church :P
@JulieB @WordyAnchorite @timamor trying to find a new church is very much like dating. You walk in thinking “Is this the one?”
@LauraJG @JulieB @timamor Ugh, that's a good comparison for all the worst reasons 😭
@timamor my #1 would be a mask required service, offering a social distancing area. I’m immune compromised. Being in a crowd, people all around me singing with gusto, unknowingly spewing their spit all around is a scenario my rheumatologist does not recommend. So, if I attend, it’s online.

@timamor
1. A rainbow flag. That pretty quickly lets me know most of what I need to know. A rainbow flag (without equivocating) usually comes with other good things.

2. I like a mix of old and new songs and theology that doesn't make me cringe.

3. At this point in running into problems with more inclusive churches meeting while the church I pastor is already meeting, so a Saturday or Sunday night service would be really cool.

But I'm probably a minority there.

@timamor I am looking for a new church and the top 3 things I’m looking for are:

1) A commitment to Scripture: preaching the word, unpacking it, living it, and seeking to grow.

2) A church that is racially diverse (not segregated). My area is racially diverse and my church should match that.

3) A place my wife, who has legit covid concerns, would be safe.

@timamor I’m also trying to find a place where there’s accountability for the pastoral team. I don’t want to be in a place where they can spiritually, emotionally, or physically abuse others and get away with it.
@jfslicer @timamor *jumps up and down on the little star for this one*
@timamor
1) a bible study group which will help me grow and make friends.
2) Somewhere to worship.
3) Somewhere to Serve
(having read other responses, I don't seem very discerning 😄

@timamor I notice a few things nobody has mentioned.

  • A big fancy building
  • A band or sound system
  • lots of people
  • @timamor
    0. Does not abuse people in any way, nor turn a blind eye to abuse (h/t @WordyAnchorite )

    1. Is not supporting an ongoing attempt by a former head of state to de-legitimize democratic and legal processes in order to be restored to power.

    2. Is not perpetrating and perpetuating racial injustice, and preventing any restoration.

    3. Is not noticeably more wicked than the surrounding culture.

    (I struggled with 3, b/c 0-2 probably disqualify all but one or maybe two churches in my city.)